The Smoke Detector Principle

@article{Nesse2001TheSD,
  title={The Smoke Detector Principle},
  author={Randolph M. Nesse},
  journal={Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences},
  year={2001},
  volume={935}
}
  • R. Nesse
  • Published 1 May 2001
  • Computer Science
  • Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
Abstract: Defenses, such as flight, cough, stress, and anxiety, should theoretically be expressed to a degree that is near the optimum needed to protect against a given threat. Many defenses seem, however, to be expressed too readily or too intensely. Furthermore, there are remarkably few untoward effects from using drugs to dampen defensive responses. A signal detection analysis of defense regulation can help to resolve this apparent paradox. When the cost of expressing an all‐or‐none defense… 

The smoke detector principle

  • R. Nesse
  • Medicine
    Evolution, medicine, and public health
  • 2019
The Smoke Detector Principle explains why evolved systems that regulate protective responses often give rise to false alarms and apparently excessive responses and can specify the decision strategy that maximizes benefits in the face of uncertainty.

Let fever do its job

For infections with novel SARS-CoV-2, the precautionary principle applies: unless evidence suggests otherwise, that fever should be allowed to run its course, and the benefits of allowing fever to occur probably outweigh its harms.

Are Humans Prepared to Detect, Fear, and Avoid Snakes? The Mismatch Between Laboratory and Ecological Evidence

This work addresses fear preparedness theories and automatic fast detection data from mainstream laboratory data and compares it with ethobehavioral information relative to snakes, predator-prey interaction, and snakes’ defensive kinematics strikes in order to analyze their potential matching.

The Effect of Affective State on Tactile Sensitivity

Repetition of the study with a larger sample could amend the short comings of this experiment, clarify the ambiguity still surrounding gender differences and distinction between fear and disgust-related stimuli, and increase the reliability of these results and equipment used.

The erroneous signals of detection theory

Analytical and computational models are used to show that, in numerous biological scenarios, the standard results of signal detection theory do not apply; more predators can result in prey being less responsive to such cues.

Unrealistic Optimism and Risk for COVID-19 Disease

Analysis of relationships among personal risk for severe COVID-19, risk perceptions, and preventative behaviors suggested that those with higher clinical risk scores did not generally behave differently than those with lower scores during the shelter-in-place order, and further suggested that unrealistic optimism may provide some short-term psychological benefits.

Cognitive adaptations to criminal justice lead to “paranoid” norm obedience

This model suggests evolutionary pressure against norm violators may lead to the emergence of a bias, causing agents to be extremely sensitive to the probability of being caught, and shows that cooperation is promoted by the number of interactions actually observed.

Why Do People Become Anxious ?

Anxiety disorders are among the most common mental illnesses, with huge attendant suffering. Current treatments are not universally effective, suggesting that a deeper understanding of the causes of

Symptoms in the host: infection and treatment model.

A decision-making model is devised to help nurses and allied professionals treat the symptoms of infectious diseases in a logical way that maximizes the benefits of symptoms and minimizes any harm that they might do.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 30 REFERENCES

The Ecology and Evolution of Inducible Defenses

  • C. Harvell
  • Biology
    The Quarterly Review of Biology
  • 1990
An integrated approach to studying inducible defenses would combine mechanistic estimates of costs, population-level estimates of defense effectiveness, and genetic estimates of correlations between fitness and inducibles characters to estimate rates of evolution in phenotypically plastic threshold characters.

Stress and the individual. Mechanisms leading to disease.

A new formulation of the relationship between stress and the processes leading to disease is presented, emphasizing the cascading relationships between environmental factors and genetic predispositions that lead to large individual differences in susceptibility to stress and, in some cases, to disease.

Physiological functions of glucocorticoids in stress and their relation to pharmacological actions.

It is proposed that stress-induced increases in glucocorticoid levels protect not against the source of stress itself but rather against the body's normal reactions to stress, preventing those reactions from overshooting and themselves threatening homeostasis.

Protective and damaging effects of stress mediators.

  • B. McEwen
  • Psychology
    The New England journal of medicine
  • 1998
The long-term effect of the physiologic response to stress is reviewed, which I refer to as allostatic load, which is the ability to achieve stability through change.

The Dawn of Darwinian Medicine

It is shown that this increasingly significant research paradigm can predict otherwise unsuspected facets of human biology, and that it provides new insights into the causes of medical disorders, such as those discussed below.

Why zebras don't get ulcers : a guide to stress, stress related diseases, and coping

When people burdened with stress start to feel bad physically, it is not just in their minds. Emotional crises bring on specific physical changes in the body. If those stress responses are prolonged

Behavioral adaptations to pathogens and parasites: Five strategies

  • B. Hart
  • Biology, Psychology
    Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews
  • 1990

"Flooding in vivo" during the circadian phase of minimal cortisol secretion: anxiety and therapeutic success without adrenal cortical activation.

Seven patients with maximally severe phobias for physical objects were treated by "flooding in vivo", i.e. live confrontation with the feared object, and anxiety, even when intense and dramatic, does not necessarily activate the adrenal cortex, and an adrenal "stress" response is not necessary for the therapeutic effect.