The Validity of the Neale and Kendler Model-Fitting Approach in Examining the Etiology of Comorbidity

@article{Rhee2004TheVO,
  title={The Validity of the Neale and Kendler Model-Fitting Approach in Examining the Etiology of Comorbidity},
  author={Soo Hyun Rhee and John K. Hewitt and Jeffrey M Lessem and Michael C. Stallings and Robin P. Corley and Michael C. Neale},
  journal={Behavior Genetics},
  year={2004},
  volume={34},
  pages={251-265}
}
Given that knowledge regarding the etiology of comorbidity between disorders can have a significant impact on research regarding the classification, treatment, and etiology of the disorders, the ability to reject incorrect hypotheses regarding the causes of comorbidity is very important. A simulation study was conducted to assess the validity of the Neale and Kendler (1995) model-fitting approach in examining the etiology of comorbidity between two disorders. First, data were simulated under… 

Figures, Tables, and Topics from this paper

The Validity of Analyses Testing the Etiology of Comorbidity Between Two Disorders: Comparisons of Disorder Prevalences in Families
TLDR
The results predicted by Klein and Riso and the results derived from the simulated datasets matched in most cases, but there were several notable discrepancies, which may be due to variations in the model parameters although the KR predictions are valid tests of the model for some model parameter sets.
The validity of analyses testing the etiology of comorbidity between two disorders: a review of family studies.
TLDR
The validity of family prevalence analyses in testing alternative comorbidity models is examined to suggest that some analyses may be valid tests of the alternate forms model, but that none of the analyses are valid Tests of the correlated liabilities model or the three independent disorders model.
Testing hypotheses regarding the causes of comorbidity: examining the underlying deficits of comorbid disorders.
TLDR
The validity of a method commonly used to test alternative hypotheses regarding the causes of comorbidity was examined; the ability to distinguish the correct model decreased as the sample size and the correlation between the underlying deficits and the symptom scores decreased, suggesting that the issue of power should be considered carefully.
The co-morbidity of anxiety and depression in the perspective of genetic epidemiology. A review of twin and family studies
TLDR
The theory of Gray and McNaughton that neuroticism is a shared risk factor for anxiety and depression is supported and a model is proposed to simultaneously investigate the influence of neuroticism and recursive interconnections on co-morbidity.
A Bivariate Mann‐Whitney Approach for Unraveling Genetic Variants and Interactions Contributing to Comorbidity
TLDR
A bivariate Mann‐Whitney (BMW) approach is proposed to unravel genetic variants and interactions contributing to comorbidity, as well as those unique to eachComorbid condition, and found BMW outperformed two commonly adopted approaches in a variety of underlying disease and comor bidity models.
Cannabis and Depression: A Twin Model Approach to Co-morbidity
TLDR
Of the 13 different co-morbidity models, two fit equally well: CUD causes MDD and Random Multiformity of CUD, and both fit substantially better than the Correlated Liabilities model.
Test of Alternative Hypotheses Explaining the Comorbidity Between Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder and Conduct Disorder
TLDR
The results suggest that correlated risk factors are a better explanation for the comorbidity between ADHD and CD than a third, independent ADHD+CD subtype.
A common factor for childhood syndromes and disorders : empirical evaluation and associated risk factors
There is strong evidence of excessive levels multivariate comorbidity for the major childhood internalizing and externalizing syndromes and / or disorders. The overall aim of this thesis is to
A twin study of depression and nicotine dependence: shared liability or causal relationship?
Evidence of Overlapping Genetic Diathesis of Panic Attacks and Gastrointestinal Disorders in a Sample of Male Twin Pairs
TLDR
PA and GD comorbidity can be explained by overlapping genetic factors and not overlapping environmental factors, and the presence of GD may be informative for genetic studies of panic.
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 29 REFERENCES
The validity of analyses testing the etiology of comorbidity between two disorders: a review of family studies.
TLDR
The validity of family prevalence analyses in testing alternative comorbidity models is examined to suggest that some analyses may be valid tests of the alternate forms model, but that none of the analyses are valid Tests of the correlated liabilities model or the three independent disorders model.
Origins of comorbidity between conduct and affective disorders.
OBJECTIVE This analysis used methods of structural equation modeling to assess the extent to which comorbidity between conduct and affective disorders could be explained by (1) common or correlated
Inferring the direction of causation in cross‐sectional twin data: Theoretical and empirical considerations
TLDR
A recent multivariate extension of the classical twin study in theory allows the inference of the direction of causation between correlated traits solely using cross‐sectional data, but it is concluded that the method has a number of biases and limitations.
Models of comorbidity for multifactorial disorders.
TLDR
Of the models that fit the data, correlated liabilities, MD causes GAD, and reciprocal causation seem best; MD appears to be a source of liability for GAD.
Testing hypotheses about direction of causation using cross-sectional family data
TLDR
Cross-sectional family data may prove useful in cases where conventional methods to establish causality, by intervention, by prospective study, or by measurement of instrumental variables, are infeasible economically, ethically or practically.
Comorbidity: concepts, claims and choices
The presence of comorbidity may distort research findings but, if properly dealt with, it also provides important research opportunities to test hypotheses about causal mechanisms. Seven possible
The Virginia Twin Study of Adolescent Behavioral Development. Influences of age, sex, and impairment on rates of disorder.
TLDR
The prevalence rates and patterns of findings from this study of twins are consistent with those of other epidemiological studies, supporting previous findings of few differences in rates of psychiatric disorder between twins and singletons.
Familial transmission of substance use disorders.
TLDR
Elevation in risk of drug disorders among the relatives of probands with drug disorders across a wide range of specific substances, including opioids, cocaine, cannabis, and alcohol, which is largely independent from the familial aggregation of both alcoholism and antisocial personality disorder.
Methodology for Genetic Studies of Twins and Families
Preface. List of Figures. List of Tables. 1. The Scope of Genetic Analyses. 2. Data Summary. 3. Biometrical Genetics. 4. Matrix Algebra. 5. Path Analysis and Structural Equations. 6. LISREL Models
...
1
2
3
...