• DOI:10.1007/S10603-006-9027-9
• Corpus ID: 155044543

The average consumer, the unfair commercial practices directive, and the cognitive revolution

@article{Incardona2007TheAC,
  title={The average consumer, the unfair commercial practices directive, and the cognitive revolution},
  author={Rossella Incardona and Cristina Poncib{\`o}},
  journal={Journal of Consumer Policy},
  year={2007},
  volume={30},
  pages={21-38}
}

• Rossella Incardona, C. Poncibò
• Published 27 February 2007
• Business
• Journal of Consumer Policy

This article examines the merit of the test of the average consumer as a basis for judicial and regulatory action. In the first part, we describe the origin of the test, its application in the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and its possible developments. In the second part, we discuss the theoretical grounds of the average consumer test (i.e., information and rationality), drawing upon the studies of cognitive psychology and behavioural economics concerning consumers’ behaviour. The result of our analysis is that we call into serious question the practical workability of the test of the average consumer, which requires consumers an overly demanding standard of rationality and information without dedicating much attention to the real functioning of consumer behaviour. The average consumer may be described as an interesting, anti-paternalistic and, to some extent, useful notion. It is, however, an overly simplistic concept with little correspondence with the real world of individual consumer behaviour and should be reinterpreted more flexibly, or even abandoned to mirror consumer behaviour more effectively.