The hawk/goose story: the classical ethological experiments of Lorenz and Tinbergen, revisited.

  title={The hawk/goose story: the classical ethological experiments of Lorenz and Tinbergen, revisited.},
  author={Wolfgang M. Schleidt and Michael D. Shalter and Humberto Moura-Neto},
  journal={Journal of comparative psychology},
  volume={125 2},
We present a historical account of the story behind the famous hawk/goose experiments of Lorenz and Tinbergen in a wider context of cognitive ethology. We discuss their significance, for ethological experimentation in general, and specifically for understanding innate constraints on cognition. As examples of the continuing significance of the hawk/goose paradigm of selective habituation, we discuss its relation to "exposure therapy" of human phobias and the use of hawk silhouettes as deterrents… 

Figures from this paper

Drifting Ethologists. Nikolaas Tinbergen and Gustav Kramer. Two Intellectual Life-Histories in an Incipient Darwinian Epistemic Community (1930-1983).

The present dissertation thesis understands itself as epistemological case study for the principles of scientific change. It presumes that the modern sciences established distinguishable subsystems

Monsters on the Brain: An Evolutionary Epistemology of Horror

Fear of the dark (nyctophobia), spiders (arachnophobia), and snakes (herpetophobia) are universal terrors among human beings, whereas zombies, vampires, and psychopaths are more culturally specific.

Nine Levels of Explanation

This paper discusses the need for multilevel explanation; Huxley and Mayr's prior models, and others that followed; Tinbergen’s differences with Lorenz on “the innate”; andMayr’'s ultimate/proximate distinction; and synthesizes these approaches with nine levels of explanation, which empowers us to explain human behavior and vindicates the idea of human nature, and of humans as a part of nature.

Conquer primal fear: Phonological features are innate and substance-free

  • C. ReissVeno Volenec
  • Linguistics
    Canadian Journal of Linguistics/Revue canadienne de linguistique
  • 2022
Abstract We argue that the representational primes of the human phonological faculty, the so-called distinctive features, are innate and substance-free. Our arguments for the innateness of features

An ethologically based view into human fear

Action anticipation in human infants reveals assumptions about anteroposterior body-structure and action

It is demonstrated that, after limited exposure, human infants as young as six months of age spontaneously encode a novel agent as having a certain axial direction with respect to its actions and rely on it when anticipating the agent's further behaviour.

Let Us Bring Comparative Psychology Back

Author(s): Abramson, Charles I. | Abstract: This article serves as the introduction to the special issue “The State of Comparative Psychology Today” for the International Journal of Comparative

A negative stimulus movement effect in pigeons



The hawk/goose experiment: sources of variability


Behaviorism is a learning paradigm with its roots dating back to the second half of 19th century and works of Ivan Sechenov (1829 1905) and Vladimir Bekhterev (1857 1927), and gaining a significant

The hawk-goose phenomenon: A replication and an extension

Mallard ducks, having no prior experience with objects passing overhead, were more active in the presence of the silhouette of a hawk than that of a goose. However, Ss were equally responsive to a

The Effect of Spatial Context on Habituation to a Predator Model

and Summary In the laboratory setting, anti-predator behavior tends to habituate so fast that its value for the prey's survival appears questionable. We propose that excessive habituation is

Patterns in the behaviour of organisms

“Social-releaser mechanisms” in birds — A controlled replication of Tinbergen’s study

In order to replicate this study, chickens, ducks, and pheasants were presented with the same type of silhouette used by Tinbergen, and the results do not support the data reported.

The Companion in the Bird's World

WHEN Dr. Lorenz's paper on the 'Kumpan" was published in 1935, it seemed to be such an original and important contribution to our knowledge of the instincts and behavior of birds, that I was anxious


  • Biology
  • 2002
The releaser concept has sometimes been misunderstood even though Lorenz has given a clear definition of it, and some general problems connected with the kind of experiments required in work of this type are discussed.

Cardiac response of domestic chickens to hawk and goose models

Social learning : psychological and biological perspectives

The Importance of Social Interaction and Observation in the Acquisition of Communicative Competence: Possible Parallels Between Avian and Human Learning is examined.