Corpus ID: 6423703

The use of the classical twin method in the social and behavioral sciences: The fallacy continues.

  title={The use of the classical twin method in the social and behavioral sciences: The fallacy continues.},
  author={Jay Ashvin Joseph},
  journal={Journal of Mind and Behavior},
  • J. Joseph
  • Published 2013
  • Psychology
  • Journal of Mind and Behavior
The classical twin method assesses differences in behavioral trait resemblance between reared-together monozygotic and same-sex dizygotic twin pairs. Twin method proponents argue that the greater behavioral trait resemblance of the former supports an important role for genetic factors in causing the trait. Many critics, on the other hand, argue that non-genetic factors plausibly explain these results. The twin method has been used for decades in psychology, psychiatry, and medicine, and more… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

Experimenting in the Biosocial: The Strange Case of Twin Research
In this chapter, I explore how twin research has been used to prove and disprove divisions between biology and environment. The history of using twins in biomedical research has lessons forExpand
Sharing genes fosters identity fusion and altruism
Abstract Researchers have shown that the more genes twins share, the more they care about one another. Here, we examine a psychological mediator of such genetic influences, “identity fusion” (aExpand
Not in Your Genes—Time to Accept the Null Hypothesis of the Human Genome Project?
It is a little known fact outside the world of those directly concerned with molecular genetics, that the HGP has been unable to identify genes, groups of genes, or small variations in genetic material, that explain more than a tiny proportion of why two groups differ in any psychological respect at all. Expand
Genetic influence on resting state networks in young male and female adults
This is the first study to the authors' knowledge to assess the heritability across young healthy adults both in general and specific to gender. Expand
The aetiology of emotional eating in childhood
Emotional overeating (EOE) and under-eating (EUE) in response to stress are common behaviours which emerge in childhood. However, their aetiology is largely unknown. This thesis analysed data from aExpand
Democratic Demands and Citizen Capabilities
In this chapter, the author develops his thesis that an individual’s personality is a durable and measurable manifestation of unconscious brain processes that systematically influence individuals’Expand
Molecular Genetics, Risk Aversion, Return Perceptions, and Stock Market Participation
We show that molecular variation in DNA related to cognition, personality, health, and body shape, predicts an individual’s equity market participation and risk aversion. Moreover, the molecularExpand
Advantaged socioeconomic conditions in childhood are associated with higher cognitive functioning but stronger cognitive decline in older age
It is concluded that neuronal loss can no longer be repaired in people with more cognitive reserve once the underlying pathology is substantial and speed of decline is accelerated, and lend support to theories of cognitive reserve. Expand
Gene x environment interactions as dynamical systems: clinical implications
The etiology and progression of the chronic diseases that account for the highest rates of mortality in the US, namely, cardiovascular diseases and cancers, involve complex gene x environmentExpand
Improving Bespoke Software Quality: Strategies for Application and Enterprise Architects
Improving Bespoke Software Quality: Strategies for Application and Enterprise Architects by Dan Wagner MSIT, Capella University, 2009 BBA, American Intercontinental University, 2006 Doctoral StudyExpand


A test of the equal-environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illness
A newly developed model-fitting approach which treats perceived zygosity as a form of specified familial environment is used which supports the validity of the EEA in twin studies of psychiatric disorders. Expand
Twin method: Defense of a critical assumption
Perceived zygosity and perceived similarity by self and others were found to be insignificant biases in the twin study method. Expand
Twin Studies of Political Behavior: Untenable Assumptions?
Using the “classical twin method,” political scientists John Alford, Carolyn Funk, and John Hibbing conclude that political ideologies are significantly influenced by genetics, an assertion that hasExpand
Twin Studies of General Mental Ability
Twin studies are a vital source of information about genetic and environmental influences on general mental ability. The classic twin design—comparison of the relative similarity between monozygoticExpand
A test of the equal environment assumption (EEA) in multivariate twin studies.
  • E. Derks, C. Dolan, D. Boomsma
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Twin research and human genetics : the official journal of the International Society for Twin Studies
  • 2006
The analysis of spatial ability and aggression indicated no detectable violation of theequal environment assumption, and multivariate data provide sufficient information to test the validity of the EEA. Expand
Political Science, Biometric Theory, and Twin Studies: A Methodological Introduction
As political scientists begin to incorporate biological influences as explanatory factors in political behavior, the need to present a methodological road map for utilizing biometric genetic theoryExpand
The Genetics of Political Attitudes and Behavior: Claims and Refutations
  • J. Joseph
  • Sociology
  • Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry
  • 2010
Some political scientists have argued in recent years that twin research shows that genetic factors play an important role in shaping political attitudes, ideologies, and behavior. Moreover, someExpand
The lost study: a 1998 adoption study of personality that found no genetic relationship between birthparents and their 240 adopted-away biological offspring.
  • J. Joseph
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Advances in child development and behavior
  • 2013
This 1998 investigation is a "lost study" in the sense that, although it is one of the most methodologically sound behavioral genetic studies ever performed, its results are largely unknown. Expand
What can we learn from twin studies? A comprehensive evaluation of the equal environments assumption.
  • J. Felson
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Social science research
  • 2014
A reanalysis of data from the most cited study of the EEA, Loehlin and Nichols (1976), using better measures, and an analysis of nationally representative twin data from MIDUS using more comprehensive controls on a wider variety of outcomes than previous studies support a middle ground position. Expand
Genetic and Environmental Influences on Adult Personality: Evaluating the Evidence
This paper is made up of two parts. In the first part we outline a frame of reference (the Big Five) for organizing the data from Behavior Genetic studies of adult personality and then briefly reviewExpand