The right to die in the minimally conscious state

  title={The right to die in the minimally conscious state},
  author={L Syd M Johnson},
  journal={Journal of Medical Ethics},
  pages={175 - 178}
  • L. Johnson
  • Published 17 November 2010
  • Medicine
  • Journal of Medical Ethics
The right to die has for decades been recognised for persons in a vegetative state, but there remains controversy about ending life-sustaining medical treatment for persons in the minimally conscious state (MCS). The controversy is rooted in assumptions about the moral significance of consciousness, and the value of life for patients who are conscious and not terminally ill. This paper evaluates these assumptions in light of evidence that generates concerns about quality of life in the MCS. It… 

Topics from this paper

End-Of-Life Decisions in Chronic Disorders of Consciousness: Sacrality and Dignity as Factors
The management of patients suffering from chronic disorders of consciousness (DOC) inevitably raises important ethical questions about the end of life decisions. Some ethical positions claim respect
Can they suffer? The ethical priority of quality of life research in disorders of consciousness
There is ongoing ethical and legal debate about withdrawing life support for patients with disorders of consciousness (DOCs). Frequently fueling the debate are implicit assumptions about the value of
All things considered: Surrogate decision-making on behalf of patients in the minimally conscious state
The minimally conscious state presents unique ethical, legal, and decision-making challenges because of the combination of diminished awareness, phenomenal experience, and diminished or absent
‘In a twilight world’? Judging the value of life for the minimally conscious patient
  • R. Huxtable
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Journal of Medical Ethics
  • 2012
The recent ruling from England on the case of M is one of very few worldwide to consider whether life-sustaining treatment, in the form of clinically assisted nutrition and hydration, should continue
Should we continue treatment for M? The benefits of living
It is argued that the benefits of being sensate to the surroundings for an otherwise unconscious person are not necessarily small, and life-sustaining treatment should not be withdrawn.
Withdrawal of treatment from minimally conscious patients
The taxing legal questions that are raised in the context of withdrawing life sustaining treatment from patients who are in a minimally conscious state are explored.
Chronic Disorders of Consciousness
Clinical and ethical issues that are particularly relevant to disorders of consciousness are discussed, so as to allow for a peaceful and dignified death.
Pure Experience and Disorders of Consciousness
The presence or absence of consciousness is the linchpin of taxonomy for disorders of consciousness (DOCs), as well as a focal point for end-of-life decision making for patients with DOCs. Focus on
What Justifies the Allocation of Health Care Resources to Patients with Disorders of Consciousness?
It is suggested that opportunity-based frameworks might complement standard approaches for justifying resources allocation to patients with disorders of consciousness and help solve the problem of uncertain moral status and accurately measuring the welfare burdens these resources would relieve.
Responsiveness in DoC: A Quest for Consciousness?
Interest on consciousness is growing, but how it arises in the brain remains fundamentally unsolved. The variety of brain mechanisms, the impairment of which is observed in DoC, has implication in


Nancy Cruzan and the right to die.
  • G. Annas
  • Medicine
    The New England journal of medicine
  • 1990
The national discussion concerning decision making for incompetent patients began with the 1976 case of Karen Ann Quinlan, when the New Jersey Supreme Court authorized the removal of her from a ventilator on the basis of her constitutional right of privacy.
Brain damage and the moral significance of consciousness.
It is argued that enjoyment of consciousness might actually give stronger moral reasons not to preserve a patient's life and, indeed, that these might be stronger when patients retain significant cognitive function.
The Wendland case--withdrawing life support from incompetent patients who are not terminally ill.
The case of a man who had informal conversations with his wife and children about end-of-life care, but who had not made a formal statement about either his wishes or who should act in his interest, is reviewed.
The minimally conscious state: Definition and diagnostic criteria
MCS is characterized by inconsistent but clearly discernible behavioral evidence of consciousness and can be distinguished from coma and VS by documenting the presence of specific behavioral features not found in either of these conditions.
Moral significance of phenomenal consciousness.
It is called for further research which might settle whether patients who manifest signs of consciousness possess the sophisticated kind of access consciousness required for personhood, which is less than many people seem to think.
Emotion processing in the minimally conscious state
As a newly described condition distinct from coma or the vegetative state, minimally conscious state (MCS) is characterised by a threshold level of consciousness, and diagnostic criteria have
The questionnaire proposed by Nakase-Richardson et al.1 could be used for setting paradigms to record event-related potentials and activation of the EEG power spectrum which might support results from questionnaire screenings for assessing emergence from PVS and MCS.
Brain response to one's own name in vegetative state, minimally conscious state, and locked-in syndrome.
These results suggest that partially preserved semantic processing could be observed in noncommunicative brain-damaged patients, notably for the detection of salient stimuli, such as the subject's own name.
The locked-in syndrome : what is it like to be conscious but paralyzed and voiceless?
There is an urgent need for a renewed ethical and medicolegal framework for the care of locked-in patients and patients suffering from LIS should not be denied the right to live - and to live with dignity and the best possible revalidation, and pain and symptom management.
Schiavo on the Cutting Edge: Functional Brain Imaging and its Impact on Surrogate End-of-Life Decision-Making
The article addresses the potential impact of functional brain imaging (functional magnetic resonance imaging and positron-emission tomography) on surrogate end-of-life decision-making in light of