The Venus effect in real life and in photographs

@article{Bertamini2010TheVE,
  title={The Venus effect in real life and in photographs},
  author={Marco Bertamini and Rebecca Lawson and Luke Jones and Madeline Winters},
  journal={Attention, Perception, \& Psychophysics},
  year={2010},
  volume={72},
  pages={1948-1964}
}
The toilet of Venus is the subject of many paintings. Typically, Venus appears with a small mirror in which her face is visible. Observers tend to say that Venus is admiring herself in a mirror, even when the location of the mirror makes this impossible. We demonstrate that the Venus effect is not specific to paintings by showing that it occurs in real life (Experiment 1) and in photographs (Experiments 1-4). The original description of the effect implied that observers describe Venus as seeing… 

Understanding what is visible in a mirror or through a window before and after updating the position of an object

TLDR
Results show that performance on the paper and pencil task was better than expected, probably because of the asymmetric nature of the object used, but an additional cost in reasoning about mirrors was confirmed.

Reasoning About Visibility in Mirrors: A Comparison Between a Human Observer and a Camera

TLDR
It is suggested that social mechanisms may be involved in perspective-taking in reasoning rather than in automatic attention allocation, and an advantage for evaluating a human viewpoint as opposed to an artificial viewpoint.

The rubber hand illusion in a mirror

Through the looking-glass: Objects in the mirror are less real

TLDR
The results suggest that reflected information is easily discounted when processing images of natural Scenes, because equivalent object changes occurred in the nonreflected and reflected parts of the scene.

What fits into a mirror: naïve beliefs about the field of view.

TLDR
The studies presented here confirm that humans have difficulty dealing with the role of the viewpoint in reflections and consistently prove that predictions are dominated by two patterns and a frontal bias.

Exploring non-reversing magic mirrors for screen-based augmented reality systems

TLDR
The perceptual differences between these two mirror visualization concepts are discussed and a first comparative study in the context of Magic Mirror anatomy teaching is presented.

How Do Children Reason About Mirrors? A Comparison Between Adults, Typically Developed Children, and Children With Autism Spectrum Disorder

TLDR
The ASD group made relatively more mistakes of ignoring the viewpoint compared to the other groups and underestimated how many objects were visible in the teddy bear condition that is when the viewpoint was an inanimate object.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 15 REFERENCES

The Venus Effect: People's Understanding of Mirror Reflections in Paintings

We propose the term ‘Venus effect’ for a common phenomenon in picture perception. It occurs when a picture shows an actor and a mirror that are not placed along the observer's line of sight, for

Titian's Pictures of the Toilet of Venus and Their Copies

It was Titian who reviving the antique theme of the Toilet of Venus1 popularized it in the Renaissance. The subject matter to which he returned, the goddess at her toilet attended by one or more

Running head : REFLECTIONS IN MIRRORS The eyes have it : Naïve beliefs about reflections

Using a paper-and-pencil task, undergraduate students predicted when a character would be able to see her reflection in a planar mirror. Experiment 1 showed that participants expected the character

Naive optics: Predicting and perceiving reflections in mirrors.

TLDR
Undergraduate students predicted what would be made visible by a planar mirror and found that when approaching a mirror from the side, participants expected to see their reflection in the mirror earlier than they actually would.

Art and illusion

On what people know about images on mirrors

Errors in Judging Information about Reflections in Mirrors

We investigated people's perception and knowledge of planar mirror reflections. People were accurate at deciding when they could first see their reflection as they approached a mirror from the side,

Overestimation of the projected size of objects on the surface of mirrors and windows.

TLDR
Judges of the size of projections of objects on mirrors and windows are treated in the same way and that observers cannot perceive such projections as distal objects are suggested.

Naive optics: understanding the geometry of mirror reflections.

TLDR
Naive optics is a promising venue to further knowledge of how observers understand basic laws of physics, and it is suggested that the phenomenon is widespread and refractory to training.

The development of three spatial perspective-taking rules.

FLAVELL, JOHN H.; FLAVELL, ELEANOR R.; GREEN, FRANCES L.; and WILCOX, SHARON A. The Development of Three Spatial Perspective-taking Rules. CHILD DEVELOPMENT, 1981, 52, 356358. Children of 42, 5, and