The Very Repugnant Conclusion
@inproceedings{Arrhenius2003TheVR,
title={The Very Repugnant Conclusion},
author={Gustaf Arrhenius},
year={2003}
}Population axiology concerns how to evaluate populations in regard to their goodness, that is, how to order populations by the relations “is better than” and “is as good as”. This field has been riddled with “paradoxes” which seem to show that our considered beliefs are inconsistent in cases where the number of people and their welfare varies. Already in Derek Parfit’s seminal contribution to the topic, an informal paradox — the Mere Addition Paradox — was presented and later contributions have…
No Paper Link Available
11 Citations
One More Axiological Impossibility Theorem
- 2009
Economics
Population axiology concerns how to evaluate populations in regard to their goodness, that is, how to order populations by the relations “is better than” and “is as good as”. This field has been…
The Impossibility of a Satisfactory Population Ethics
- 2011
Philosophy
Population axiology concerns how to evaluate populations in regard to their goodness, that is, how to order populations by the relations “is better than” and “is as good as”. This field has been…
On the Repugnance of the Repugnant Conclusion
- 2008
Philosophy
: The aim of this paper is to discuss the plausibility of a certain position in the philosophical literature within which the Repugnant Conclusion is treated, not as repugnant, but as an acceptable…
Repugnant conclusions
- 2021
Medicine
Social Choice and Welfare
It is shown that a large set of social orderings that are conventionally understood to escape the repugnant conclusion do not in fact avoid it in all instances, and it is proved that any plausible social ordering implies some instance of the repugsnant conclusion.
Population Ethics for an Imperfect World: Basic Justice, Reasonable Disagreement, and Unavoidable Value Judgements
- 2021
Political Science
Abstract Our collective impact on the environment results from a combination of population, affluence and technology. Human population, 2.6bn in 1950, is predicted to reach 10.9bn by 2100. So much we…
Remarks on Population Ethics
- 2008
Medicine
Discussing relevant issues on population principles is of critical importance because different environmental policies lead to different population sizes as well as different quality of lives involved.
The impossibility of a satisfactory population prospect axiology (independently of Finite Fine-Grainedness)
- 2021
Economics
Philosophical Studies
Arrhenius’s impossibility theorems purport to demonstrate that no population axiology can satisfy each of a small number of intuitively compelling adequacy conditions. However, it has recently been…
Sufficiency and the Threshold Question
- 2020
Economics
The Journal of Ethics
In this paper I address the objection to sufficientarianism posed by Paula Casal and Richard Arneson, that it is hard to conceive of a sufficiency threshold such that distribution is highly important…
The Population Ethics of Belief : In Search of an Epistemic Theory
- 2016
Philosophy
Consider Phoebe and Daphne. Phoebe has credences in 1 million propositions. Daphne, on the other hand, has credences in all of these propositions, but she’s also got credences in 999 million other…
The population ethics of belief: in search of an epistemic Theory X∗
- 2016
Philosophy
Consider Phoebe and Daphne. Phoebe has credences in 1 million propositions. Daphne, on the other hand, has credences in all of these propositions, but she’s also got credences in 999 million other…
10 References
Normative population theory
- 1991
Economics
ConclusionWe have shown, contrary to the claims of Cowen, that average and critical-level utilitarianism, which do not suffer from the repugnant conclusion, do not recommend the killing of people…
An Impossibility Theorem in Population Axiology with Weak Ordering Assumptions
- 1999
Philosophy
It has been known for quite a while now that the on-going project of constructing an acceptable population axiology has gloomy prospects. Already in Derek Parfit’s seminal contribution to the topic,…
What Österberg's Population Theory has in Common with Plato's
- 2001
Philosophy
Jan Österberg is one of the pioneers in the field of population ethics. He started thinking about this issue already in the late 60s and he has developed one of the most original and interesting…
What Should We Do About Future Generations?
- 1989
Philosophy
Economics and Philosophy
Parfit's requirements for an ideal Theory X cannot be fully met since the Mere Addition Principle and Non-Antiegalitarianism imply the Repugnant Conclusion: Theory X does not exist. However, since…
Normative population theory
- 1989
Economics
Social choice and welfare
The optimal population is what an individual would prefer if he had to sequentially live out each life in his choice and the ideal life need not maximize cardinal utility.
An Impossibility Theorem for Welfarist Axiologies
- 2000
Economics
Economics and Philosophy
A search is under way for a theory that can accommodate our intuitions in population axiology. The object of this search has proved elusive. This is not surprising since, as we shall see, any…
Future generations : A challenge for moral theory
- 2000
Philosophy, Computer Science
A search is underway for a theory that can accommodate the authors' intuitions in regard to moral duties to future generations and the object of this search has prove that Bayesian inference can be modified for this purpose.
Possible People " in Essays on Bioethics
- 1993
Possible People " in Essays on Bioethics
Jesper Ryberg, Topics on Population Ethics, Ph.D. Diss
- 1996
Jesper Ryberg, Topics on Population Ethics, Ph.D. Diss