The meaning of race in psychology and how to change it: a methodological perspective.

  title={The meaning of race in psychology and how to change it: a methodological perspective.},
  author={Janet E. Helms and Maryam M Jernigan and Jackquelyn Mascher},
  journal={The American psychologist},
  volume={60 1},
The primary purpose of this article was to offer a methodological critique in support of arguments that racial categories should be replaced as explanatory constructs in psychological research and theory. To accomplish this goal, the authors (a) summarized arguments for why racial categories should be replaced; (b) used principles of the scientific method to show that racial categories lack conceptual meaning; (c) identified common errors in researchers' measurement, statistical analyses, and… 

Tables from this paper

Researching Race Within Educational Psychology Contexts
In this article, we question why race as a sociohistorical construct has not traditionally been investigated in educational psychology research. To do so, we provide a historical discussion of the
Intersectionality and research in psychology.
  • E. Cole
  • Psychology, Sociology
    The American psychologist
  • 2009
Feminist and critical race theories offer the concept of intersectionality to describe analytic approaches that simultaneously consider the meaning and consequences of multiple categories of
On Becoming Cultural Beings: A Focus on Race, Gender, and Language
In this article, the authors present theoretical perspectives and empirical evidence on the perceptual narrowing and meaning attributed by each culture through social interactions to the categories
On Becoming Cultural Beings: A Focus on Race, Gender, and Language
In this article, the authors present theoretical perspectives and empirical evidence on the perceptual narrowing and meaning attributed by each culture through social interactions to the categories
Some better practices for measuring racial and ethnic identity constructs.
Racial and ethnic identity (REI) measures are in danger of becoming conceptually meaningless because of evaluators' insistence that they conform to measurement models intended to assess
A Theory of Race
Social commentators have long asked whether racial categories should be conserved or eliminated from our practices, discourse, institutions, and perhaps even private thoughts. In A Theory of Race,
Women, men, and all the other categories
This article looks at psychological theory and research that aims to capture and study human diversity in new ways. Human diversity, increasingly framed in terms of intersectionality - focusing the
Invisibility of Racial/Ethnic Minorities in Developmental Science: Implications for Research and Institutional Practices
This article examines invisibility, or how dominant practices serve to overlook, silence, or dismiss knowledge produced by and for racial/ethnic minority populations, and makes recommendations for changes in practices for individuals, institutions, and the field at large.
Racial groups and test fairness, considering history and construct validity.
Removing from test scores of systematic variance attributable to experiences of racial or cultural socialization and focusing on criterion-irrelevant variance in test scores that is attributable to race are suggested.
Expanding Opportunities For Diversity in Positive Psychology: An Examination of Gender, Race, and Ethnicity
Positive psychology has been criticized for ignoring issues relevant to disenfranchised populations. This article presents the results of a 17-year review of the current state of theory and research


Ethnicity and race: Psychological perspectives
  • A. Yee
  • Psychology, Sociology
  • 1983
This article attempts to accomplish the following: (a) indicate the increasingly dangerous and troublesome disparity between biological knowledge and common practice in regards to the use of “race”
Some dubious premises in research and theory on racial differences. Scientific, social, and ethical issues.
Investigators and theoreticians interpreting such differences on the basis of limited sampling within the three broad racial groups should be careful to avoid selectivity and misrepresentation of data that serve racist ideology, and should be cautious about presenting their theories to the public through inappropriate media forums.
When we talk about American ethnic groups, what do we mean?
American ethnic groups are often thought of as discrete categories to which people belong and that explain some aspects of psychological functioning. However, ethnicity is a complex multidimensional
Testing Moderator and Mediator Effects in Counseling Psychology Research.
The goals of this article are to (a) describe differences between moderator and mediator effects; (b) provide nontechnical descriptions of how to examine each type of effect, including study design,
The Thomas and Cross Models of Psychological Nigrescence
Adult Black identity change that took place within the context of the recent Black sociopolitical movement is the focus of a literature review. The review summarizes two models that depict the
Racism as a stressor for African Americans. A biopsychosocial model.
A contextual model for systematic studies of the biopsychosocial effects of perceived racism is presented, along with recommendations for future research.
Testing Stereotype Threat: Does Anxiety Explain Race and Sex Differences in Achievement?
  • J. Osborne
  • Psychology
    Contemporary educational psychology
  • 2001
Examination of whether anxiety will explain racial differences in academic performance and gender differences in math performance in the context of a nationally representative sample of high school seniors provided general support for Steele's stereotype-threat hypothesis.
The Asian American Racism-Related Stress Inventory: Development, factor analysis, reliability, and validity
The development of the 29-item Asian American Racism-Related Stress Inventory (AARRSI) is presented. In the first study, data from 161 Asian American respondents were subjected to an exploratory
Understanding Racial Differences on Cognitive Ability Tests in Selection Contexts: An Integration of Stereotype Threat and Applicant Reactions Research
This study integrates research on stereotype threat with research on applicant perceptions to examine how these two paradigms jointly enhance the understanding of racial subgroup cognitive ability
Realism, instrumentalism, and scientific symbiosis: psychological theory as a search for truth and the discovery of solutions.
The authors propose that the iterative deployment of these 2 perspectives, just as the Iterative application of inductive and deductive reasoning in science may promote more rigorous, integrative, cumulative, and useful scientific theories.