The low barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB) proposal revisited: The case of the Asp ··· His pair in serine proteases

  title={The low barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB) proposal revisited: The case of the Asp ··· His pair in serine proteases},
  author={Claudia N. Schutz and Arieh Warshel},
  journal={Proteins: Structure},
The fact that hydrogen bonds (HBs) can provide major stabilization to transition states (TSs) of enzymatic reactions is well known. However, the nature of HB stabilization has been the subject of a significant controversy. It is not entirely clear if this stabilization is associated with electrostatic effects of preorganized dipoles or with delocalized resonance effects of the so‐called low barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB). One of the best test cases for the LBHB proposal is the complex of… 
Low-barrier hydrogen bond in photoactive yellow protein
It is proposed that in the excited state the fast relaxation of the LBHB into a normal hydrogen bond is the trigger for photo-signal propagation to the protein moiety and the mechanism of the formation of LBHBs is proposed.
Direct evidence of a low barrier hydrogen bond in the catalytic triad of a Serine protease
NMR evidence is shown that LBHB does exist in NS3, a serine protease from Dengue, and this result will help in understanding the mechanism of the catalytic triad in the important group ofserine proteases.
Low barrier hydrogen bonds in protein structure and function.
Ligand-Induced Proton Transfer and Low-Barrier Hydrogen Bond Revealed by X-ray Crystallography.
Three ultrahigh resolution X-ray crystal structures of CTX-M β-lactamase are reported, demonstrating that desolvation of the active site by ligand binding can provide a protein microenvironment conducive to LBHB formation and suggesting that LBHBs may contribute to stabilization of the TS in general acid/base catalysis together with other preorganized features of enzyme active sites.
QM/MM simulation (B3LYP) of the RNase A cleavage-transesterification reaction supports a triester A(N) + D(N) associative mechanism with an O2' H internal proton transfer.
The mechanism of the backbone cleavage-transesterification step of the RNase A enzyme remains controversial even after 60 years of study. We report quantum mechanics/molecule mechanics (QM/MM) free
Contribution of a Low-Barrier Hydrogen Bond to Catalysis Is Not Significant in Ketosteroid Isomerase
The results suggest that the amount of stabilization energy of the reaction intermediate provided by LBHB is small compared with that provided by an ordinary hydrogen bond in KSI, which reduces the binding affinity for the steroid inhibitors.
Challenging a paradigm: Theoretical calculations of the protonation state of the Cys25‐His159 catalytic diad in free papain
Applying the QM/SCRF(VS) molecular modeling approach, it is concluded that the His–Cys catalytic diad in free papain is fully protonated, NH(+)/SH.
Spectroscopic and DFT studies of second-sphere variants of the type 1 copper site in azurin: covalent and nonlocal electrostatic contributions to reduction potentials.
This study provides a methodology for uncoupling covalency from nonlocal electrostatics, which, when coupled to X-ray crystallographic data, distinguishes specific local interactions from more long-range protein/active interactions, while affording further insight into the second-sphere mechanisms available to the protein to tune the E(0) of electron-transfer sites in biology.
A new role of low barrier hydrogen bond in mediating protein stability by small molecules
This study has identified a novel approach for designing tubulin degraders, providing a unique example of LBHB function and suggests that designing small molecules to form LBHBs with protein residues resulting in the highly specific degradation of a target protein could be a new strategy for drug development.


Is there a weak H‐bond → LBHB transition on tetrahedral complex formation in serine proteases?
The hydrogen bond in both the free enzyme and in the enzyme‐inhibitor TC is a strong ionic asymmetric one‐well hydrogen bond, in contrast to a previous suggestion that it is a weak H‐bond in the former and a double‐well LBHB in the latter.
A low-barrier hydrogen bond in the catalytic triad of serine proteases? Theory versus experiment.
Experimental facts are considered regarding the aspartic acid-histidine and cis-urocanic H-bonds that are inconsistent with fundamental tenets of the LBHB hypothesis and cast doubt on the existence of LBHBs, as currently defined, within enzyme active sites.
Ab initio QM/MM dynamics simulation of the tetrahedral intermediate of serine proteases: insights into the active site hydrogen-bonding network.
The study suggests factors that may be implicated in product release: breaking the hydrogen bond of the charged oxygen with the backbone of Ser-195 in the oxyanion hole and a loop opening between residues 216-225 that enables the breaking of a hydrogen bond in subsite S(3).
On low-barrier hydrogen bonds and enzyme catalysis.
Although we agree that hydrogen bonds are important in enzyme catalysis, we disagree with the contention of Cleland and Kreevoy (1) and Frey et al. (2) that "lowbarrier hydrogen bonds" (LBHBs) can
Characterization of Low-Barrier Hydrogen Bonds. 6. Cavity Polarity Effects on the Formic Acid−Formate Anion Model System. An ab Initio and DFT Investigation
High-level ab initio molecular orbital and density functional theory calculations incorporating cavity polarity effects via the use of self-consistent reaction field (SCIPCM) simulations reveal that
Direct determination of the protonation states of aspartic acid-102 and histidine-57 in the tetrahedral intermediate of the serine proteases: neutron structure of trypsin.
A neutron structure analysis at 2.2-A resolution has been performed on bovine trypsin covalently inhibited by a transition-state analogue, the monoisopropylphosphoryl (MIP) group, showing conclusively that the catalytic base in the transition state of the reaction is His-57, not Asp-102.
A Predictive Model of Strong Hydrogen Bonding in Proteins: The Nδ1−H−Oδ1 Hydrogen Bond in Low-pH α-Chymotrypsin and α-Lytic Protease
A computational QM/MM methodology for the systematic study of various structural and spectroscopic properties of strong hydrogen bonds in enzymes is presented. The theoretical model is applied to the
The Low Barrier Hydrogen Bond in Enzymatic Catalysis*
This minireview will explain the original proposal, summarize the experimental data from the past few years, and argue that LBHBs do play important roles in enzymatic reactions.
Energetics of a Low Barrier Hydrogen Bond in Nonpolar Solvents
A measure of the strength of a low barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB) in apolar organic media was obtained using synthetic molecules derived from Kemp's triacid. The structures feature unusually rigid
Characterization of Low-Barrier Hydrogen Bonds. 5. Microsolvation of Enol-Enolate. An ab Initio and DFT Investigation.
The results suggest that small amounts of interstitial water in enzyme active sites may not preclude the existence or importance of low-barrier hydrogen bonds in such biological catalysts.