Thinking about Progress: From Science to Philosophy

  title={Thinking about Progress: From Science to Philosophy},
  author={Finnur Dells{\'e}n and Insa Lawler and James Norton},
Is there progress in philosophy? If so, how much? Philosophers have recently argued for a wide range of answers to these questions, from the view that there is no progress whatsoever to the view that philosophy has provided answers to all the big philosophical questions. However, these views are difficult to compare and evaluate, because they rest on very different assumptions about the conditions under which philosophy would make progress. This paper looks to the comparatively mature debate… 
1 Citations


Experimental Philosophy and Philosophical Disputes
One view of philosophy that is sometimes expressed, especially by scientists, is that while philosophers are good at asking questions, they are poor at producing convincing answers. And the perceived
Progress in Philosophy
A great deal has been written about progress in ^"^ science; little has been written about progress in philosophy.1 Perhaps the very subject is some? thing of an embarrassment. What is to be avoided
Is There Progress in Philosophy? The Case for Taking History Seriously
Abstract In response to widespread doubts among professional philosophers (Russell, Horwich, Dietrich, McGinn, Chalmers), Stoljar argues for a ‘reasonable optimism’ about progress in philosophy. He
Method in the Service of Progress
There is a powerful three-step argument that philosophy has made no progress. The first step maintains that a field makes genuine progress to the extent that, over time, it provides true answers to
Philosophy Makes No Progress, So What Is the Point of It?
Philosophy makes no progress. It fails to do so in the way science and mathematics make progress. By “no progress” is meant that there is no successive advance of a well-established body of
Oxford Handbook for the Philosophy of Science
We survey some debates about the nature and structure of physical theories and about the connections between our physical theories and naturalized metaphysics. Our discussion is organized around an
How Intellectual Communities Progress
Abstract Recent work takes both philosophical and scientific progress to consist in acquiring factive epistemic states such as knowledge. However, much of this work leaves unclear what entity is the
Extensive philosophical agreement and progress
I first argue that there is plenty of agreement among philosophers on philosophically substantive claims, which fall into three categories. This agreement suggests that there is important
Understanding scientific progress: the noetic account
The answer explored in the paper is that the requisite type of cognitive change occurs when scientific results are made publicly available so as to make it possible for anyone to increase their understanding of X.
Problems Of Philosophy
IN the following pages I have confined myself in the main to those problems of philosophy in regard to which I thought it possible to say something positive and constructive, since merely negative