The Use and Abuse of P52: Papyrological Pitfalls in the Dating of the Fourth Gospel

@article{Nongbri2005TheUA,
  title={The Use and Abuse of P52: Papyrological Pitfalls in the Dating of the Fourth Gospel},
  author={Brent Nongbri},
  journal={Harvard Theological Review},
  year={2005},
  volume={98},
  pages={23 - 48}
}
  • B. Nongbri
  • Published 1 January 2005
  • History
  • Harvard Theological Review
The thesis of this paper is simple: we as critical readers of the New Testament often use John Rylands Greek Papyrus 3.457, also known as P52, ininappropriate ways, and we should stop doing so. A recent example will illustrate the problem. In what is on the whole a superb commentary on John's gospel, D. Moody Smith writes the following about the date of John: For a time, particularly in the early part of the twentieth century, the possibility that John was not written, or at least not published… 
The Dating of New Testament Papyri
The narrow dating of some of the early New Testament papyri and the methodological approach that is used must be brought into question in the light of the acknowledged difficulties with
Papyri and the Social World of the New Testament
In this book, Sabine Huebner explores the world of the protagonists of the New Testament and the early Christians using the rich papyrological evidence from Roman Egypt. This gives us unparalleled
Descriptions and the materiality of texts
This article builds on the notions of thick and thin description elaborated by Geertz and looks at what descriptive methods have been used in the field of papyrology, a sub-discipline of classics
Dating Early Christian Papyri: Old and New Methods – Introduction
  • R. Mazza
  • History
    Journal for the Study of the New Testament
  • 2019
This article provides a methodological introduction to the issues and questions raised in the dossier: How can we attribute a date to ancient papyri when it is not indicated in the text? What methods
THE GOSPEL OF THE ACTS OF JOHN: ITS RELATION TO THE FOURTH GOSPEL
This chapter focuses on the Gospel of the Acts of John (GAJ), which is found in chapters 87-105 of the Acts of John . Chapters in the GAJ contain a complete gospel narrative, which has been preserved
Perspectives on Immortality and Eternal Life in the Book of Wisdom and the Gospel of John: A Conceptual Analysis Based on Metaphorical Structuring
The similarities between the Fourth Gospel and wisdom literature have been addressed by many scholars. This study is also intended to continue along this line by looking at the particular link
Palaeographic Analysis of Codices from the Early Christian Period: A Point of Method
  • B. Nongbri
  • History
    Journal for the Study of the New Testament
  • 2019
It is often said that palaeographic analysis of Greek literary manuscripts from the Roman era has progressed from an aesthetic judgment to more of a science, thanks largely to increased data (in the
The Date and Content of P. Antinoopolis 12 (0232)
P. Antinoopolis 12 (Aland 0232), a miniature codex containing remnants of 2 John, was considered by C. H. Roberts to be our earliest copy of this short epistle (third century) and also evidence of an
The Political Meaning of a Cipher—John 21:11
The mystery of the one-hundred and fifty-three fish in John 21 has been discussed for centuries. Unlike previous religious or theological readings based on ancient gematria, the claim of this article
On the Functions of Miniaturizing Books in Jewish Religion
  • M. Schleicher
  • Philosophy
    Postscripts: The Journal of Sacred Texts, Cultural Histories, and Contemporary Contexts
  • 2018
The purpose of this article is to offer a functional approach to miniaturized books as a religious phenomenon. Moving beyond mere descriptions of size and aesthetic quality, it asks about the
...
...