The Role of Local Knowledge in Medical Practice: A Trans-historical Perspective

  title={The Role of Local Knowledge in Medical Practice: A Trans-historical Perspective},
  author={Josep M Comelles},
  journal={Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry},
  • J. Comelles
  • Published 1 March 2000
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry
This article explores the role ofparticipant-observation and ethnographic writing inthe shaping of medical practice since Hippocrates. Drawing on a range of historical sources and genresthat include the 17th- and 18th-centurymedical topographies and medical geographies,19th-century medical ethnography and folklore,and their marginal persistence into the 20thcentury in the form of Mexican pasante reports,I argue that these writings should not be approachedas part of the history of anthropology… Expand
9 Citations
Entre etnografía y didáctica: La construcción de la experiencia sobre el proceso salud, enfermedad y atención en los "medical dramas"
From ethnography to education: The construction of experience in the health / illness / treatment cycle in medical dramas Abstract: In this article, we wish to discuss three dimensions of medicalExpand
The transformation of medical education in eighteenth‐century England: international developments and the West Midlands
This article deals with transformations in eighteenth‐century medical education. Its focus is the work of an individual surgeon, Thomas Tomlinson, who delivered one of the earliest anatomical coursesExpand
Joining Ethnography and History in Cultural Competence Training
  • M. Knipper
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Culture, medicine and psychiatry
  • 2013
It is a particular pleasure for me to add some observations and ideas to this impressive collection of papers on four training programmes on cultural competence in the United States and Canada, adding some thoughts on the importance of the often neglected historical dimensions of cultural diversity and the benefits of combining the anthropological with an adequately defined historical perspective. Expand
Forgotten paths: culture and ethnicity in Catalan mental health policies (1900-39)
  • J. Comelles
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • History of psychiatry
  • 2010
The paper concludes with a discussion of the influence of pre-war Catalan mental health policies on the wartime practice of psychiatry and, later, on the development of the French psychothérapie institutionnelle after World War II. Expand
Negotiating science and experience in medical knowledge: gynaecologists on endometriosis.
  • E. Whelan
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Social science & medicine
  • 2009
Analysis of gynaecological literature on endometriosis found that the discourse of science is used strategically in this literature as a formal epistemology to lend weight to authors' claims and to guide medical thinking and research. Expand
La mirada (auto)etnográfica de tres comadronas y su traducción (cinemato)gráfica: Los vericuetos del yo autoral
Actually, the changes resulting from the questioning of the Welfare State, ideological positions and feminism have launched a debate on supply/demand about Reproductive Health. Our purpose is toExpand
Context, co-presence and 'compossibilities': bioprospecting between endogenous knowledge and science in South Africa
This paper describes and explores the case of a South African bioprospecting consortium involving some technology transfer, but also exhibiting features of a biotechnology learning network whichExpand
Diagnostic Fluidity: Working with uncertainty and mutability
Based on a case of a “lay” diagnosis that questions a treatment and leads the patient to decide to cease taking it, this paper examines the patient’s protracted journey, the conditions in which heExpand
Genealogía de la Antropología Médica en España 1 The Genealogy of Medical Anthropology in Spain
En este articulo proponemos una revision de la antropologia medica en Espana desde una perspectiva historica. El articulo analiza diferentes etapas: 1. las relaciones historicas entre la medicina yExpand


The fear of (one's own) history: on the relations between medical anthropology, medicine and history.
This article aims to explore a main obstacle to the full conquest of interdisciplinarity, namely the persistence of sabaltern discourses and practices related to medical history and to social sciences among the medical professions. Expand
Medicine, rationality, and experience : an anthropological perspective
Preface 1. Medical anthropology and the problem of belief 2. Illness representations in medical anthropology: a reading of the field 3. How medicine constructs its objects 4. Semiotics and the studyExpand
The Therapeutic Revolution: Medicine, Meaning, and Social Change in Nineteenth-Century America
By the end of the century, traditional therapeutics had altered fundamentally; this is a significant event not only in the history of medicine, but in social history as well; historians have not only failed to delineate this change in detail, they have hardly begun to place it in a framework of explanation which would relate it to all those other changes which shaped the twentieth-century Western world. Expand
A World of Internal Medicine: Portrait of an Internist
The following portrait attempts to penetrate and represent the thought-world of a single practitioner of general internal medicine, to depict the premises, attitudes, and values which guide, express,Expand
Early Anthropology in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries
Although social sciences such as anthropology are often thought to have been organized as academic specialties in the nineteenth century, the ideas upon which these disciplines were founded actuallyExpand
Patient's Progress: Doctors and Doctoring in Eighteenth-Century England
This book discusses medicine, Ideology and Society, and the role of doctors and women in this society, in the context of a post-modern society. Expand
Hippocrates in a World of Pagans and Christians
In Hippocrates in a World of Pagans and Christians, Temkin shows how the perennial appeal of Hippocratic practice helped establish the relationship between scientific medicine and monotheisticExpand
La gestion des risques : de l'anti-psychiatrie à l'après-psychanalyse
Robert Castel és un sociòleg francès que està dedicant la seva tasca professional a l'anàlisi històrica de la Psiquiatria des d'una perspectiva bastant prò· xima als plantejaments de la històriaExpand
Risk Acceptability According to the Social Sciences
First published in 1985, Mary Douglas intended Risk and Acceptability as a review of the existing literature on the state of risk theory. Unsatisfied with the current studies of risk, which she foundExpand
Où en est l'anthropologie médicale appliquée?
A l'occasion d'une reunion organisee par l'association AMADES (Anthropologie Medicale Appliquee au Developpement et a la Sante, dont le siege est a Toulouse) plusieurs communications ont eteExpand