The Scientific Status of Projective Techniques

@article{Lilienfeld2000TheSS,
  title={The Scientific Status of Projective Techniques},
  author={Scott O. Lilienfeld and James M Wood and Howard N. Garb},
  journal={Psychological Science in the Public Interest},
  year={2000},
  volume={1},
  pages={27 - 66}
}
Although projective techniques continue to be widely used in clinical and forensic settings, their scientific status remains highly controversial. In this monograph, we review the current state of the literature concerning the psychometric properties (norms, reliability, validity, incremental validity, treatment utility) of three major projective instruments: Rorschach Inkblot Test, Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), and human figure drawings. We conclude that there is empirical support for the… 

Tables from this paper

The Thema Tic appercepTion TesT in The lighT of research. The possibiliTy of using This TesT in forensic assessmenTs
As the 1990s drew to a close, projective tests became the focus of discussion and heated debate, while new studies led experts to question their validity and practical utility. This probably explains
Projective Personality Assessment in Child Custody Evaluations
This chapter reviews the utilization of projective personality tests in custody cases, including the frequency in which various projective tests are employed, as well as the reliability and validity
Fundamental Psychometric Considerations in Assessment
The field of psychometry, defined by Francis Galton (1879) as “the art of imposing measurement and number upon operations of the mind” (p. 149), has long guided the development and appraisal of
Therapeutic exploration with the Rorschach Inkblot Test: a case demonstration of the lifeworld approach with a child
  • J. L. YuQ. Lee
  • Psychology
    Asia Pacific Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy
  • 2021
Originally introduced by Hermann Rorschach in his seminal work Psychodiagnostics, the Rorschach Inkblot Method (RIM) was widely recognized as a revolutionary psychological assessment. Nonetheless,
Can Projective Drawings Detect if a Child Experienced Sexual or Physical Abuse?
TLDR
Results indicate that, although individual studies have found support for various indicators or scoring systems, these results are rarely replicated and many times studies finding significant results suffer from serious methodological flaws and alternative explanations for findings (e.g., mental illness).
The Use of Projective Drawings to Assess Alexithymia: The Validity of the Wartegg Test
TLDR
The results can be considered encouraging concerning the overall usefulness and validity of the WZT and efforts to develop a psychometrically valid and reliable method of interpreting the WzT should be continued.
Prediction of Psychiatric Hospitalization, Diagnoses, Arrests, and Violent Behavior Through Scored Drawings and Associations
  • F. Dyer
  • Psychology
    Psychological reports
  • 2018
TLDR
The article presents a completely empirical approach to using drawings and associations as a supplemental tool in forensic psychological assessment, a modern alternative to prior theory-driven “projective technique” approaches that have failed to pass scientific scrutiny.
Effective Use of Projective Techniques in Clinical Practice: Let the Data Help With Selection and Interpretation
By learning about the validity of individual test scores, psychologists can avoid using scores that are invalid and making judgments that are potentially harmful to their clients. This is important
Observations on the Validity of Neuropsychological and Personality Assessment Testing
The validity of neuropsychological testing is evaluated in the context of a growing controversy surrounding personality assessment. Claims made by a committee established by the American
Brian Allen and Chriscelyn Tussey the Controlled Research Can Projective Drawings Detect if a Child Experienced Sexual or Physical Abuse ? : A Systematic Review of
Clinical observations have suggested that children who experience physical or sexual abuse may provide indicators in their drawings that can distinguish them from nonabused children. Some have even
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 480 REFERENCES
The Incremental and Predictive Validity of the Rorschach Test in Personality Assessments of Normal, Neurotic and Psychotic Subjects.
The purpose of this study was to determine the optimal amount of Rorschach protocol data required for maximal accuracy in person­ ality assessment when experience level of judges and degree of
What the Rorschach Can Do for You: Incremental Validity in Clinical. Applications
TLDR
There is solid conceptual basis in psychology for employing multi-method assessment, and clinical applications in which Rorschach data contribute to fuller or more accurate formulations than would otherwise be possible attest the incremental validity that can derive from including relatively unstructured measures in a test battery.
Construct validity in psychological tests.
TLDR
The present interpretation of construct validity is not "official" and deals with some areas where the Committee would probably not be unanimous, but the present writers are solely responsible for this attempt to explain the concept and elaborate its implications.
Behavioral Science Foundations of the Rorschach Test: Research and Clinical Applications
TLDR
An overview of several domains of applied and laboratory Rorschach behavioral science, including statistical power analysis, interobserver agreement and interrater reliability, Rorshach assessment of thought disorder, and emerging research linking RorsChach variables with diagnostic criteria from the DSM-JiV is provided.
Whither the Rorschach? An analysis of the evidence.
TLDR
The authors begin their article by examining a number of conceptual issues that are at the heart of the disagreements about the Rorschach, and focus is then shifted to the central issue of clinical utility, with an emphasis on why current research is insufficient to demonstrate the utility of the RORSchach.
A review of recent research addressing the utility of the Rorschach.
To address the utility of the Rorschach, the author synthesized a large sample (N = 138) of empirical, quantitative research published in the past 20 years. Longitudinal and behavioral criteria and
Construct validity of the Rorschach Oral Dependency Scale: 1967–1995.
A review of research examining the construct validity of J. M. Masling, L. Rabie, and S. H. Blondheim's (1967) Rorschach Oral Dependency (ROD) scale as a measure of interpersonal dependency revealed
Diagnostic taxa as open concepts: Metatheoretical and statistical questions about reliability and construct validity in the grand strategy of nosological revision.
Since I find it hard to conceive that a rational mind could think otherwise, I presuppose that, ceteris paribus, careful delineation of the signs, symptoms, and course of a disorder (I cannot
Drawings of the opposite sex: Continued use of the draw a person test and young state hospital patients
TLDR
It is suggested that in order for the DAP to become a more objectively utilized personality technique, a scoring method should be developed that takes into account the overall quality of the drawing in conjunction with the individual details of each area of the figure drawn.
...
...