The UN Committee Against Torture: Human Rights Monitoring and the Legal Recognition of Cruelty

  title={The UN Committee Against Torture: Human Rights Monitoring and the Legal Recognition of Cruelty},
  author={Tobias Kelly},
  journal={Human Rights Quarterly},
  pages={777 - 800}
  • T. Kelly
  • Published 2009
  • Sociology
  • Human Rights Quarterly
Focusing on the Committee Against Torture, this article argues that human rights monitoring can hide as much as it reveals. In particular, monitoring should be understood as a “second order” process that displaces the discussion of the causes and consequences of violence in favor of a focus on the systems that are supposed to monitor cruelty. In this process, measurements, monitoring, and prevention are in danger of becoming merged. As such, the ways in which the Committee Against Torture… Expand
Two Cheers for Ritual: The UN Committee Against Torture
Abstract:This paper asks, what might it mean to take seriously the claim that human rights processes are a form of ritual? It does so through an ethnographic analysis of the work of the UN CommitteeExpand
Interpretation of Article One of the Convention against Torture in Light of the Practice and Jurisprudence of International Bodies
Torture is one of the most brutal and horrendous human right violation, constituting direct attack on the core of human dignity. Though a number of international legal frameworks incorporate theExpand
The cause of human rights: doubts about torture, law, and ethics at the United Nations
Although human rights practitioners are often seen as being distinguished by their dogmatic claims or their technical fixations, there is a danger of ignoring the hesitations and confusions that alsoExpand
Fracturing the “Exception”: The Legal Sanctioning of Violent Interrogation Methods in Israel since 1987
This article examines the legal constructs governing the use of violent interrogation methods in Israel since 1987. It explores the shift from a sweeping suspension of the prohibition on torture to aExpand
Human Rights and Policing: Exigency or Incongruence?
The juncture of human rights and policing is a relatively recent field of scholarship. It tends to explain the relationship between policing and human rights as one of exigency and necessity,Expand
The Legitimacy of American Human Rights Conduct in the War on Terror
This thesis examines the effect American human rights conduct during the war on terror had on three international human rights norms: torture, habeas corpus, and rendition for the purposes ofExpand
The Feminist Expansion of the Prohibition of Torture: Towards a Post-Liberal International Human Rights Law?
International human rights law (IHRL), discourse and activism have been the subject of well-known critiques. Two categories of critique are closely linked to the liberal ideology underlying the humanExpand
Boundaries of Torture
In Part II we look at the boundaries of torture and the ethical issues they bring to light. In this chapter I employ Nel Noddings’ notion of the three components of evil as a framework of analysis.Expand
Why the torture taboo matters
Torture is one of the most prohibited practices in international society and has become a symbol of cruel and unnecessary suffering. Despite this absolute prohibition, torture is widely practiced byExpand
Norms and Legitimacy in International Society
The purpose of this chapter is to suggest how we might both theorize and measure the effects of the defection of the Bush administration from international human rights norms during the war onExpand


Torture : a collection
Torture is perhaps the most unequivocally banned practice in the world today. Yet within six weeks after September 11, articles began appearing suggesting that torture might be "required" in order toExpand
Constructing a Global Law-Violence against Women and the Human Rights System
  • S. Merry
  • Sociology
  • Law & Social Inquiry
  • 2003
This ethnographic analysis of one of the core human rights conventions suggests that despite the lack of enforceability of this convention and its operation within the framework of state sovereignty,Expand
The future of UN human rights treaty monitoring
1. The UN human rights treaty system: a system in crisis? James Crawford and Philip Alston Part I. The UN Human Rights Monitoring System in Action: 2. Individual chains in a world of massiveExpand
Violence, Suffering and Human Rights
This article develops a trenchant critique of the rise of human rights as the main universal standard against which to judge violence and suffering. It begins with a case study of an act of massExpand
Human Rights at the UN: The Political History of Universal Justice
IntroductionPart I: Human Rights Foundation in the First Half of the Twentieth Century 1. First Expressions of International Human Rights Ideas 2. The Decline of Human Rights between World Wars 3.Expand
From Resistance to Renewal: The Third World, Social Movements and The Expansion Of International Institutions
One of the most significant aspects of 20th century international law is its institutionalization, through international courts and bureaucracies, from international economic law to human rights law.Expand
The Un Human Rights Treaty System: Universality at the Crossroads
Introduction. Overdue Reports The Consideration of a State Party's Record in the Absence of a Report Periodicity of Reports Focussed and Consolidated Reporting Inadequate Reports Special ReportsExpand
Social reconstruction and the radicalization of development : aid as a relation of global liberal governance.
That democratic societies do not fall into conflict has become an axiom of contemporary international relations. Liberal societies, however, do not properly exist along the troubled margins of theExpand
Caring for victims of torture
The science and politics of rehabilitating torture survivors: an overview and countertransference and ethical principles for treatment of torture survivors and Voices from the Field: Politics and Caregiving. Expand
International Law in a World of Liberal States
International law and international politics cohabit the same conceptual space. Together they comprise the rules and the reality of 'the international system', an intellectual construct that lawyers,Expand