The Reversal Test: Eliminating Status Quo Bias in Applied Ethics*

@article{Bostrom2006TheRT,
  title={The Reversal Test: Eliminating Status Quo Bias in Applied Ethics*},
  author={Nick Bostrom and Toby Ord},
  journal={Ethics},
  year={2006},
  volume={116},
  pages={656 - 679}
}
Suppose that we develop a medically safe and affordable means of enhancing human intelligence. For concreteness, we shall assume that the technology is genetic engineering (either somatic or germ line), although the argument we will present does not depend on the technological implementation. For simplicity, we shall speak of enhancing “intelligence” or “cognitive capacity,” but we do not presuppose that intelligence is best conceived of as a unitary attribute. Our considerations could be… 

Topics from this paper

An Empirically Informed Critique of Habermas’ Argument from Human Nature
TLDR
The argument from human nature is based on a series of false or problematic assumptions, and fails to play the normative role intended by Habermas, and ultimately, genetic enhancement jeopardizes the very foundations of moral equality.
Is Disability Conservationism Rooted in Status Quo Bias?
TLDR
I believe that the given cases do not primarily relativize the normative weight of the value of diversity for the ethics of genetic selection, but rather they force us to evaluate whether conserving genetic diversity is an appropriate argument to restore inequalities.
Retracing Liberalism and Remaking Nature: Designer Children, Research Embryos, and Featherless Chickens
  • D. Fox
  • Medicine, Sociology
    Bioethics
  • 2010
TLDR
It is concluded that liberal theory is incapable of furnishing a coherent or desirable account to govern the way the authors use their emerging powers of biotechnology.
If and Then: A Critique of Speculative NanoEthics
Most known technology serves to ingeniously adapt the world to the physical and mental limitations of human beings. Humankind has acquired awesome power with its rather limited means.
Neoliberalising Bioethics: Bias, Enhancement and Economistic Ethics
  • K. Birch
  • Sociology
    Genomics, society, and policy
  • 2008
In bioethics there is an ongoing debate about the ethical case for human enhancement through new biomedical technologies. In this debate there are both supporters and opponents of human enhancement
Human Enhancement Ethics: The State of the Debate
Are we good enough? If not, how may we improve ourselves? Must we restrict ourselves to traditional methods like study and training? Or should we also use science to enhance some of our mental and
The reversal test, status quo bias, and opposition to human cognitive enhancement
Abstract Bostrom and Ord’s reversal test has been appealed to by many philosophers to substantiate the charge that preferences for status quo options are motivated by status quo bias. I argue that
Responsible Innovation in Social Epistemic Systems: The P300 Memory Detection Test and the Legal Trial
Memory Detection Tests (MDTs) are a general class of psychophysiological tests that can be used to determine whether someone remembers a particular fact or datum. The P300 MDT is a type of MDT that
An Epistemic Argument for Conservatism
Abstract‘Epistemic’ arguments for conservatism typically claim that given the limits of human reason, we are better off accepting some particular social practice or institution rather than trying to
Withdrawal Aversion and the Equivalence Test
TLDR
This article defends equivalence—the view that withholding and withdrawal of treatment are ethically equivalent when all other factors are equal—and argues that preference for withholding over withdrawal could represent a form of cognitive bias—withdrawal aversion.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-7 OF 7 REFERENCES
Beneficence, determinism and justice: an engagement with the argument for the genetic selection of intelligence.
  • K. Birch
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Bioethics
  • 2005
TLDR
This article is designed as an engagement in the intelligence selection debate using an analysis of Savulescu's arguments to raise a series of problematic issues in relation to the ethics of parental selection of intelligence.
Protecting the endangered human: toward an international treaty prohibiting cloning and inheritable alterations.
TLDR
In this Article, human cloning and inheritable genetic alterations from the human species perspective are discussed, and language for a proposed international "Convention of the Preservation of the Human Species" that would outlaw all efforts to initiate a pregnancy by using either intentionally modified genetic material or human replication cloning is suggested.
The Case against Perfection
reakthroughs in genetics present us with a promise and a predicament. The promise is that we may soon be able to treat and prevent a host of debilitating diseases. The predicament is that our
Procreative beneficence: why we should select the best children.
TLDR
A principle which is defended, called Procreative Beneficence, is defended: couples should select the child, of the possible children they could have, who is expected to have the best life, or at least as good a life as the others, based on the relevant, available information.
The Future of Human Nature
Publisher's Note. Foreword. Are There Postmetaphysical Answers to the Question: What is the "Good Life"?. The Debate on the Ethical Self--Understanding of the Species. I Moralizing Human Nature?. II
Upside Risks: Social Consequences of Beneficial Biotechnology
  • Are Genes Us? The Social Consequences of the New Genetics
  • 1994