The Social Influence of Confidence in Group Decision Making

@article{Zarnoth1997TheSI,
  title={The Social Influence of Confidence in Group Decision Making},
  author={Zarnoth and Sniezek},
  journal={Journal of experimental social psychology},
  year={1997},
  volume={33 4},
  pages={
          345-66
        }
}
  • Zarnoth, Sniezek
  • Published 1 July 1997
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of experimental social psychology
This study investigates the relation between an individual's self-reported confidence and his or her influence within a freely interacting group. Each participant chose responses and provided confidence assessments for choice items of a variety of task types, first as an individual and a second time as a member of a pentad, a member of a dyad, or an individual. The influence of a particular faction within a group was greater if its members were more confident. A participant's response accuracy… 

Topics from this paper

The effects of variability and expectations on utilization of member expertise and group performance
One of the most important resources a group has is the expertise of its members (Hackman & Morris, 1975; McGrath, 1984). Further, research suggests that recognition of expertise plays an important
Categorization by groups and individuals
Categorization is a core psychological process that is central to decision making. While a substantial amount of research has been conducted to examine individual categorization behavior, little is
The communication and influence of confidence and uncertainty
While the social influence of confidence has been shown to be an influential factor in persuasion, previous research, using numerically expressed confidence, has identified a number of factors that
Views That Are Shared With Others Are Expressed With Greater Confidence and Greater Fluency Independent of Any Social Influence
  • A. Koriat, Shiri Adiv, N. Schwarz
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc
  • 2016
TLDR
The results indicate that PME for binary choices can arise from the process underlying confidence and latency independent of social influence.
The influence of group decision making on indecisiveness-related decisional confidence
Indecisiveness is an individual difference measure of chronic difficulty and delay in decision making. Indecisiveness is associated with low decisional confidence and distinct patterns of pre-choice
The role of decision confidence in advice-taking and trust formation.
TLDR
This study tests the hypothesis that an individual's internal decision confidence can be used as a signal to learn the accuracy of others' advice, even in the absence of feedback, and explores implications of these individual-level heuristics for network-level patterns of trust and belief formation.
Arguments, more than confidence, explain the good performance of reasoning groups.
TLDR
Results show that argument quality can overcome confidence among the factors influencing the discussion of intellective tasks.
The social transmission of overconfidence.
TLDR
The overconfidence transmission hypothesis, which predicts that individuals calibrate their self-assessments in response to the confidence others display in their social group, is proposed and tested and suggests that social transmission processes may be in part responsible for why local confidence norms emerge in groups, teams, and organizations.
Gender Composition and Group Confidence Judgment: The Perils of All-Male Groups
We explore the joint effects of group decision making and group gender composition on the calibration of confidence judgments. Participants in two laboratory experiments, individually and in groups
Gender Composition and Group Confidence Judgment: The Perils of All-Male Groups
TLDR
It is found that compared to a statistical aggregation of individual confidence intervals, group discussions have a neutral or positive effect on the quality of confidence judgments for groups with at least one female group member; in contrast, group discussion actually harms confidence calibration for all-male groups.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 57 REFERENCES
Group position as a function of member attitudes. Choice shift effects from the perspective of social decision scheme theory.
500 undergraduates made decisions as individuals or 4-person groups about several attitude objects along a 7-point semantic differential scale and about several social issues along a percentage
Group size, member ability, and social decision schemes on an intellective task.
510 college students first took Part 1 of the difficult Terman Concept Mastery Test as individuals and then retook the same test as control individuals or in cooperative high-ability or low-ability
The Impact of Behavioral Style and Status Characteristics on Social Influence: A Test of Two Competing Theories
Two theories of social influence during interaction are compared. A cognitive theory (Status Characteristics and Expectation States) contends that dominance and influence in small groups are caused
Recognition of Expertise in Decision-Making Groups
Two studies examined the effects of group size and participation requirements on group performance, expertise, and recognition of group expertise. In Study 1, 324 college students were assigned to
Group Judgment Accuracy: Reliability and Validity of Postdiscussion Confidence Judgments
Abstract The present study investigated the group judgment process, specifically the issue of whether individuals in a group setting are able to identify the most accurate group member under
The overconfidence effect in social prediction.
In five studies with overlapping designs and intents, subjects predicted a specific peer's responses to a variety of stimulus situations, each of which offered a pair of mutually exclusive and
Interaction with Others Increases Decision Confidence but Not Decision Quality: Evidence against Information Collection Views of Interactive Decision Making
Abstract We present three studies of interactive decision making, where decision makers interact with others before making a final decision alone. Because the theories of lay observers and social
The relationships among group size, member ability, social decision schemes, and performance
Abstract This study examines the effect of member task skills and social decision schemes on the performance-size relationship for both simulated and interacting groups. Group performance is found to
Accuracy and confidence in group judgment
A weighting scheme model is used to describe and evaluate the process by which groups combine individual judgments and their associated confidence levels into a single group judgment with some level
Psychology of Group Influence
Preface. 1. Paul B. Paulus An Overview and Evaluation of Group Influence Part 1: Basic Group Influence 2. Russell G. Geen Alternative Conceptions of Social Facilitation 3. Eric S. Knowles Spatial
...
1
2
3
4
5
...