The Rational Attacker in Russia? Negative Campaigning in Russian Presidential Elections

  title={The Rational Attacker in Russia? Negative Campaigning in Russian Presidential Elections},
  author={Lee Sigelman and Eric B. Shiraev},
  journal={The Journal of Politics},
  pages={45 - 62}
Formal models of negative campaigning offer several predictions about the volume, sources, and targets of candidates' attacks on one another. We test these predictions and predictions drawn from other perspectives by analyzing public statements by candidates in the 1996 and 2000 Russian presidential campaigns. Our tests provide mixed support for the model-derived predictions. Concluding discussion centers on the need to reconsider some of the models' basic assumptions and to incorporate some… 
Attack Politics: Who Goes Negative and Why?
I introduce a formal model of campaign strategy to show when candidates will engage in negative campaigning and how it can affect election results. The model separates campaign strategies by target
Negative Campaigning in Turkish Elections
Abstract The academic literature on negative campaigning is growing. As an attempt to contribute to the theoretical and empirical knowledge on the phenomena, this study focuses on the Turkish
Defending Negativity? Evidence from Presidential Campaigns in Taiwan
This article presents an empirical analysis of TV and newspaper advertising across four presidential election campaigns in Taiwan. The findings suggest that although there are high levels of
Ideological proximity and valence competition: Negative campaigning through allegation of corruption in the Italian legislative arena from 1946 to 1994
We consider the possibility for the parties to invest in negative campaigning – a behavior that, in our framework, involves blaming alleged insufficiencies of the rival concerning commonly shared
Negativity in the Public Space: Comparing a Hundred Years of Negative Campaigning on Election Posters in Sweden
Election posters are one of the oldest channels of political communication. With the advent of modern democracy, following the revolutions in the mid-19th century, posters were important. They helped
Who will attack the competitors? How political parties resolve strategic and collective action dilemmas in negative campaigning
Examining almost 8000 press releases issued by over 600 individual politicians during four election campaigns in Austria finds strong support for theoretical expectations that holders of high public office and party leaders are less likely to issue attacks, leaving the bulk of the 'dirty work' to be carried out by party floor leaders and general secretaries.
Choosing the enemy
This article examines which political parties are the most likely targets of negative campaigning in a multiparty system. The choice of target is an important strategic decision parties make when
Negative campaigning in Western Europe: beyond the vote-seeking perspective
Are election campaigns in Western Europe becoming more negative? Under which circumstances do political parties decide to attack? Are there differences in negative campaigning between the British
Going Negative in Comparative Perspective: Electoral Rules and Campaign Strategies
“Going negative” has practical and normative implications for electoral outcomes in all democracies. But most research on campaign strategy is limited to the two-candidate, plurality context provided
Mobilizing and chasing: The voter targeting of negative campaigning – lessons from the Swiss case
There are two targeting objectives for an election campaign: mobilizing core voters and chasing undecided voters. According to most previous research, negative campaigning exclusively fulfils a


How Russia Votes
In this ground-breaking study, Stephen White, Richard Rose, and Ian McAllister analyze the momentous sequence of elections held during the collapse of the Soviet Union and the creation of the Russian
Towards a positive theory of political rhetoric: Why do politicians lie?
This paper presents a model in which politicians can increase the probability of election by making exaggerated claims about the benefits of their own platform — referred to as positive campaigning —
The Strategy of Rhetoric: Campaigning for the American Constitution
This book, the last work of an eminent political scientist, is an innovative study of political persuasion during the 1787-88 campaign to ratify the U.S. Constitution. Employing historical and
Modeling Negative Campaigning
Negative campaigning is an important aspect of campaign competition but plays little or no role in existing models of campaigns. Within the context of plurality elections for a single office we model
An Economic Theory of Democracy
Downs presents a rational calculus of voting that has inspired much of the later work on voting and turnout. Particularly significant was his conclusion that a rational voter should almost never
Emerging Party Systems in Post-Soviet Societies: Fact or Fiction?
The political science literature reflects two viewpoints regarding the formation of party systems in post-Soviet societies. Scholars drawing on traditional theories of party formation usually argue
The Development of Party Identification in Post-Soviet Societies
of how the parties are arrayed along axes of political conflict and where they fit in the political spectrum. T he development of mass partisanship and party identification has long been a focus of
How Yeltsin Won." University of California, Los Angeles. Typescript
  • 1996
" A Rational Choice Model of Campaign Strategy . " In The Elections in Israel , 1981 , ed . Asher Arian
  • 1983
" Correliatsionnyi analyiz paramentskikh vyborov 1995 goda " [ A Correlational Analysis of the Parliamentary Elections of 1995 ]
  • Polis
  • 1996