The core disagreement between Pigou, the profession, and Coase in the analyses of the externality question

  title={The core disagreement between Pigou, the profession, and Coase in the analyses of the externality question},
  author={Harold Demsetz},
  journal={European Journal of Political Economy},
  • H. Demsetz
  • Published 1 December 1996
  • Economics
  • European Journal of Political Economy

Coasean versus Pigovian solutions to the problem of social cost: the role of common entitlements

This paper works towards drawing a proper relationship between the Coasean and Pigovian approaches that should be based on the distinction between individual/private and shared/common entitlements.

Externality, Pigou and Coase: A Case for Bilateral Taxation and Amenity Rights

While Coase correctly emphasizes the reciprocal nature of an externality, he ignores an important asymmetry. At the initial private equilibrium, the incremental harm on the sufferers of the external

The three roles of the ‘Coase theorem’ in Coase's works

Abstract This article aims at understanding Coase's apparently paradoxical attitude towards his eponym ‘theorem’. On the one hand, he judges as excessive the attention devoted to an assertion that

Institutional Support of Internalization of Negative external Effects of Old Industrial Production Models

  • О.S. Serdiuk
  • Economics
    Management of Economy: Theory and Practice. Chumachenko’s Annals
  • 2020
The article substantiates the conceptual provisions for the institutional support of the internalization of the negative externalities of old industrial production models. To internalize negative

Generalization of Tools for Internalization of Negative Externalities in the European Union: Conclusions for Ukraine

A comparative analysis of the tools of internalization of negative external. Based on the generalization and assessment of the possibilities of using the tools of internalization of negative

The Theory of the Firm: An Overview of the Economic Mainstream, Revised Edition

  • P. Walker
  • Economics
    SSRN Electronic Journal
  • 2021
In this survey we give a short overview of the way in which the theory of the firm has been formulated within the 'mainstream' of economics, both 'past' and 'present'. As to a break point between the

Sustainable Markets and the State: Taxation, Cap-and-Trade, Pay-for-Success, and Nudging

»Nachhaltige Märkte und Staat: Besteuerung, “cap-and-trade”, “payfor-success” und Nudging«. Sustainable markets are heterogeneous phenomena, developed and implemented to keep up the idea of free

All in the same boat: externalities, interdependence and the commons of Venice lagoon

Venice Lagoon has a complex relationship with the many economic activities it hosts: tourism, oil refineries, a logistics hub, agriculture, households, and fisheries heavily affect the condition of

Directions for improving the efficiency of internalization of negative external effects of industrial production

It was established that the key factors that reduce the efficiency of internalization of negative external effects of industrial production in Ukraine are: shortcomings of the mechanism of taxation

Resource-Based and Property Rights Perspectives on Value Creation: The Case of Oil Field Unitization

Resource-based theory implicitly assumes that property rights to resources are secure. Extant property rights theory enables us to relax this assumption to take into account processes where there are



On External Diseconomies and the Government-Assisted Invisible Hand

I. THE MODERN-OLD APPROACH AND ITS LIMITATIONS The areas of economics in which theory is tailored to the theorist's political beliefs are steadily shrinking. Gone are the days of the " dismal science

Wealth Distribution and the Ownership of Rights

  • H. Demsetz
  • Economics
    The Journal of Legal Studies
  • 1972
INTRODUCTION. In the first issue of the Journal I discussed the allocative effects of right ownership,' expanding on Professor R. H. Coase's important contribution to this subject,2 but I referred to

The Firm, the Market, and the Law

Few other economists have been read and cited as often as R.H. Coase has been, even though, as he admits, "most economists have a different way of looking at economic problems and do not share my

Ownership, control, and the firm

A selection of writings on the theme of ownership, by a leading authority on industrial economics and organization. They all contain Demsetz's unique blend of positive theorizing and evidence

When Does the Rule of Liability Matter?

  • H. Demsetz
  • Economics, Law
    The Journal of Legal Studies
  • 1972
TEE active interface between law and economics has been limited largely to antitrust and regulation, but recent work, primarily in economics, has revealed a much wider area of common interest. The

Meade, Bees, and Externalities

WITHIN the past fifteen years economists have done considerable theoretical and empirical work on the topic of externalities (also termed spillovers, neighborhood effects or social costs), which are

The Fable of the Bees: An Economic Investigation

EVER since A. C. Pigou wrote his books on "welfare,"' a divergence between private and social costs has provided the main argument for instituting government action to correct allegedly inefficient

The Decision for Accidents: An Approach to Nonfault Allocation of Costs

Although it may seem desirable to seek to eliminate accident-causing activities, virtually all societies decide that many activities, though certain to cause some accidents, are nonetheless valuable

The Collected Scientific Papers of Paul A. Samuelson

"It is a measure of Professor Samuelson’s preeminence that the sheer scale of his work should be so much taken for granted," a reviewer for the Economist once observed, marking both Paul Samuelson’s

Economics of welfare

VOLUME 1 Introduction D. Collard Principles and Methods of Industrial Peace, 1905, 260pp Economic Science in Relation to Practice, 1908, 32pp VOLUME 2 Wealth and Welfare, 1912, 524pp VOLUME 3