The Venn-MacColl Dispute in Nature

@article{Verburgt2020TheVD,
  title={The Venn-MacColl Dispute in Nature},
  author={Lukas M. Verburgt},
  journal={History and Philosophy of Logic},
  year={2020},
  volume={41},
  pages={244 - 251}
}
During 1881, the British logicians John Venn and Hugh MacColl engaged in a brief dispute in Nature about ‘symbolical logic’. The letters to the editor shed interesting light on the early reception of MacColl’s contributions to logic and his position in the logical community of the Victorian era. Drawing on the correspondence between Venn and William Stanley Jevons, this paper analyzes the background and context of these letters, adding to the recent interest in the social dimensions of the… 

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 28 REFERENCES

Are other logics possible? Maccoll's logic and some english reactions, 1905-1912

By the mid-1900s Hugh MacColl had published enough in the way of papers and notes on logic that a more connected presentation could be made. Accordingly, he reworked several items into a book

Hugh Maccoll and the birth of logical pluralism

A survey of the life of Hugh MacColl

Introduction Contrary to a widespread assumption the modern history of modal logic did not start with C. I. Lewis’ Survey of Symbolic Logic [Lewis 1918]. His eminent work was preceded by some 20

Hugh Maccoll and the German algebra of logic

In this paper the early reception of Hugh MacCool's logical system up to the 1890s, by the German algebraist of logic, Ernst Schroder, is investigated. In his monumental Vorlesungen uber die Algebra

Hugh MacColl and George Boole on Hypotheticals

Hugh MacColl (1837–1909), the father of formal non-classical logic, reported that he had developed his early formal system—published as papers in the journals Educational Times, Proceedings of the

Recent Mathematico-Logical Memoirs

THE Boolian reform of logical science is at las beginning to manifest itself and to bear the first-fruits of controversy. Thirty years ago Boole's remarkable memoirs were treated as striking but

Symbolical Logic

I AM afraid I share the proverbial obtuseness of my countrymen in the matter of jokes. I really did not at first see the point of Mr. Venn's humorous suggestion that “an attitude of slight social

Lewis Carroll's logic

  • A. Moktefi
  • Art
    British Logic in the Nineteenth Century
  • 2008

Symbolic Logic

MANY who are interested in the progress of logical science have looked forward to the appearance of this long-expected work as one likely to give them a logical treat. They will not be disappointed.

Beyond Case-Studies: History as Philosophy

Dissatisfaction with hasty philosophical generalizations from a small number of conveniently chosen case-studies has contributed significantly to a widespread disillusionment with the whole