The Shadow Cabinet in Westminster Systems: Modeling Opposition Agenda Setting in the House of Commons, 1832–1915

  title={The Shadow Cabinet in Westminster Systems: Modeling Opposition Agenda Setting in the House of Commons, 1832–1915},
  author={Andrew C. Eggers and Arthur Spirling},
  journal={British Journal of Political Science},
  pages={343 - 367}
This article considers the emergence of an informal institution vital to the functioning of Westminster polities: that the Shadow Cabinet is a ‘government in waiting’. It compares the evidence for two theoretical accounts of its timing: a ‘procedural’ theory wherein the Shadow Cabinet is a solution to internal organizational issues in the House of Commons prior to widespread working-class voting, and a ‘competition’ theory that predicts that suffrage extension acts as a key stimulus for Shadow… 
The Politics of Procedural Choice: Regulating Legislative Debate in the UK House of Commons, 1811–2015
  • Niels D. Goet
  • Political Science
    British Journal of Political Science
  • 2019
Abstract The historical development of rules of debate in the UK House of Commons raises an important puzzle: why do members of parliament (MPs) impose limits on their own rights? Despite a growing
Competition and communication: the development of campaigning in Britain from the Second Reform Act to the First World War
This thesis traces the development of political competition in Britain by exploring the relationship between politicians and their constituents; in particular, it examines the decisions rank-and-file
Short-lived Parliamentarisation in 19th-century Germany: Parliamentary Government in the Frankfurt Assembly of 1848/1849
The article shows that Germany established a short-lived but fully operative parliamentary system of government in its first democratically elected national parliament in 1848—some 70 years earlier
Victorian Voting: The Origins of Party Orientation and Class Alignment
Much of what we know about the alignment of voters with parties comes from mass surveys of the electorate in the postwar period or from aggregate electoral data. Using individual elector level panel
Victorian Voting: Party Orientation and Class Alignment Revisited
Much of what we know about the alignment of voters with parties comes from mass surveys of the electorate in the postwar period or from aggregate electoral data. Using individual elector level panel
Parliament as Prime Minister’s electoral college: the defection game in Malaysia’s democratic backsliding
ABSTRACT The collapse of Malaysia’s multiethnic reformist government by a party coup in February 2020 – called the ‘Sheraton Move’ – can be assessed along at least three dimensions: first, a
Analyzing the Agenda of Parliament in the Age of Reform∗ VERY PRELIMINARY
This article provides a new measure of the agenda of the British Parliament–the substantive topics on which debate was focused–from 1810-1914. This measure is obtained by applying a keyword approach
The determinants of legislative speechmaking on salient issues: the analysis of parliamentary debates on Theresa May’s Brexit withdrawal agreement using structural topic models
This thesis aims to reveal the differences in legislative speechmaking determined by the roles, which the members of parliaments (MPs) can play on the parliamentary floor, and the effects of debates
The Meaningful Votes: Voting on Brexit in the British House of Commons
Why do politicians rebel and vote against the party line when high stakes bills come to the floor of the legislature? To address that question, we leverage the three so-called Meaningful Votes that
Divide to conquer? Strategic parliamentary opposition and coalition government
Parliamentary elections often result in the formation of a coalition government. While the legislative process allows actors within a coalition government to monitor each other, little attention has


Party Cohesion in Westminster Systems: Inducements, Replacement and Discipline in the House of Commons, 1836–1910
This article considers the historical development of a characteristic crucial for the functioning and normative appeal of Westminster systems: cohesive legislative parties. It gathers the universe of
Strategic Opposition and Government Cohesion in Westminster Democracies
Cohesive government-versus-opposition voting is a robust empirical regularity in Westminster democracies. Using new data from the modern Scottish Parliament, we show that this pattern cannot be
The Rejected, the Ejected, and the Dejected: Explaining Government Rebels in the 2001-2005 British House of Commons
The combination of parliamentary government and plurality elections in the British House of Commons is often assumed to produce highly cohesive parliamentary parties. However, the number and
Ideology, Party and Interests in the British Parliament of 1841 47
Building upon Poole and Rosenthal’s NOMINATE technique and Kalt and Zupan’s residualization approach, I seek to disentangle the influences of constituency interests, party and ideology on the votes
Pivotal Politics: A Theory of U.S. Lawmaking
Politicians and pundits alike have complained that the divided governments of the last decades have led to a legislative gridlock. The author argues against this, advancing the theory that divided
In the shadows: the Shadow Cabinet in Australia
This report discusses the roles, functions and procedures of the modern Australian shadow cabinet. It aims to redress the shortage of material on the Shadow Cabinet, and provide the reader with a
The Timing of Cabinet Reshuffles in Five Westminster Parliamentary Systems
Despite their political prominence, cabinet reshuffles have not attracted a great deal of scholarly attention. We provide a theory of cabinet reshuffles that emphasizes both systematic and
Opposition in the British Political System
BY 1997 THE CONSERVATIVE PARTY HAD BEEN IN POWER FOR EIGHTEEN years, the longest period of uninterrupted rule by a single party this century. To many it looked as if the alternation of two parties in
Catalyst or Cause? Legislation and the Demise of Machine Politics in Britain and the United States
In the nineteenth century, British and American parties competed by hiring electoral agents to bribe and treat voters. British parties abruptly abandoned this practice in the 1880s. The conventional
Patterns of democracy : government forms and performance in thirty-six countries
In this updated and expanded edition of his classic text, Arend Lijphart offers a broader and deeper analysis of worldwide democratic institutions than ever before. Examining thirty-six democracies