The claim that China's fertility restrictions contributed to the use of prenatal sex selection: A sceptical reappraisal

@article{Goodkind2015TheCT,
  title={The claim that China's fertility restrictions contributed to the use of prenatal sex selection: A sceptical reappraisal},
  author={Daniel Goodkind},
  journal={Population Studies},
  year={2015},
  volume={69},
  pages={263 - 279}
}
  • D. Goodkind
  • Published 2 September 2015
  • Economics
  • Population Studies
Most observers assume that China's fertility restrictions contribute to the use of prenatal sex selection. I question the logic and evidence underlying that assumption. Experts often stress that China's low fertility is largely voluntary, and that fertility restrictions are an unneeded safety valve. Others claim that China's ‘1.5-child’ loophole, common throughout rural areas, reinforces son preference or intensifies prenatal sex discrimination by hardening fertility constraints. These claims… 
Gender-Biased Sex Selection in Asia: Motives, Methods, Magnitudes
  • Laura Rahm
  • Economics
    Gender-Biased Sex Selection in South Korea, India and Vietnam
  • 2019
This chapter sets the scene by exploring the motives, methods and magnitudes of gender-biased sex selection (GBSS) drawing from socio-demographic and anthropological research. It starts out by
Missing Women, Gender Imbalance and Sex Ratio at Birth: Why the One-Child Policy Matters
In this paper, we show that the one-child policy has played a significant role in the decline of China’s fertility. The one-child policy had reduced China’s fertility rate by an additional 11.5%,
The Astonishing Population Averted by China’s Birth Restrictions: Estimates, Nightmares, and Reprogrammed Ambitions
TLDR
International comparisons of fertility and income suggest instead that China’s very low fertility arrived two or three decades too soon, and if China had not harshly enforced a norm of 1.5-children during the last quarter century, most mothers would have had two children, one-half birth higher than observed.
Sex Ratios and Crime: Evidence from China
Abstract Since the introduction of the one-child policy in China in 1979, many more boys than girls have been born, foreshadowing a sizable bride shortage. What do young men unable to find wives do?
Is prenatal sex selection associated with lower female child mortality?
TLDR
Analysis of the dynamics of child sex ratios between 1980 and 2015 using country-level life table data finds that reductions in numbers of excess female deaths have accompanied increases in missing female births in all countries experiencing the emergence of prenatal sex selection but relative excess female mortality has persisted in some countries but not others.
Recent sex ratio at birth in China
TLDR
China’s sex ratio at birth (SRB) has declined substantially during the past two decades, but the negative effects need to be tackled.
Abortion Around the World: An Overview of Legislation, Measures, Trends, and Consequences
Abstract:Following the May 2018 Irish referendum largely in favour of abortion, only two European countries, Malta and Andorra, still do not give women the right to decide to end a pregnancy in the
Son Preference of Immigrants to the United States: Data from U.S. Birth Certificates, 2004–2013
TLDR
The early twenty-first century the elevated SRB for Chinese and Indian women born in China and India respectively suggests sex selection for higher order births in the U.S. for immigrant women.
If Science Had Come First: A Billion Person Fable for the Ages (A Reply to Comments)
TLDR
The demographic impact of China’s birth planning program, the most determined attempt to control the size of the human species that the world has ever known, is estimated to be nearly 1 billion larger by 2060.
How Do Demographic Trends Change? The Onset of Birth Masculinization in Albania, Georgia, and Vietnam 1990–2005
The theory of demographic transistion assumes the gradual move from a pre-transitional equilibrium of birth and death rates to a new equilibrium corresponding to lower vital rates. While this model
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 134 REFERENCES
On substituting sex preference strategies in East Asia : Does prenatal sex selection reduce postnatal discrimination?
TLDR
The preliminary findings in this analysis support the substitution hypothesis and suggest consideration of policy change and increases in the sex ratio in countries with a strong preference for sons indicate the availability and use of sex-selective abortion.
The determinants of discrimination against daughters in China: Evidence from a provincial-level analysis
TLDR
A provincial-level analysis of the way in which various socio-economic and socio-demographic determinants influence the decision to discriminate against daughters in China helps to illuminate the circumstances that encourage sex-selective behaviours.
Estimating a Dynamic Model of Sex Selection in China
TLDR
A model of fertility choice when parents have access to a sex-selection technology and face a mandated fertility limit is presented and it is found that a couple’s first son is worth 1.42 years of income more than a first daughter, and the premium is highest among less-educated mothers and families engaged in agriculture.
Fertility Decline and Gender Bias in Northern India
Although it is widely acknowledged that the preference for sons is a barrier to a decline in fertility, considerable disagreement exists as to what actually happens to this preference when fertility
Fertility decline and gender bias in northern India.
TLDR
Evidence is presented from northern India to show that the preference for sons is reduced when the ideal family size becomes small, even though it does not completely disappear, which appears to contradict trends in the juvenile sex ratio and the incidence of female feticide that suggest the intensification of gender bias.
Fertility decline and gender bias in
Although it is widely acknowledged that the preference for sons is a barrier to a decline in fertility, considerable disagreement exists as to what actually happens to this preference when fertility
Child Underreporting, Fertility, and Sex Ratio Imbalance in China
TLDR
A new triangulation of evidence indicates that about 19% of children at ages 0–4 were unreported in the 2000 census, more than double that of the 1990 census, and suggests that China’s fertility in the late 1990s (and perhaps beyond) was below officially adjusted levels.
Should prenatal sex selection be restricted? Ethical questions and their implications for research and policy
Sex-selective abortion following prenatal sex testing is so blatantly discriminatory that many observers have, understandably, called on governments to condemn and restrict the practice. Yet ethical
Has the Chinese Birth Planning Program Been Successful in Changing Fertility Preferences? Evidence from Linked Records in Four Counties in Rural Northern China
The success of the Chinese One-Child policy and its rural adaptations in changing reproductive behavior and bringing about a dramatic fertility decline is unquestionable. However, an important but as
‘Missing girls’ in China and India: trends and policy challenges
ABSTRACT Child sex ratios plateaued in China between the censuses of 2000 and 2010, a major change from decades of sharp rises. In India they rose by 1.4 per cent during the intercensal period
...
...