The historical Muhammad and the historical Jesus: A comparison of scholarly reinventions and reinterpretations

  title={The historical Muhammad and the historical Jesus: A comparison of scholarly reinventions and reinterpretations},
  author={Herbert Berg and Sarah E. Rollens},
  journal={Studies in Religion},
  pages={271 - 292}
Scholars of the historical Jesus and scholars of the historical Muhammad are engaged in seemingly similar activities, but they rarely look to each other to compare and evaluate their methods and theories. Such a comparison reveals that both seek to read thoroughly theological texts as historical texts, or at least ones out of which the historical facts can be rooted. Thus, both sets of scholars approach the texts with assumptions shared by the believers. Furthermore, because of the status… 
The cultural evolution of prosocial religions
It is explained how a package of culturally evolved religious beliefs and practices characterized by increasingly potent, moralizing, supernatural agents, credible displays of faith, and other psychologically active elements conducive to social solidarity promoted high fertility rates and large-scale cooperation with co-religionists, often contributing to success in intergroup competition and conflict.
The Essence of Essentializing: A Critical Discourse on “Critical Discourse in the Study of Islam”
Abstract Many scholars have called for more critical discourse in the study of Islam, particularly in response to post-9/11 scholarly and popular depictions of a normative, spiritual Islam in
Prosociality and religion: History and experimentation
The authors discuss Abrahamic religions as the best-known prosocial religions, but the evidence shows the case does not fit their conceptual framework and an extension of the authors’ ideas about the meaning of priming effects is proposed.
  • 2009
Les lecteurs de notre revue trouveront ci-dessous la bibliographie internationale de sociologie des religions pour l’année 2008. Nous rappelons que notre bibliographie ne couvre de façon systématique
The Historical Jesus


The Quest of the Historical Muhammad
Writing in 1962 Stephen Neill listed twelve of what he regarded as “positive achievements of New Testament studies” over the past century. 1 As an affirmation of progress in a notoriously difficult
The Sayings Gospel Q and the Quest of the Historical Jesus: A Response to John S. Kloppenborg
John Kloppenborg's article is a superb example of why studies of the gospel tradition, including the Sayings Gospel Q, should be important to students of religion as well as of early Christianity.
Theses on method
The conjunction "of" that joins the two nouns in the disciplinary ethnonym "History of Religions" is not neutral filler. Religion is that discourse whose defining characteristic is its desire to
Reconstructing the Earliest sīra Texts: the Hiǧra in the Corpus of ʿUrwa b. al-Zubayr
Abstract In his famous study “Ueber die Entwickelung des Ḥadīth” I. Goldziher  argued that the Islamic tradition (ḥadīṯ ) could not be used as a historical source for the time of the Prophet and the