The status of theory and method in rhetorical criticism

  title={The status of theory and method in rhetorical criticism},
  author={James Jasinski},
  journal={Western Journal of Communication},
  pages={249 - 270}
  • J. Jasinski
  • Published 1 September 2001
  • Art
  • Western Journal of Communication
(2001). The status of theory and method in rhetorical criticism. Western Journal of Communication: Vol. 65, Rhetorical Criticism: The State of the Art Revisited, pp. 249-270. 
The Rhetoric of Rhetorical Inquiry
Responding to the essays that make up the 2020 decennial special issue on the state of the art in rhetorical criticism, this essay takes a rhetoric of inquiry approach that asks what metaphors,
Theory/Criticism: A Functionalist Approach to the “Specific Intellectual” Work of Rhetorical Criticism
In this essay, the author uses a functionalist perspective to explore the tension between theory and criticism within contemporary rhetorical criticism. Theory and criticism, he argues, exist as the
A Rhetorical Forecast
This article considers the future of our discipline. The author imagines how emerging media artifacts, discourses, and environments will affect the practices of communication scholarship and change
Between abundance and marginalization: the imperative of racial rhetorical criticism
ABSTRACT Tracing what has become a profound and robust conversation among rhetorical critics, I argue in this essay that questions of race are of such central importance to rhetorical criticism that
(Self-)Portrait of Prof. R.C.: A Retrospective
This essay offers a retrospective on the four special issues of this journal (1957, 1980, 1990, 2001) dedicated to the “state of the art” of rhetorical criticism. Drawing on Oscar Wilde's The
Charting a Course Between Methodological Formalism and Eclecticism: Pedagogical Tensions in Three Rhetorical Analysis Textbooks
This review explores how method-oriented approaches to rhetorical criticism are articulated in three textbooks. In method-oriented criticism, methods are abstracted, foregrounded, and separated from
The Constrained Liberty of the Liberal Arts and Rhetorical Education
Rhetorical studies has long worried about its identity as a critical discipline and a practical art. Since the Great Recession of 2008, a myriad of social and political forces has provoked a
The Rhetorical Citizenship of Corporations in the Digital Age
Abstract Purpose The prime goal of this chapter is to discuss what the notion of rhetorical citizenship as a normative aspiration might entail for corporations. Methodology/approach The
NGO's and the case of ―KONY 2012‖: A critical narrative analysis
This thesis documents a critical narrative analysis of the discourse surrounding the ―KONY 2012‖ campaign and video as found in texts, documents, and artifacts stemming from NGO‘s Amnesty
A Bibliographic Synthesis of Rhetorical Criticism
While conducting research for this article, I often came across this claim: Rhetorical criticism has traditionally been housed in speech communication de partments.1 One look at the bibliography for


Method in rhetorical criticism
The search for method in rhetorical criticism has been hampered by a desire to isolate a unique approach to the assessment of rhetorical discourse and an assumption that one could usefully select a
“Feminine style” and political judgment in the rhetoric of Ann Richards
This essay argues for a revised perspective of the theory of “feminine style” developed by Karlyn Kohrs Campbell to explain the characteristics of historical feminist rhetorical action. Using a cas...
A Ricoeurian Approach to Rhetorical Criticism.
This essay proposes an approach to rhetorical criticism which features the relationship between a message and a culturally‐distanced interpreter or critic. Paul Ricoeur's approach is applied to an
Decorum, Power and the Courtly Style
If politics is an art, then matters of style must be crucial to its practice. This essay considers how political actions are shaped by rhetorical practices that depend upon aesthetic perceptions. M...
Structuralism vs. phenomenology: Implications for rhetorical criticism
This study examines the implications of the structuralist, phe‐nomenological, and constructivist views of discourse and applies them to rhetorical criticism. Structuralist criticism analyzes the
Rhetorical Criticism: A Study In Method
Winner, Speech Communication Association Award for Distinguished Scholarship This is a book that, almost singlehandedly, freed scholars from the narrow constraints of a single critical paradigm and
Rhetorical criticism, 1971: Retrospect, prospect, introspect
This article is the text of an address delivered at the California State Conference in Rhetorical Criticism at Hayward, May 1, 1971. In the spirit of the symposium in an earlier issue of this journal
Rhetoric and judgment in the constitutional ratification debate of 1787–1788: An exploration in the relationship between theory and critical practice
The relationship between the practice of public rhetoric and the nature of political judgment is complex. The essay analyzes a pivotal constitutive controversy, the public Constitutional ratification
A note on theory and practice in rhetorical criticism
Ihe subject of theory and practice mandates attention to the "problem of mediation," to the intersections between thought and action, idea and will, conception and execution. One cannot deal
Equal rights amendment controversy: Two worlds in conflict
The Equal Rights Amendment controversy is studied as a conflict between two world views that are created by the rhetoric generated by proponents and opponents. Descriptions of the settings, actions,