The dynamics of welfare stigma

  title={The dynamics of welfare stigma},
  author={Robin H. Rogers-Dillon},
  journal={Qualitative Sociology},
Drawing on the symbolic interactionist tradition, this paper focuses on the construction and management of welfare stigma in female welfare recipients' daily lives. In-depth interviews with ten women on welfare are analyzed, particularly in terms of how respondents manage their use of food stamps as stigma symbols. The complex and often contradictory pictures the women in this study painted of their feelings of stigma do not support the assumption, which underlies most research on welfare… 


Scholarship of welfare stigma agrees that the more selective the welfare policy is, the more stigmatizing it is. Yet there are controversies about the impact of welfare stigma on the take-up of

Welfare stigma among low-income, African American single mothers

This article conceptualizes the stigmatization process that is associated with the use of Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) programs. A symbolic interactionist perspective that

Single Welfare Mothers' Resistance

Popular conceptions of welfare recipients are congruous with policy constructions that attribute responsibility for poverty to personal decisions and choices. This research investigates the ways

The stigma of claiming benefits: a quantitative study

Abstract Stigma has long been viewed by some as essential to discourage excessive claims, yet seen by others as a cause of non-take-up by people in need and as a form of symbolic violence. More

Contesting Stigma: On Goffman's Assumptions of Normative Order

Goffman's classic analysis of stigma tacitly suggests that it has a conditional nature. An important shortcoming, however, is that his analysis proceeds from the existence of a normatively shared

Aporia, attentiveness, and the politics of social welfare

Much of the discussion about welfare practice in the US assumes a conceptual opposition between democracy and social welfare, with democracy associated with autonomy, and welfare associated with

“Feeling Less Than a Second Class Citizen”: Examining the Emotional Consequences of Poverty in New York City

It has been argued that individuals living in poverty are shamed, and thus, experience it in various social and institutional spaces. However, little is known about this dynamic in the United States.

‘It Isn't Charity because We've Paid into it’: Social Citizenship and the Moral Economy of Welfare Recipients in the Wake of 2012 UK Welfare Reform Act

Drawing on interviews with welfare claimants living in Essex, UK, this article examines the material and symbolic effects of the UK government’s 2012 Welfare Reform Act, and it highlights the

Citizenship as a gift: how Syrian refugees in Belgium make sense of their social rights

ABSTRACT While citizenship scholars have documented the increasing moralisation of immigration and integration policies, relatively few have explored how immigrants themselves make sense of their

Benefits stigma in Britain

This report set out to investigate the stigma attached to claiming benefits in Britain today, using an original MORI survey conducted in May 2012, focus groups with claimants and non-claimants,



The Social Bases of Welfare Stigma

Use of the concept of welfare stigma suggests the theoretical framework of the labeling approach to deviance. In a review of issues from that literature, we distinguish between feelings of shame and

The Psychological Effects of Income Testing Income-Support Benefits

One of the chief arguments against income-tested (welfare) programs, and for their replacement by a system of non-income-tested benefits, is that welfare is "stigmatizing" and therefore has negative

Recipient Views of Cash versus In-Kind Benefit Programs

This article describes a study comparing recipients of cash assistance and in-kind benefits with regard to their feelings of stigma, their views of their rights and of the legitimacy of eligibility

The Destigmatization of Public Dependency

While acceptance of governmental assistance is increasing among Americans of all social classes, social workers and social planners remain concerned that stigma prevents those most in need from

A Genealogy of Dependency: Tracing a Keyword of the U.S. Welfare State

D EPENDENCY HAS BECOME a keyword of U.S. politics. Politicians of diverse views regularly criticize what they term welfare dependency. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas spoke for many

The undeserving poor

Protecting Soldiers And Mothers