• Corpus ID: 14466551

The Tradespace Exploration Paradigm

  title={The Tradespace Exploration Paradigm},
  author={Adam M. Ross and Daniel E. Hastings},
Over the past five years, researchers working on a number of system design projects in the Space Systems, Policy, and Architecture Research Consortium (SSPARC) at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) have developed a process of value-focused, broad tradespace exploration for the development of space systems. The broad tradespace framework has provided insights into communicating and quantifying the impact of changing requirements, uncertainty, and system properties such as… 

Figures from this paper

Combining tradespace exploration with system dynamics to explore future space architectures
This work proposes a merger of Tradespace Exploration with System Dynamics modeling techniques in a complementary approach. It tests the value of this mixed method for modeling the multiplicity of
Role for Interactive Tradespace Exploration in Multi- Stakeholder Negotiations
Preliminary results indicate the method to be a rapid and beneficial technique, which generated compromise alternatives, guided the elicitation of previously unarticulated information, and resulted in increased confidence and solution buy-in of participating stakeholders.
Quantifying Flexibility in Tradespace Exploration: Value Weighted Filtered Outdegree
A metric to identify valuably flexible designs in a tradespace, Value Weighted Filtered Outdegree, is presented and applied to a satellite radar case application and is able to identify design in the tradespaces that would not have been identified with existing tradespACE analysis metrics.
An Iterative Subsystem-Generated Approach to Populating a Satellite Constellation Tradespace
This paper presents a process used to populate and analyze the tradespace for an example constellation of Earth observation satellites, by analyzing individual subsystem level trades in parallel and capturing system level interactions at key nodal checkpoints.
Scenario planning in dynamic multi-attribute tradespace exploration
A methodology for specifying and analyzing large numbers of alternative system timelines and providing a basis for evaluating system evolution strategies that enable sustainment of value delivery across potential timelines is presented.
Tradespace Exploration of Space Settlement Architectures Using Long-term Cost and Benefit Metrics
The application of the SLGR metric is shown to a (future) long-term Mars base campaign using only Apollo-derived notional elements without ISRU, and to a case of a human settlement on Mars using future in-situ resource utilization technologies.
Tradespace exploration for space system architectures : a weighted graph framework
A framework for modeling relationships based on the evaluation of a pre-existing tradespace for analyzing architecture change decisions is proposed, using a directed, weighted 'tradespace graph' that serves as a model of the architecture decision making process.
Tradespace investigation of strategic design factors for large space telescopes
This paper offers a quantitative approach for modeling some of the stakeholder influences relevant to large telescope array designs—the linkages between a given mission and the wider NASA community.
Assessing Changeability in Aerospace Systems Architecting and Design Using Dynamic Multi-Attribute Tradespace Exploration
The analysis approach introduced in this paper is shown to be a powerful concept for focusing discussion, design, and assessment of the changeability of aerospace systems.
Foundational and Precautionary Considerations for Value-Driven Tradespace Exploration and Analysis
A synthesized set of core mechanics that make up common value-driven tradespace exploration and analysis techniques, with a set of associated processes are described, to foster continued dialogue about appropriate application of TSE&A and avenues for further research and development.


Multi-Attribute Tradespace Exploration with Concurrent Design for Space System Conceptual Design
Preliminary results indicate that this process can improve the quality of communication to more quickly resolve project ambiguity, and enable the engineer to discover better value designs for multiple stakeholders.
Multi-Attribute Tradespace Exploration as Front End for Effective Space System Design
A process is introduced and described to capture decision maker preferences and use them to generate and evaluate a multitude of space system designs, while providing a common metric that can be easily communicated throughout the design enterprise.
Applications of Uncertainty Analysis Applied to Architecture Selection of Satellite Systems
The application is presented of a framework for managing a tradespace of architectures not through traditional effectiveness measures such as cost and performance, but instead through a quantitative analysis of the embedded uncertainty in each potential space system architecture.
Multi-attribute tradespace exploration and its application to evolutionary acquisition
The Air Force has recently embraced Evolutionary Acquisition (EA) as its acquisition strategy of choice. EA is an especially difficult method of acquisition and presents some extraordinary challenges
Modularity as an enabler for evolutionary acquisition
The end of the cold war witnessed several significant changes in the defense acquisition environment. Budgets declined and the scope of missions expanded. At first, the DoD did not respond well to
This study uses new methods to explore the theoretical performance of over a hundred possible orbital transfer vehicle designs. The designs have varying propulsion types, fuel mass fractions, and
Evaluating the Cost and Risk Impacts of Launch Choices
A method is presented for quantitatively assessing the generalized cost and risk impacts to a space system architecture of a restrictive government launch policy and application is made to the case
Tools for evolutionary acquisition : a study of Multi-Attribute Tradespace Exploration (MATE) applied to the Space Based Radar (SBR)
In general MATE was shown to be useful to any acquisition effort that derives its benefit from a networked approach and is of sufficient technical complexity as to make tradeoff decisions opaque to casual analysis.
Systems Engineering: An Approach to Information-Based Design
(NOTE: Each chapter begins with The Purpose of This Chapter and concludes with Summary, References, and Problems.) Foreword. 1. Introduction to Engineering Design and Decision Making. The Engineering
Measuring the Value of Designing for Uncertain Future Downward Budget Instabilities
A method is presented for understanding the behavior of space system program costs under downward annual budget pressure, with a real options analysis incorporated for determining the maximum worth