Top of the Batch: Interviews and the Match

  title={Top of the Batch: Interviews and the Match},
  author={Federico Echenique and Ruy Gonzalez and Alistair J. Wilson and Leeat Yariv},
  journal={ERN: Market Structure (Topic)},
Most doctors in the NRMP are matched to one of their most-preferred internship programs. Since various surveys indicate similarities across doctors' preferences, this suggests a puzzle. How can nearly everyone get a position in a highly-desirable program when positions in each program are scarce? We provide one possible explanation for this puzzle. We show that the patterns observed in the NRMP data may be an artifact of the interview process that precedes the match. Our analysis highlights the… Expand
Interview Hoarding
If doctors are willing to accept more interviews but the hospitals do not increase the number of interviews they offer, no doctor will be better off and potentially many doctors will be harmed. Expand
How to Build an Institution
How should institutions be designed that “work” in bringing about desirable social outcomes? I study a case of successful institutional design—the redesign of the National Resident MatchingExpand


Two-sided Matching with Limited Interviews
We study the outcome in a matching market where both sides have limited ability to consider options. For example, in the national residency matching program, doctors are limited to apply to a smallExpand
An Empirical Model of the Medical Match
  • N. Agarwal
  • Economics, Medicine
  • The American economic review
  • 2015
This paper develops a framework for estimating preferences in a many-to-one matching market using only observed matches. I use pairwise stability and a vertical preference restriction on one side toExpand
The Redesign of the Matching Market for American Physicians: Some Engineering Aspects of Economic Design
The design of the new clearinghouse adopted by the National Resident Matching Program, which annually fills approximately 20,000 jobs for new physicians, is reported, finding the set of stable matchings, and the opportunities for strategic manipulation, are surprisingly small. Expand
Effect of selfish choices in deferred acceptance with short lists
It is found that residents' choices in this model mimic the behavior observed in real systems where individuals apply to a mix of positions consisting mostly of places where they are reasonably likely to get accepted, as well as a few "reach" applications to hospitals of very high quality, and a few 'safe' applications to Hospitals of lower than their expected level. Expand
An Experimental Study of Decentralized Matching
We present an experimental study of complex decentralized one-to-one matching markets, such as labor or marriage markets. In our experiments, subjects are informed of everyone's preferences and canExpand
Two-Sided Matching: A Study in Game-Theoretic Modeling and Analysis
The marriage model and the labor market for medical interns, a simple model of one seller and many buyers, and Discrete models with money, and more complex preferences are examined. Expand
Unbalanced Random Matching Markets: The Stark Effect of Competition
We study competition in matching markets with random heterogeneous preferences and an unequal number of agents on either side. First, we show that even the slightest imbalance yields an essentiallyExpand
Credible group stability in many-to-many matching problems
It is shown that pairwise stability is equivalent to credible group stability when one side has responsive preferences and the other side has categorywise- responsive preferences, and a credibly group-stable matching is immune to any "executable" group deviations. Expand
Incentive Compatibility of Large Centralized Matching Markets
We study the manipulability of stable matching mechanisms. To quantify incentives to manipulate stable mechanisms, we consider markets with random cardinal utilities, which induce ordinal preferencesExpand
A Theory of Stability in Many-to-Many Matching Markets
We develop a theory of stability in many-to-many matching markets. We give conditions under which the setwise-stable set, a core-like concept, is nonempty and can be approached through an algorithm.Expand