The pre-linguistic basis of grammaticalisation: a unified approach to metaphor and reanalysis

  title={The pre-linguistic basis of grammaticalisation: a unified approach to metaphor and reanalysis},
  author={S Hoefler and Andrew D. M. Smith},
  journal={Studies in Language},
Traditionally, grammaticalisation has been described as being based on phenomena specific to language such as metaphorical extension or reanalysis. This characterisation is somewhat in contrast to claims that grammaticalisation is involved in the much more general process of the initial emergence of language. In this article, we provide a unified analysis of both the metaphor-based and the reanalysis-based account of grammaticalisation which is grounded in the cognitive mechanisms underlying… 

Tables from this paper

Communicative emergence and cultural evolution of word meanings
The experiments show that rather than straightforwardly reflecting pre-linguistic conceptualisation, word meanings are also dynamically shaped by learning and communication, and these processes are constrained by the conventions that already exist within a language.
Modelling the role of pragmatic plasticity in the evolution of linguistic communication
A model of the cultural evolution of language is introduced that acknowledges and incorporates the fact that communication exhibits pragmatic plasticity and explores the explanatory potential of this fact with regard to language evolution.
Evolutionary psycholinguistic approach to the pragmatics of reference
This thesis explicitly acknowledges and investigates the adaptationist nature of functional claims in psycholinguistics, and attempts to demonstrate that Psycholinguistic inquiry can provide evidence that is relevant to theories of how the cognitive architecture of linguistic communication evolved.
Human Self-Domestication and the Evolution of Pragmatics
The reduction in reactive aggression, one of the key factors in self-domestication processes, enabled us to fully exploit the authors' cognitive and interactional potential as applied to linguistic exchanges, and ultimately to evolve a specific form of communication governed by persuasive reciprocity-a trait of human conversation characterized by both competition and cooperation.
The emergence of duality of patterning: Insights from the laboratory
The results of an experimental-semiotics study tested the hypothesis that DP is a necessary solution to the problem of conveying a large number of meanings but were inconclusive with regard to the idea that DP arises as a consequence of conventionalization.
Much recent research has sought to model language as a complex adaptive system, in which linguistic patterns emerge from the social and communicative interactions in which language is used (e.g.
Modelling relevance-driven language evolution
A basic architecture for a model that overcomes shortcomings of existing models by incorporating elements of Relevance Theory and Cognitive Semantics is introduced.
The Influence of Shared Visual Context on the Successful Emergence of Conventions in a Referential Communication Task
The study illustrates the benefits of exploring the emergence of linguistic conventions using an ostensive-inferential model of communication and suggests that dyads with access to the visual context successfully adapt the conventions built for one color space to another color space, unlike dyads lacking it.
Cooperation, social selection, and language change: an experimental investigation of language divergence
An experimental model is used to investigate the role of social pressures in stimulating language divergence, which put real speakers in the artificial environment of a computer game and manipulated two major factors: frequency of interaction and competitiveness.


Grammaticalization: A Conceptual Framework
Grammaticalization, the process of converting regular lexical items and structures into conventionally interpreted grammatical morphemes, has traditionally been perceived as a syntactic or
Cognitive Foundations of Grammar
Cognitive Foundations of Grammar will appeal to students of linguistics, psychology, and anthropology, especially those interested in grammaticalization processess.
On Grammatical Relations as Constraints on Referent Identification.
It is argued that grammatical relations are construction-specific conventionalizations (grammaticalizations) of implicatures which arise out of repeated patterns of reference to particular types of referents, and that any cross-linguistic use of terms such as “subject” should be avoided.
Grammaticalization vs. Reanalysis: a Semantic- Pragmatic Account of Functional Change in Grammar
Most current theorizing conceives of grammaticalization (and reanalysis) in purely structural-descriptive terms, according to Lehmann's (1995) parameters. But these leave fundamental questions
The Evolution of Grammar: Tense, Aspect, and Modality in the Languages of the World
This analysis reveals that lexical substance evolves into grammatical substance through various mechanisms of change, such as metaphorical extension and the conventionalization of implicature, providing clear evidence that language use is a major factor in the evolution of synchronic language states.
Presumptive Meanings: The theory of generalized conversational implicature by Stephen C. Levinson
  • N. Green
  • Linguistics
    Computational Linguistics
  • 2001
Levinson's book presents a theory of generalized conversational implicature (GCI), and makes the central claim that this theory necessitates a "new view of the architecture of the theory of meaning"
A unitary approach to lexical pragmatics: relevance, inference and ad hoc concepts.
According to recent work in the new field of lexical pragmatics, the meanings of words are frequently pragmatically adjusted and fine-tuned in context, so that their contribution to the proposition
Presumptive Meanings: The theory of generalized conversational implicature
From the Publisher: When we speak, we mean more than we say. In this book Stephen C. Levinson explains some general processes that underlie presumptions in communication. This is the first extended
Historical Syntax in Cross-Linguistic Perspective
The nature of syntactic change and the issue of causation are discussed, as well as the role of language contact and syntactic borrowing, in the development of complex constructions.