The authenticity of prophetic Hadïth: a pseudo-problem

  title={The authenticity of prophetic Had{\"i}th: a pseudo-problem},
  author={Wael B. Hallaq},
  journal={Studia Islamica},
  • W. Hallaq
  • Published 1999
  • Philosophy
  • Studia Islamica
L'A. a pour objectif de demontrer que l'etude des erudits occidentaux concernant l'authenticite des «hadith» prophetiques n'a pratiquement plus de raison d'etre. Pour ce faire, il laisse simplement la position traditionnelle parler d'elle-meme. Puis il conclut que les erudits musulmans traditionnels ont resolu le probleme pour nous et qu'il est inutile de poursuivre une quete nee de la non-ecoute de ce que disent ces savants depuis longtemps. 

The Origins of the Shī'a: Identity, Ritual, and Sacred Space in Eighth-Century Kūfa

Part I. Narratives and Methods: 1. Kufa and the classical narratives of early Shi'ism 2. Confronting the source barrier: a new methodology Part II. Case Studies: 3. In the name of God: the Basmala 4.

L’extension du domaine du ṣaḥīḥ. Les procédés d’istiḫrāǧ et d’istidrāk dans les sciences du Hadith

L’interet pour les traditions prophetiques considerees comme authentiques (ṣaḥīḥ) s’accrut considerablement apres la publication des deux celebres Ṣaḥīḥ-s d’al-Buḫārī (m. 256/870) et de Muslim (m.

Matn Criticism and its Role in The Evaluation of Hadith Authenticity

For centuries, Muslim community has taken ‘ulūm al-ḥadīth for granted as a valid method in hadith verification; if a hadith is declared as an authentic hadith after examined using the method, then

From Legal Theory to Erkenntnistheorie: Ibn Taymiyya on Tawātur as the Ultimate Guarantor of Human Cognition

This article presents and analyzes Ibn Taymiyya’s views on tawātur in uṣūl al-fiqh and as the basis of a generalized epistemological system. In legal theory, Ibn Taymiyya expands the umbrella of what

Law and Politics under the Abbasids

Abu Ma'ali al-Juwayni (d.478/1085) lived in a politically tumultuous period. The rise of powerful dynastic families forced the Abbasid Caliph into a position of titular power, and created

Rejoinder to Muhammad Ayub’s 'Qur’an, Hadith and Riba Connotation: A Critique of the Paper by Dr. Mohammad Omar Farooq'

Riba-Interest equation, where riba is blanketly equated with interest, is a major issue in Islamic economics and finance. To justify this equation, hadiths or prophetic narrations as one of the

Gender Issues and the Search for a Hadith: A Journey in Scholarly Due Diligence

Hadith are the second source of the Islamic way of life in general and of Islamic law and jurisprudence in particular. From a religious perspective, whether in matters of faith or practice, the

Sharī'a: Theory, Practice, Transformations

In recent years, Islamic law, or Shari'a, has been appropriated as a tool of modernity in the Muslim world and in the West and has become highly politicised in consequence. Wael Hallaq's magisterial

Bilal Philips as a Proponent of Neo-Traditional Salafism and His Significance for Understanding Salafism in the West

This article aims to explain the ideas and the significance of Dr. Bilal Philips, a prominent ‘Salafi‘preacher, a major proponent of Neo-Traditional Salafism, and how his writings and activities can


Purpose of this study: This article discusses the basic principles that must be possessed by Muslim scholars to understand knowledge and its sources. The term ‘academic crime’ generally refers to the