The Type-Token Distinction and Four Problems with Propertarian IP Justifications

  title={The Type-Token Distinction and Four Problems with Propertarian IP Justifications},
  author={Wojciech Gamrot},
Propertarian justifications of intellectual property postulate the appropriation of various entities, often called patterns, designs, or technologies. These must be immaterial and should not be confused with material structures that embody them. Hence two classes of objects are distinguished. It is convenient to refer to them as types and tokens. The type must involve a condition defining which material structures should be considered its tokens. For an IP regime to be economically meaningful… Expand


A Lockean Theory of Intellectual Property
What follows is a brief introduction to the domain or subject matter of intellectual property, an examination of the most widely supported rule-utilitarian argument, a defense of a new Lockean model,Expand
The justification of intellectual property: Contemporary philosophical disputes
  • K. Himma
  • Political Science, Computer Science
  • J. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol.
  • 2008
The issue of whether the state is morally justified in affording content-creators a legal right to exclude others from the content of their creations is a sharply contested issue in informationExpand
Two Challenges to the Idea of Intellectual Property
Although the expression 'intellectual property' is widely used, it could be argued that the very idea of intellectual property is incoherent. After all, ideas are not like land, houses or clothing;Expand
Copyright as Intellectual Property Privilege
We often call copyright a species of intellectual property, abbreviating it, "IP." This brief paper suggests that we consider copyright as another sort of IP: an intellectual privilege. ThoughExpand
Could There be a Right to Own Intellectual Property?
Intellectual property typically involves claims of ownership of types, rather than particulars. In this article I argue that this difference in ontology makes an important moral difference. InExpand
Abstraction, Filtration, and Comparison in Patent Law
This essay explores how copyright's doctrine of abstraction, filtration, and comparison is being used in patent law, and how that use could be improved and why the application is different for design and utility patents. Expand
On the Impossibility of Intellectual Property
The concept of intellectual property (IP) has been variously criticized as incompatible with natural rights and detrimental to the dissemination of innovations. In this paper I argue that it can beExpand
The Making of a New Copyright Lockean
I. INTRODUCTION: TWO FATAL FLAWS A. The Ubiquity of Lockean Justifications in Copyright Discourse B. A Rejoinder to Contemporary Copyright Lockeans: The Two Fatal Flaws II. INDISPUTABLE LOCKEANExpand
Natural Intellectual Property Rights and the Public Domain
No natural rights theory justifies strong intellectual property rights. More specifically, no theory within the entire domain of natural rights thinking – encompassing classical liberalism,Expand
Intellectual Property, Innovation, and Social Progress: The Case Against Incentive Based Arguments
After a brief introduction to the subject matter of intellectual property, an internal and external critique of Anglo-American systems of intellectual property protection will be offered.9Expand