Thoughts on Periodizing the Gilded Age: Capital Accumulation, Society, and Politics, 1873-18981

  title={Thoughts on Periodizing the Gilded Age: Capital Accumulation, Society, and Politics, 1873-18981},
  author={Richard Schneirov},
  journal={The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era},
  pages={189 - 224}
  • R. Schneirov
  • Published 1 July 2006
  • History
  • The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
There was once a time in the not too recent past when scholarly discussion and debate over periodization was central to the task of writing and thinking about the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Scholars such as Richard Hofstadter, Robert Wiebe, and Samuel P. Hays applied versions of modernization theory to the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries to produce what came to be known as the “organizational synthesis.” A competing periodization centered on the rise of the large business… 


  • Matthew Schneirov
  • Sociology, History
    The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
  • 2017
The study of the mass circulation “popular magazine” during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era was revived during the 1990s as part of the emerging fields of gender studies, consumer studies, and the

Capitalism as a social movement: the corporate and neoliberal reconstructions of the American political economy in the twentieth century

Abstract This paper examines the ways in which social movements based among leading capitalists have remade the US political economy. In the first part we examine the period from the late 1880s


No one today is quite sure what time period the Gilded Age and Progressive Era covers. It sprawls somewhere in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, but few historians can agree on where

The fin de siècle and the multiple temporalities of historical periodization

ABSTRACT Developing an effective theory of periodization requires an engagement with the multilayered figurative constructions of historical time made by historians and historical actors. The fin de

The Paradoxical Origins of Modern Debt in Late Nineteenth Century Iceland

Instituted in 1885, the Landsbanki was intended to facilitate—among other things— the introduction of the mentality that can be called capitalistic rationality, a key prerequisite for the modern

Movements, Aesthetics, and Markets in Literary Change: Making the American Labor Problem Novel

One path to cultural innovation in artistic and literary fields is differentiation of a genre into new subgenres. But what are the dynamics at work in such a process? This article addresses that

The Oneida Community and the utility of liberal capitalism

Historians studying the utopian Oneida Community have often located its demise in rising internal dissent and failing consensus among its members, with special emphasis on the personal jealousies and

The Politics of Economic Crises: The Panic of 1873, the End of Reconstruction, and the Realignment of American Politics1

  • Nicolas Barreyre
  • History, Political Science
    The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
  • 2011
On September 18, 1873, the announcement of Jay Cooke and Company's bankruptcy sent Wall Street to a panic, and the country to a long, harsh depression. Americans interpreted this economic crisis in

Mobilizing for Social Democracy in the 'Land of Opportunity': Social Movement Framing and the Limits of the 'American Dream' in Postwar United States

This thesis looks at the use of ‘American Dream’ language by the U.S. labour and civil rights movements during the first three decades following the Second World War. It examines, in particular, the


Popular Geography Writing in America, 1783–1888” is an intellectual and cultural history that traces the connections among geography writing, print culture, and nationalism. It challenges the



The Social Analysis of Economic History and Theory: Conjectures on Late Nineteenth-Century American Development

UNTIL RECENTLY, HISTORIANS WRITING ABOUT THE late nineteenth-century United States cast their story as if the hopelessly outclassed "people" inevitably lost whatever battle they happened to be

"Marxism" and the Politics of History: Reflections on the Work of Eugene D. Genovese

The title of this essay should be “Historiography ‘R’ Us.” Three years ago, Lloyd Gardner urged me to participate in a roundtable discussion of William Appleman Williams at the Organization of

The reconstruction of American liberalism, 1865-1914

Tracing the transformation of liberal political ideology from the end of the Civil War to the early twentieth century, Nancy Cohen offers a new interpretation of the origins and character of modern

Pragmatism and the Political Economy of Cultural Revolution, 1850–1940

The rise of corporate capitalism was a cultural revolution as well as an economic event, according to James Livingston. That revolution resides, he argues, in the fundamental reconstruction of

The Antislavery debate : capitalism and abolitionism as a problem in historical interpretation

This volume brings together one of the most provocative debates among historians in recent years. The center of controversy is the emergence of the antislavery movement in the United States and

Modernization Theory and the Comparative Study of National Societies: A Critical Perspective

  • Dean C. Tipps
  • Economics
    Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • 1973
Use of the term ‘modernization’ in its present connotations is of relatively recent origin, becoming an accepted part of the vocabulary of American, if not international, social science only in the

Wholes and Parts: The Need for Synthesis in American History

The American cant of newness, so pervasive in the general culture, is all the more remarkable for its capacity to penetrate even specialized professional discourses. What a succession of "new"

The Political Economy of American Populism from Jackson to the New Deal

  • T. Goebel
  • History, Political Science
    Studies in American Political Development
  • 1997
Over the past few decades, historians engaged in the study of American Populism have advanced a number of conflicting interpretations of the last great protest movement of the nineteenth century.

Strikes in Nineteenth-Century America

Strikes have always held great fascination for historians of the working class. Collective work stoppages tear the tissue of “normal life,” and in doing so they provide historians with revealing

The New American History

Preface to the Revised and Expanded Edition - Eric Foner Introduction to the First Edition - Eric Foner Part I: Eras of the American Past 1. Beneficiaries of Catastrophe: The English Colonies in