The interdependence of structure, objects and dependence

@article{French2010TheIO,
  title={The interdependence of structure, objects and dependence},
  author={Steven French},
  journal={Synthese},
  year={2010},
  volume={175},
  pages={89-109}
}
  • S. French
  • Published 13 March 2010
  • Philosophy
  • Synthese
According to ‘Ontic Structural Realism’ (OSR), physical objects—qua metaphysical entities—should be reconceptualised, or, more strongly, eliminated in favour of the relevant structures. In this paper I shall attempt to articulate the relationship between these putative objects and structures in terms of certain accounts of metaphysical dependence currently available. This will allow me to articulate the differences between the different forms of OSR and to argue in favour of the ‘eliminativist… 
View on Springer
idt.mdh.se
68 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
8
Background Citations
22
Methods Citations
2
Results Citations
1

68 Citations

The Dependence of Objects on Structure: Tailoring our Metaphysics to Fit the Physics

The composition of objects is a much discussed issue in metaphysics. In this paper I look at various approaches to this issue in the context of two examples: the relationship between ‘everyday’…

From ontic structural realism to metaphysical coherentism

The present paper argues that the typical structuralist claims according to which invariances, symmetries and the like are fundamental – especially in physics – should not be understood in terms of…

From ontic structural realism to metaphysical coherentism

The present paper argues that the typical structuralist claims according to which invariances, symmetries and the like are fundamental – especially in physics – should not be understood in terms of…

Do Objects Depend on Structures?

  • J. Wolff
  • Philosophy
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 2012
It is shown that objects cannot be reduced to structure, and it is argued that ontological dependence cannot be used to establish strong forms of structural realism.

Reconciling Ontic Structural Realism and Ontological Emergence

While ontic structural realism (OSR) has been a central topic in contemporary philosophy of science, the relation between OSR and the concept of emergence has received little attention. We will argue…

Structuralism in the Idiom of Determination

  • Kerry McKenzie
  • Philosophy
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 2020
Ontic structural realism (OSR) is a thesis of fundamentality metaphysics: the thesis that structure, not objects, has fundamental status. Claimed as the metaphysic most befitting of modern physics,…

Do objects depend on structure?

Ontic Structural Realists hold that structure is all there is, or at least all there is fundamentally. This thesis has proved to be puzzling: what exactly does it say about the relationship between…

The Presentation of Objects and the Representation of Structure

The rise and development of various forms of structuralism (including structural realism and structural empiricism) has seen a concomitant array of diverse representations of structure placed on the…

Structuralist approaches to Bohmian mechanics

Lam and Esfeld have argued that, within Bohmian mechanics, the wave function can be interpreted as a physical structure instantiated by the fundamental particles posited by the theory. Further, to…

Structuralist approaches to Bohmian mechanics

Lam and Esfeld have argued that, within Bohmian mechanics, the wave function can be interpreted as a physical structure instantiated by the fundamental particles posited by the theory. Further, to…
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 51 REFERENCES

In Defence of Ontic Structural Realism

In this paper we clarify how ‘epistemic’ (ESR) and ‘ontic’ structural realism (OSR) should be understood and reply to some important criticisms of the latter. We shall begin with an outline of the…

Structuralism and the notion of dependence

The notion of dependence figures prominently in recent discussions of non-eliminative mathematical structuralism. Structuralists often argue that mathematical objects from one and the same structure…

Structures And Structuralism In Contemporary Philosophy Of Mathematics

This paper identifysystematically and in detail, several main variants ofstructuralism, including some not often recognized, are identified, and the relations between thesevariants, and between the respective problems they face, become manifest.

The Dissolution of Objects: Between Platonism and Phenomenalism

One of the motivations for Ladyman’s ‘ontic’ form of SR is that it offers the realist some hope that she may be able to get away with carrying less metaphysical baggage than the ‘standard’ realist…

On the Preferability of Epistemic Structural Realism

It will be that a weaker version of the form of realism, mainly developed by Steven French and James Ladyman, is more plausible – namely, epistemic structural realism.

VI* STRUCTURE AS A WEAPON OF THE REALIST'

Although much of its history has been neglected or misunderstood, a structuralist ‘tendency’ has re-emerged within the philosophy of science. Broadly speaking, it consists of two fundamental strands:…

What structures could not be

James Ladyman has recently proposed a view according to which all that exists on the level of microphysics are structures “all the way down”. By means of a comparative reading of structuralism in…

Remodelling Structural Realism: Quantum Physics and the Metaphysics of Structure

Ladyman's 'metaphysical' or 'ontic' form of structural realism is outlined and it is argued that by reconceptualising objects in structural terms it offers the best hope for the realist in the context of modern physics.

Scientific Structuralism: On The Identity and Diversity of Objects in a Structure

The identity and diversity of individual objects may be grounded or ungrounded, and intrinsic or contextual. Intrinsic individuation can be grounded in haecceities, or absolute discernibility.…

To What Physics Corresponds

In what follows I wish to reconsider certain ideas to be found in Post’s (1971) defence of the ‘retentionist’ or ‘accumulativist’ view of science. In particular I shall focus on heuristics and…
...