The Trouble with Trees: Afforestation Plans for Africa.

@article{Bond2019TheTW,
  title={The Trouble with Trees: Afforestation Plans for Africa.},
  author={William J. Bond and Nicola Stevens and Guy F. Midgley and Caroline E. R. Lehmann},
  journal={Trends in ecology \& evolution},
  year={2019}
}
Extensive tree planting is widely promoted for reducing atmospheric CO2. In Africa, 1 million km2, mostly of grassy biomes, have been targeted for 'restoration' by 2030. The target is based on the erroneous assumption that these biomes are deforested and degraded. We discuss the pros and cons of exporting fossil fuel emission problems to Africa. 

Figures and Topics from this paper

Alternative Biome States in Terrestrial Ecosystems.
TLDR
The theory as applied to the puzzle of nonforested (open) biomes growing in climates that are warm and wet enough to support forests (alternative biome states, ABSs) is introduced.
With Power Comes Responsibility – A Rangelands Perspective on Forest Landscape Restoration
  • S. Vetter
  • Geography
    Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
  • 2020
Tree planting has long been promoted to avert climate change and has received renewed impetus in recent years with the Bonn Challenge and related forest restoration initiatives guided by the forest
The long-term performance of 35 tree species of sudanian West Africa in pure and mixed plantings
TLDR
This work inventoried the survival and growth of 5817 trees belonging to 35 species planted more than 25 years ago in pure and mixed plantings and retained 13 species in the list of woody species of interest for planting in the Sudanese zone of West Africa.
People plant trees for utility more often than for biodiversity or carbon
Abstract Tree planting is both a promising and controversial solution to climate change and biodiversity loss. However, this controversy is largely theoretical because we lack detailed information of
Seeing the Forests as well as the (Trillion) Trees in Corporate Climate Strategies
Largely driven by the corporate sector, the recent surge of interest in trees as a solution to climate change has a distinct emphasis on planting trees. Realizing anticipated benefits will require
Making Way for Trees? Changes in Land-Use, Habitats and Protected Areas in Great Britain under “Global Tree Restoration Potential”
Numerous tree planting initiatives have been launched worldwide, based on the idea that carbon capture by trees can help to limit global warming. A recent study estimated the additional tree canopy
Does the Introduction of N2-Fixing Trees in Forest Plantations on Tropical Soils Ameliorate Low Fertility and Enhance Carbon Sequestration via Interactions Between Biota and Nutrient Availability? Case Studies From Central Africa and South America
Plant and/or crop growth rely on nutrient dynamics driven by specific soil biota in different environments. This mini-review aims to provide an overview of interactions between soil organisms,
Limits to resilience of Afroalpine vegetation to grazing and burning: a case study of grasses from the Drakensberg Mountain Centre, southern Africa
TLDR
Taxonomic diversity and composition of DMC Afroalpine grasslands was relatively unaffected by moderate grazing and intense burning, although heavy grazing had a largely detrimental impact, with its ubiquity across the DMC a major cause for concern.
Misinterpretation of Asian savannas as degraded forest can mislead management and conservation policy under climate change
Abstract Savannas cover large areas of tropical Asia. Yet, these ecosystems are threatened by intense land-use and governmental afforestation initiatives. They are vulnerable to woody encroachment
Large uncertainties in future biome changes in Africa call for flexible climate adaptation strategies.
TLDR
It is concluded that substantial future biome changes due to climate and CO2 changes are likely across Africa, and adaptation strategies must be highly flexible.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 22 REFERENCES
Restoring natural forests is the best way to remove atmospheric carbon
Plans to triple the area of plantations will not meet 1.5 °C climate goals. New natural forests can, argue Simon L. Lewis, Charlotte E. Wheeler and colleagues.Plans to triple the area of plantations
Where Tree Planting and Forest Expansion are Bad for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services
Misperceptions about the world's grassy biomes contribute to their alarming rates of loss due to conversion for agriculture and tree plantations, as well as to forest encroachment. To illustrate the
Trading Water for Carbon with Biological Carbon Sequestration
TLDR
This work combined field research, synthesis of more than 600 observations, and climate and economic modeling to document substantial losses in stream flow, and increased soil salinization and acidification, with afforestation in tree plantations.
Grasslands may be more reliable carbon sinks than forests in California
Although natural terrestrial ecosystems have sequestered ∼25% of anthropogenic CO2 emissions, the long-term sustainability of this key ecosystem service is under question. Forests have traditionally
Ecosystem services from southern African woodlands and their future under global change
TLDR
The net ecological response to these changes is poorly constrained, as they act in different directions, and differentially on trees and grasses, leading to uncertainty in future service provision.
Global Cooling by Grassland Soils of the Geological Past and Near Future
Major innovations in the evolution of vegetation such as the Devonian origin of forests created new weathering regimes and soils (Alfisols, Histosols) that increased carbon consumption and
Potential for low-cost carbon dioxide removal through tropical reforestation
Achieving the 1.5–2.0 °C temperature targets of the Paris climate agreement requires not only reducing emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) but also increasing removals of GHGs from the
Ecological limits to terrestrial biological carbon dioxide removal
Terrestrial biological atmospheric carbon dioxide removal (BCDR) through bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECS), afforestation/reforestation, and forest and soil management is a family of
Biophysical and economic limits to negative CO2 emissions
To have a >50% chance of limiting warming below 2 °C, most recent scenarios from integrated assessment models (IAMs) require large-scale deployment of negative emissions technologies (NETs). These
The global tree restoration potential
TLDR
There is room for an extra 0.9 billion hectares of canopy cover, which could store 205 gigatonnes of carbon in areas that would naturally support woodlands and forests, which highlights global tree restoration as one of the most effective carbon drawdown solutions to date.
...
1
2
3
...