The Three Critical Flaws of Critical Geopolitics: Towards a Neo-Classical Geopolitics

  title={The Three Critical Flaws of Critical Geopolitics: Towards a Neo-Classical Geopolitics},
  author={Terrence W. Haverluk and Kevin M. Beauchemin and Bruce A. Mueller},
  pages={19 - 39}
Critical geopolitics is the dominant school of geopolitics in contemporary geography. Critical geopolitics is a body of radical scholarship that emerged in the 1980s that attempts to move beyond classic geopolitics. In order to resuscitate geopolitics, critical geopoliticians had to distance themselves from the imperialist, racist, and environmentally determinist geopolitics of the 1940s. In doing so, however, critical geopoliticians created a body of scholarship that omits important… 
Geoeconomic Analysis and the Limits of Critical Geopolitics: A New Engagement with Edward Luttwak
ABSTRACT There is a new wave of interest in the interplay between commerce and strategy, and ‘geoeconomics’ is again becoming a key concept in policy analysis. In the academia, however, since the
From a critique to self-evolving (inter)discipline: Critical geopolitics vs. popular geopolitics
The paper shows the development of critical geopolitics from its conceptualisation by O Tuathail, Dalby and Routledge at the end of the last century up to its critics and development of phenomena
Neoclassical geopolitics: Preliminary theoretical principles and methodological guidelines
The paper is aimed at making geopolitical studies and neoclassical geopolitics equivalent. In this sense, the objectives are conceptual and operational, comprising an original definition of
Refracting (geo)political choices in the Arctic
Abstract Geopolitics as a field was originally intended as a theoretical modelling of the relationship between fixed geographical circumstances and political choice. Now, the field is largely
Geopolítica crítica: alcances, límites y aportes para los estudios internacionales en Sudamérica
The purpose of this paper is to discuss the concept of critical geopolitics in epistemological, theoretical and methodological terms, and its connection with international studies. It will analyze
Putting the “geo” into geopolitics: a heuristic framework and the example of Australian foreign policy
This paper aims to contribute to the understanding of geopolitics by offering a heuristic framework to understand the “geo” in geopolitics. The approach integrates economic and strategic processes
Environmental Determinism as Orientalism: The Geo-Political Ecology of Crisis in the Middle East
From ‘Resource Curse’ to ‘Climate Conflict’, more and more analyses of the current crisis in the Middle East start their reasoning from geo-physical or natural conditions as determinants of social
Towards Contested ‘Spheres of Influence’ in the Western Pacific: Rising China, Classical Geopolitics, and Asia-Pacific Stability
ABSTRACT The evolution of US-Sino great power competition in East Asia has emerged as a key geostrategic issue in international politics. A central question is whether the ‘geography of the peace’
Geopolitical Approaches, Regional Security Complexes, and Political Psychology
This chapter constructs the book’s theoretical framework, which is based on Stefano Guzzini’s view of neoclassical geopolitics enriched with elements from the Regional Security Complex Theory. The
Which Geopolitics for the European Union? The EU's Eastern Partnership
This article discusses whether the European Union (EU) has engaged in a geopolitical approach when it comes to its Eastern neighbors, now included in the EU’s Eastern Partnership. The paper concludes


Imperialism, Domination, Culture: The Continued Relevance of Critical Geopolitics
Twenty years ago Gearóid Ó Tuathail called for an approach within Political Geography that made geopolitical culture and the formulation of foreign policy the object of analysis. He specified the
The Geopolitics Reader
Introduction: Thinking Critically About Geopolitics 1. Imperialist Geopolitics 2. Cold War Geopolitics 3. Twenty First Century Geopolitics 4. The Geopolitics of Global Dangers 5. Anti-Geopolitics
Towards a feminist geopolitics
The intersections and conversations between feminist geography and political geography have been surprisingly few. The notion of a feminist geopolitics remains undeveloped in geography. This paper
Geopolitics, the revolution in military affairs and the Bush doctrine
In the aftermath of September 11, 2001 American geopolitical categories changed as the world was remapped into categories congruent with the prosecution of the global war on terror. The designation
Captain America's Empire: Reflections on Identity, Popular Culture, and Post-9/11 Geopolitics
Abstract This article introduces comic books as a medium through which national identity and geopolitical scripts are narrated. This extension of the popular geopolitics literature uses the example
Popular Geopolitics Past and Future: Fandom, Identities and Audiences
This short and hopefully provocative paper serves as both a retrospective of the past twenty years of critical work on so-called popular geopolitics and also an impetus for a more theoretical
Why Geographic Factors are Necessary in Development Studies
This paper proposes that the resurgence of geographic factors in the study of uneven development is not due simply to the recurrent nature of intellectual fashions, nor necessarily because arguments
Great powers and geopolitical change
In an era of high technology and instant communication, the role of geography in the formation of strategy and politics in international relations can be undervalued. But the mountains of Afghanistan
The Role of Geography in Development
This article assesses how the tension between centripetal forces (such as forward and backward linkages in production and increasing returns in transportation) and centrifugal forces (such as factor
Environmental factors in the study of international politics
Japanese abroad.... The factor of geographic isolation during ... two thousand years has helped fashion national traits which eventually, and ahnost inevitably, led Japan to political isolation and