The right kind of participation? The effect of a deliberative mini-public on the perceived legitimacy of public decision-making

  title={The right kind of participation? The effect of a deliberative mini-public on the perceived legitimacy of public decision-making},
  author={Daan Jacobs and Wesley Kaufmann},
  journal={Public Management Review},
  pages={91 - 111}
ABSTRACT Deliberative mini-publics have been put forward as a form of citizen participation that is particularly well suited to improve the legitimacy of public decision-making. Using a survey experiment, we find that the perceived legitimacy of a process that includes a deliberative mini-public is higher than a process in which citizens are not able to participate at all, but no higher than a process that includes a participation method that relies on self-selection. Our findings imply that… 

Deliberative Mini-Publics and Perceived Legitimacy: The Effect of Size and Participant Type

The growing use of deliberative mini-publics has created a wide array of different designs. Yet, it is largely unknown whether specific design characteristics affect the extent to which mini-publics

Participation in Public Administration Revisited

Participation has been a relevant issue in public administration research and theory for several decades, especially in old democracies. However, recent processes of globalization, Europeanization

Just Advisory and Maximally Representative: A Conjoint Experiment on Non-Participants' Legitimacy Perceptions of Deliberative Forums

Citizen involvement in deliberative forums is frequently discussed with an eye to boosting the legitimacy of decision-making. However, this idea has been radically challenged by Cristina Lafont

Democratic Public Justification

Abstract Democratic institutions are appealing means of making publicly justified social choices. By allowing participation by all citizens, democracy can accommodate diversity among citizens, and by

Do Voters Trust Deliberative Minipublics? Examining the Origins and Impact of Legitimacy Perceptions for the Citizens’ Initiative Review

Deliberative theorists argue that democracies face an increasing legitimacy crisis for lack of effective representation and robust decision-making processes. To address this problem, democratic

Public Support for Citizens’ Assemblies Selected through Sortition: Survey and Experimental Evidence from 15 Countries

As representative democracies are increasingly criticized, a new institution is becoming popular in academic circles and real-life politics: asking a group of citizens selected by lot to deliberate

Local advisory councils in deliberative decision-making. Findings from research in Polish cities

ABSTRACT Local advisory councils (LACs) are defined as collegial bodies that are anchored in local communities (representing public institutions, NGOs, social groups, business, and individuals), and

Democratic innovations in (subnational) constitution-making: the institutionalized case(s) of the Italian Provinces of Trento and Bolzano

  • M. Trettel
  • Political Science
    Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research
  • 2021
The paper looks at Democratic Innovations in the process of amending subnational constitutional documents. Through qualitative approach, it focuses on two case studies: those of the Italian Provinces

Local Evidence and Diversity in Minipublics

A policymaker selects a group of citizens—a minipublic—to advise her on the desirability of a policy. Each citizen can discover local evidence about the policy but might prefer not to due to

Being Consistent Matters: Experimental Evidence on the Effect of Rule Consistency on Citizen Red Tape

A growing stream of research in public administration is concerned with how red tape and administrative burden affects citizens. Drawing on the procedural fairness literature, we argue that the



Deliberation, Participation, and Democratic Legitimacy: Should Deliberative Mini-Publics Shape Public Policy?

In this article I defend the view that only a participatory conception of democracy is compatible with the criterion of democratic legitimacy that deliberative democrats endorse. I do so by analyzing

Strengthening democracy through bottom-up deliberation: An assessment of the internal legitimacy of the G1000 project

Recent scholarship claims that citizen deliberation can contribute to the quality of democracy and to the legitimacy of political decision making. By including everyone who is affected by a decision

Generating Democratic Legitimacy through Deliberative Innovations: The Role of Embeddedness and Disruptiveness

Democratic deliberation is claimed to improve the legitimacy of democratic decision making. However, deliberation’s beneficial effects do not come about easily. If deliberative innovations want to

Deliberative Impacts: The Macro-Political Uptake of Mini-Publics

Democratic theorists often place deliberative innovations such as citizen's panels, consensus conferences, planning cells, and deliberative polls at the center of their hopes for deliberative

The Emancipatory Effect of Deliberation: Empirical Lessons from Mini-Publics

This article investigates the prospects of deliberative democracy through the analysis of small-scale deliberative events, or mini-publics, using empirical methods to understand the process of

Improving deliberative participation: connecting mini-publics to deliberative systems

This article argues for the assessment of deliberative mini-publics as a dynamic part of a wider deliberative system. The approach draws primarily on Dryzek’s (2009) deliberative capacity building

Organizing consent: The role of procedural fairness in political trust and compliance

.  Political theory often attributes democratic legitimacy to the fairness of the processes by which collective decisions are taken; empirical research by contrast has primarily investigated whether

Procedural legitimacy and political trust: The case of citizen juries in Spain

.  During the past few years, new mechanisms of citizen participation in decision making have been introduced into local governance frameworks in many countries around the world. One of the basic

What can deliberative mini‐publics contribute to democratic systems?

Can deliberative mini‐publics contribute to deepening the democratic dimensions of electoral democracies? The question is framed in this article using a problem‐based approach to democratic theory–to

Which decision‐making arrangements generate the strongest legitimacy beliefs? Evidence from a randomised field experiment

How can democracies satisfy citizens' demands for legitimate decision making? This article reports findings from a randomised field experiment designed to mimic decision making in large-scale