The Survival of the Secret Treaty: Publicity, Secrecy, and Legality in the International Order

  title={The Survival of the Secret Treaty: Publicity, Secrecy, and Legality in the International Order},
  author={Megan Donaldson},
  journal={American Journal of International Law},
  pages={575 - 627}
  • M. Donaldson
  • Published 1 July 2017
  • History
  • American Journal of International Law
Abstract This article offers the first detailed history of the norm of treaty publication as it has evolved over the last century. Drawing on both public debates and archives of foreign ministries, it traces how, and why, secret treaties have persisted, even in liberal democracies. It challenges assumptions of ever-greater transparency over time, and complicates the associations made—by interwar reformers and international lawyers today—between the norm of treaty publication and ideals of… 

Publicity in International Lawmaking

This book explores how best to recalibrate our understanding of international lawmaking through the lens of increased reporting and legal debate around covert and quasi-covert uses of force. Recent

Community Interest and the International Public Legal Order

  • Sarah Thin
  • Political Science, Law
    Netherlands International Law Review
  • 2021
Traditional ideas about the private nature of the international legal order are increasingly being forced to contend with the development of public legal elements at the international level. The

Manufacturing International Law: Pre-printed Treaties in the ‘Scramble for Africa’

The 1880s saw a unique confluence of means, motives, and opportunities which led the British and their agents on African frontiers to enter into hundreds of pre-printed form treaties with local



A Mirage in the Sand? Distinguishing Binding and Non-Binding Relations Between States

  • C. Chinkin
  • Law
    Leiden Journal of International Law
  • 1997
The article discusses the two decisions (thus far) of the International Court of Justice in the case concerning Maritime Delimitation and Territorial Questions between Qatar and Bahrain, especially

International Agreements: Recent U.S.-UK Practice Concerning the Memorandum of Understanding

The memorandum of understanding (MOU) is a well-accepted type of legal instrument in international law and practice. Indeed, it was recognized as such by the British expert Lord McNair, who, in his

A (Qualified) Defense of Secret Agreements

Secret international agreements have a bad reputation. Ever since states misused secret agreements during World War I, commentators have condemned these agreements as pernicious and destabilizing to

A Comparative Approach to Treaty Law and Practice

  • D. Hollis
  • Law
    National Treaty Law and Practice
  • 2005
Traditionally, scholars and practitioners have viewed the study of treaties primarily through the lens of international law - considering how treaties constitute a source of law or obligation and

The Theory and Practice of Informal International Instruments

  • A. Aust
  • Political Science
    International and Comparative Law Quarterly
  • 1986
LAWYERS practising in foreign or defence ministries are familiar with the use of informal instruments to record arrangements between States. To others, especially those outside government circles,

The Protocol of Séevres, 1956: anatomy of a war plot

The tripartite aggression against Egypt in 1956 involved an extraordinary reversal of Britain's position in the Middle East. The French were the matchmakers in bringing Britain and Israel into a

French Security and a British ‘Continental Commitment’ after the First World War: a Reassessment*

In his classic study Britain and France between two World Wars, Arnold Wolfers characterised ‘British support’ as the ‘conditio sine qua non’ of French security policy. Wolfers argued that only an

Article 80. Registration and publication of treaties

The system of registration and publication of treaties first established under the League of Nations and continued in the framework of the UN seeks to prevent the negative effects of secret treaties.

Analysis of the Terms “Treaty” and “International Agreement” for Purposes of Registration Under Article 102 of the United Nations Charter

The implementation of Article 18 of the Covenant of the League of Nations, which was designed to usher in a new era of open diplomacy, may be regarded as one of the more successful achievements of

Hard and Soft Law in International Governance

We examine why international actors—including states, firms, and activists—seek different types of legalized arrangements to solve political and substantive problems. We show how particular forms of