• DOI:10.11124/jbisrir-2012-433
• Corpus ID: 45190593

The effectiveness of group visits for patients with heart failure on knowledge, quality of life, self‐care, and readmissions: a systematic review protocol

@article{Slyer2012TheEO,
  title={The effectiveness of group visits for patients with heart failure on knowledge, quality of life, self‐care, and readmissions: a systematic review protocol},
  author={Jason T. Slyer and Lucille R. Ferrara},
  journal={JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports},
  year={2012},
  volume={10},
  pages={4647–4658}
}

• J. Slyer, Lucille R. Ferrara
• Published 12 December 2012
• Medicine
• JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports

Review question/objective The objective of this review is to identify the effectiveness of group visits for patients with heart failure (HF) on knowledge, quality of life, self‐care behaviors, and hospital readmissions. Research Questions: What is the impact of group visits for patients with HF on knowledge related to HF compared to standard one‐on‐one medical care? What is the impact of group visits for patients with HF on quality of life compared to standard one‐on‐one medical care? What is the impact of group visits for patients with HF on self‐care behaviors compared to standard one‐on‐one medical care? What is the impact of group visits for patients with HF on emergency room visits and unplanned hospital readmissions compared to standard one‐on‐one medical care? Background Heart failure (HF) continues to be a major health burden throughout the world. There are currently over 5.7 million Americans,1 15 million Europeans,2 and 277,800 Australians3 living with HF. These numbers are expected to double by 2040.4 Patients and caregivers perform the majority of HF care in the home.5 Patients with HF need to learn to be successful in self‐managing their condition to lessen the burden of symptoms such as fatigue, dyspnea, and edema. Patient education is the primary process used to increase knowledge of self‐care practices for patients with HF. Patients with HF need to follow a complex medical regimen while adhering to a low sodium diet and prescribed fluid restrictions. In addition patients monitor their physical condition daily for exacerbation of symptoms or signs of fluid overload. Education, behavior modification, and skill development are necessary for a patient with HF to be successful in self‐managing their condition. Most HF education occurs during one‐on‐one visits between the patient and the health care provider in an examination room during a regular clinic visit. However, there is usually limited time to address all of the needed education topics in an in‐depth, meaningful manner with information the patient can take home and utilize in their daily routines. Group visits provide an alternative venue to provide care for this complex patient population. A group visit is an interactive process between a health care provider and a small group of patients and their caregivers who usually share a common medical concern. The participants of group visits can benefit from the knowledge and experiences of the other participants while providing support and encouragement to each other as they learn to cope with living with a chronic condition. The process of the group visit was first developed in 1991 by Dr. John C. Scott at the Kaiser Permanente system in Colorado, United States.6 Dr. Scott and a nurse held monthly group visits lasting 60 minutes with a group of 15 to 20 patients to manage their complex medical conditions. The group visit model can vary across settings, including from 6‐20 patients over a 1‐2 hour period with varying times devoted to education and discussion of health concerns. The group visit typically incorporates a one‐on‐one physical examination with a physician or nurse practitioner in conjunction with a group discussion and medical management. Group visits have shown to be beneficial in improving patient outcomes for conditions such as diabetes, hypertension, and other chronic illness.7,8,9,10 The goal of group visits for patients with HF is to increase patient knowledge and self‐care abilities, while improving self‐efficacy. Self‐care incorporates the decision making process a patient undergoes when deciding on a course of action to maintain stability as a result of a change in symptoms. 11 Improved self‐care can improve symptoms, which will likely result in an increase in quality of life and a reduction in hospitalizations related to decompensation. Quality of life (QOL) refers to a patient's perception of the impact of a health condition and treatment on the patient's health status13 and can be measured with valid and reliable tools such as the Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire (MLHFQ) 14or the Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire (KCCQ).15 Self‐care abilities can be measured using an instrument such as the Self‐Care Heart Failure Index (SCHFI).11 HF knowledge can be measured using an instrument such as the Atlanta Heart Failure Knowledge Test.12 Group visits can be used to continue to optimize medication therapy while providing a forum for knowledge acquisition and fostering support. A search of the Cochrane Library of Systematic Reviews, the Joanna Briggs Library of Systematic Reviews, MEDLINE, and CINAHL did not identify any previously conducted systematic reviews on the effectiveness of group visits on outcomes for patients with heart failure. Therefore, this review seeks to identify studies evaluating the effectiveness of group visits for patients with heart failure on patient knowledge, quality of life, self‐care behaviors, and hospital readmissions.