The end of the adaptive landscape metaphor?

@article{Kaplan2008TheEO,
  title={The end of the adaptive landscape metaphor?},
  author={Jonathan Michael Kaplan},
  journal={Biology \& Philosophy},
  year={2008},
  volume={23},
  pages={625-638}
}
  • J. Kaplan
  • Published 5 June 2008
  • Sociology
  • Biology & Philosophy
The concepts of adaptive/fitness landscapes and adaptive peaks are a central part of much of contemporary evolutionary biology; the concepts are introduced in introductory texts, developed in more detail in graduate-level treatments, and are used extensively in papers published in the major journals in the field. The appeal of visualizing the process of evolution in terms of the movement of populations on such landscapes is very strong; as one becomes familiar with the metaphor, one often… 

The landscape metaphor in development

© Oxford University Press 2014. Published 2014 by Oxford University Press. role in the formal mathematical modelling of adaptation and speciation and in the didactics of the basic principles of

Adaptive multiscapes: an up-to-date metaphor to visualize molecular adaptation

Several shortcomings of Wright’s visualization of fitness landscapes can be overcome through adaptive multiscapes, and relevant aspects of population adaptation, such as neutral drift, functional promiscuity or environment-dependent fitness, as well as entropic trapping and the concomitant impossibility to reach fitness peaks are visualized at once.

Landscape Revolutions for Cultural Evolution: Integrating Advanced Fitness Landscapes into the Study of Cultural Change

The use of fitness landscapes as models and metaphors is increasingly common in the study of cultural evolution. Fitness landscapes used in this context are often based on imagery developed by Sewall

Visualizing Macroevolution: From Adaptive Landscapes to Compositions of Multiple Spaces

The adaptive landscape is an important diagrammatic concept that was conceived in population genetics. During the Modern Synthesis, in the first half of the twentieth century, the landscape imagery

The topology of evolutionary novelty and innovation in macroevolution

  • D. Erwin
  • Biology
    Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
  • 2017
The nature of evolutionary novelty and innovation within the context of evolutionary spaces is discussed, and it is argued that the primacy of search as a conceptual metaphor ignores the generation of new spaces as well as other changes that have played important evolutionary roles.

Landscapes, Surfaces, and Morphospaces: What Are They Good For?

In principle, it is relatively easy to see how one can go from individual-genotype landscapes to genotypic-frequency landscapes (the two Wright versions of the metaphor), but the further transition from either of these to phenotypes is anything but straightforward because of the notorious complexity and non-linearity of the genotype–phenotype mapping function.

Landscape construction in non-gradient dynamics: A case from evolution

Comparisons of different aspects of various landscapes lead to a conclusion that the generalized landscape is a possible direction to continue the exploration of Wright's theory for complex dynamics, where the conventional gradient landscape does not exist.

VISUALIZING FITNESS LANDSCAPES

  • D. McCandlish
  • Biology
    Evolution; international journal of organic evolution
  • 2011
A rigorous method for creating low‐dimensional representations of fitness landscapes using the eigenvectors of the transition matrix describing the evolution of a population on the fitness landscape when mutation is weak.

Thinking in continua: beyond the “adaptive radiation” metaphor

The account of the life cycle of metaphors in science suggests that it is time to exchange the spent metaphor for new concepts that better represent the full range of diversity, disparity, and speciation rate across all of life.

Predicting evolution and visualizing high-dimensional fitness landscapes

This contribution focuses on the predictability of evolution on rugged genetic fitness landscapes, and determines that peaks in such landscapes are highly clustered: high peaks are predominantly close to other high peaks, such that evolutionary trajectories towards the highest peak in the landscape can be achieved via a series of valley crossings.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 12 REFERENCES

Evolution and speciation on holey adaptive landscapes.

Fitness Landscapes and the Origin of Species

This book builds for the first time a general, quantitative theory for the origin of species based on the notion of fitness landscapes introduced by Sewall Wright in 1932, generalizing this notion to explore the consequences of the huge dimensionality of Fitness landscapes that correspond to biological systems.

Surfaces of Selective Value Revisited

I attempted to construct a pictorial representation of the indicated evolutionary processes in terms of what I later called the shifting-balance theory, first proposed in an abstract (1929).

Are Pictures Really Necessary? The Case of Sewell Wright's "Adaptive Landscapes"

  • M. Ruse
  • Philosophy
    PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association
  • 1990
Philosophical analyses of science tend to ignore illustrations, implicitly regarding them as theoretically dispensible. If challenged, it is suggested that such neglect is justifiable, because the

Sewall Wright and evolutionary biology

"Provine's thorough and thoroughly admirable examination of Wright's life and influence, which is accompanied by a very useful collection of Wright's papers on evolution, is the best we have for any

The heuristic role of sewall Wright's 1932 adaptive landscape diagram

Sewall Wright’s adaptive landscape is the most influential heuristic in evolutionary biology. Wright’s biographer, Provine, criticized Wright’s adaptive landscape, claiming that its heuristic value

An emerging synthesis between community ecology and evolutionary biology.

The Dappled World: A Study of the Boundaries of Science

C a rt w r i g h t ’s latest book brings together previously published and new material into a single vo l u m e. She offe rs an important and systematic pers p e c t ive on the nature of natural

Genes: philosophical analyses put to the test.

This paper describes one complete and one ongoing empirical study in which philosophical analyses of the concept of the gene were operationalized and tested against questionnaire data obtained from

Genetics: What is a gene?

The idea of genes as beads on a DNA string is fast fading. Protein-coding sequences have no clear beginning or end and RNA is a key part of the information package, reports Helen Pearson.Genes