Thinking is Believing

@article{Mandelbaum2014ThinkingIB,
  title={Thinking is Believing},
  author={Eric Mandelbaum},
  journal={Inquiry},
  year={2014},
  volume={57},
  pages={55 - 96}
}
Abstract The idea that people can entertain propositions without believing them is widespread, intuitive, and most probably false. The main goal of this essay is to argue against the claim that people can entertain a proposition without believing it. Evidence is presented demonstrating that we cannot withhold assent from any proposition we happen to consider. A model of belief fixation is then sketched and used to explain hitherto disparate, recalcitrant and somewhat mysterious psychological… 
View on Taylor & Francis
philpapers.org
79 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
4
Background Citations
27
Methods Citations
2
Results Citations
3

79 Citations

Citation Type

Citation Type

The science of belief: A progress report.
TLDR
Empirical and observational data support the existence of a Spinozan system of belief fixation, one that is automatic and independent of belief rejection, and at least two systems of belief change, which functions to guard the authors' most centrally held beliefs from potential inconsistency with newly formed beliefs.
If You Can't Change What You Believe, You Don't Believe It
I develop and defend the view that subjects are necessarily psychologically able to revise their beliefs in response to relevant counter-evidence. Specifically, subjects can revise their beliefs in…
Negative Doxastic Voluntarism and the concept of belief
TLDR
Negative Doxastic Voluntarism is introduced according to which there is a fundamental asymmetry in belief change: humans tend to acquire beliefs more or less automatically and unreflectively, but they tend to withdraw beliefs in a controlled and deliberate way.
Against dispositionalism: belief in cognitive science
Dispositionalism about belief has had a recent resurgence. In this paper we critically evaluate a popular dispositionalist program pursued by Eric Schwitzgebel. Then we present an alternative: a…
Attitude, Inference, Association: On the Propositional Structure of Implicit Bias
The overwhelming majority of those who theorize about implicit biases posit that these biases are caused by some sort of association. However, what exactly this claim amounts to is rarely specified.…
Beliefs and biases
TLDR
It is argued that both the critiques and defenses of belief models of implicit bias are problematic and debates about nature of the implicit bias ought to shift away from the belief question and toward more fundamental questions about stability and evidential sensitivity of implicit biases.
Inferring Others' Hidden Thoughts: Smart Guesses in a Low Diagnostic World
People are biased toward believing that what others say is what they truly think. This effect, known as the truth bias, has often been characterized as a judgmental error that impedes accuracy. We…
How Not to Deal with the Tragic Dilemma
ABSTRACT Race is often epistemically relevant, but encoding racial stereotypes can lead to implicitly biased behavior. Thus, given the way race structures society, it seems to be impossible to be…
In the Space of Reasonable Doubt
TLDR
It is argued that the lens of reasonable doubt sheds light on aspects of belief dynamics, as well as of the nature of epistemic attitudes, which are often obscured by belief-centred approaches.
Consciousness, belief, and the group mind hypothesis
TLDR
It is argued that a state is not a belief unless the owner of the state is disposed to access the state’s content in a corresponding conscious judgment, and that if there is no such thing as group consciousness, then the authors cannot literally ascribe beliefs to groups.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 125 REFERENCES
How mental systems believe.
Is there a difference between believing and merely understanding an idea?Descartes thought so. He considered the acceptance and rejection of an idea to be alternative outcomes of an effortful…
Believe It or Not
TLDR
The findings suggest that comprehending a statement may not require believing it, and that it may be possible to suspend belief in comprehended propositions.
Alief and Belief
I introduce and argue for the importance of a cognitive state that I call alief. Paradigmatic alief can be characterized as a mental state with associatively-linked content that is representational,…
You can't not believe everything you read.
TLDR
Three experiments support the hypothesis that comprehension includes an initial belief in the information comprehended, and prevent Ss from "unbelieving" the false information they automatically believed during comprehension.
Explaining the Abstract/Concrete Paradoxes in Moral Psychology: The NBAR Hypothesis
For some reason, participants hold agents more responsible for their actions when a situation is described concretely than when the situation is described abstractly. We present examples of this…
Unbelieving the Unbelievable : Some Problems in the Rejection of False Information
Spinoza suggested that all information is accepted during comprehension and that false information is then unaccepted. Subjects were presented with true and false linguistic propositions and, on some…
Attitude, Inference, Association: On the Propositional Structure of Implicit Bias
The overwhelming majority of those who theorize about implicit biases posit that these biases are caused by some sort of association. However, what exactly this claim amounts to is rarely specified.…
On the Aim of Belief
The phenomenon to be explained in this case is that the attribution of propositional content to a thought seems to yield normative consequences, on purely conceptual grounds. To say of a thought that…
Introspection: Divided and Partly Eliminated
This paper will argue that there is no such thing as introspective access to judgments and decisions. It won’t challenge the existence of introspective access to perceptual and imagistic states, nor…
The intentional stance
How are we able to understand and anticipate each other in everyday life, in our daily interactions? Through the use of such "folk" concepts as belief, desire, intention, and expectation, asserts…
...
1
2
3
4
5
...