The relativistic velocity composition paradox and the Thomas rotation

  title={The relativistic velocity composition paradox and the Thomas rotation},
  author={A. Ungar},
  journal={Foundations of Physics},
  • A. Ungar
  • Published 1 November 1989
  • Physics
  • Foundations of Physics
The relativistic velocity composition paradox of Mocanu and its resolution are presented. The paradox, which rests on the bizarre and counterintuitive non-communtativity of the relativistic velocity composition operation, when applied to noncollinear admissible velocities, led Mocanu to claim that there are “some difficulties within the framework of relativistic electrodynamics.” The paradox is resolved in this article by means of the Thomas rotation, shedding light on the role played by… Expand

Figures from this paper

Geometrical interpretation for relativistic composition of velocities and the Thomas precession
The relativistic composition of velocities is interpreted in terms of the rapidity triangle, as a generalization of the non-relativistic parallelogram rule. Some geometrical experiments are presentedExpand
On the relativistic velocity composition paradox and the Thomas rotation
The non-commutativity and the non-associativity of the composition law of the non-colinear velocities lead to an apparent paradox, which in turn is solved by the Thomas rotation. A 3×3 parametric,Expand
The Expanding Minkowski Space
abstractUnder the common relativistic velocity composition law the relativistically admissible velocities form a weakly associative-commutative group (WACG) rather than an ordinary group. A study ofExpand
Successive Lorentz transformations of the electromagnetic field
A velocity-orientation formalism to deal with compositions of successive Lorentz transformations, emphasizing analogies shared by Lorentz and Galilean transformations, has recently been developed.Expand
Thomas rotation and Mocanu paradox -- not at all paradoxical
Non-commutativity of the Einstein velocity addition, in case of non-collinear velocities, seemingly gives rise to a conflict with reciprocity principle. However, Thomas rotation comes at a rescue andExpand
Alternative realization for the composition of relativistic velocities
The reciprocity principle requests that if an observer, say in the laboratory, sees an event with a given velocity, another observer at rest with the event must see the laboratory observer with minusExpand
Alternative realization for the composition of relativistic velocities
The reciprocity principle requests that if an observer, say in the laboratory, sees an event with a given velocity, another observer at rest with the event must see the laboratory observer with minusExpand
On a quasi-relativistic formula in polarization theory.
  • T. Tudor
  • Physics, Medicine
  • Optics letters
  • 2015
In a pure operatorial (nonmatrix) Pauli algebraic approach, this Letter shows that the Poincaré vector of the light transmitted by a dichroic device can be expressed as function of the PoincaréExpand
Spacetime without Reference Frames: An Application to the Velocity Addition Paradox
Abstract Much conceptualisation in contemporary physics is bogged down by unnecessary assumptions concerning a specific choice of coordinates which often leads to misunderstandings and paradoxes.Expand
Thomas rotation: a Lorentz matrix approach
The composition of two pure Lorentz transformations (boosts) parametrized by non-parallel velocities is equivalent to a boost combined with a pure spatial rotation - the Thomas rotation. Thirty yearsExpand


The Relativistic Noncommutative Nonassociative Group of Velocities and the Thomas Rotation
The bizarre and counterintuitive noncommutativity and nonassociativity of the relativistic composition of nonparallel admissible velocities is sometimes interpreted as a peculiarity of special theoryExpand
Lorentz Transformation and the Thomas Precession
The various kinematic effects of special relativity are here treated by considering iterations of the infinitesimal Lorentz transformation. There is only one relativistic effect that appears as aExpand
The Thomas rotation formalism underlying a nonassociative group structure for relativistic velocities
Physics is a major external source of mathematical theories. It is shown here that the Thomas rotation effect of special theory of relativity (STR) gives rise to a “group” structure for the set ofExpand
The Motion of the Spinning Electron
IN a letter published in NATURE of February 20, p. 264, Messrs. Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit have shown how great difficulties which atomic theory had met in the attempt to explain spectral structure andExpand
Relativistic motion of a charged particle, the Lorentz group, and the Thomas precession
The equation of motion of a classical charged particle in a homogeneous, static electromagnetic field is solved exactly in terms of a Lorentz transformation. All higher‐order corrections to theExpand
The Thomas precession and velocity-space curvature
The motion of a physical system acted upon by external torqueless forces causes the relativistic Thomas precession of the system’s spin vector, relative to an inertial frame. A time‐dependent forceExpand
Derivation of the Spin-Orbit Interaction
Many students find it paradoxical that spin-orbit coupling is discussed in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics although it is usually said to be a consequence of relativity. The resolution of thisExpand
Special relativity completed: The source of some 2s in the magnitude of physical phenomena
Some factors of 2 relate predictions made of relativistic systems by the special and the general theory. Conventional wisdom often assigns the source of the factors of 2 to complicated kinematicalExpand
The Lorentz group and the Thomas precession. II. Exact results for the product of two boosts
The product of two Lorentz boosts in different directions is equal to the product of a pure boost and a spatial rotation. To second order, the resulting boost is simply the sum of the individualExpand
Weakly Associative Groups
The space ℝc3 of 3-dimensional relativistically admissible velocities possesses (i) a binary operation which represents the relativistic velocity composition law; and (ii) a mapping from theExpand