The Problem of Ideology-Marxism without Guarantees

  title={The Problem of Ideology-Marxism without Guarantees},
  author={Stuart Hall},
  journal={Journal of Communication Inquiry},
  pages={28 - 44}
  • Stuart Hall
  • Published 1 June 1986
  • History
  • Journal of Communication Inquiry
In the past two or three decades, marxist theory has been going through a remarkable, but lop-sided and uneven revival. On the one hand, it has come once again to provide the principal pole of opposition to &dquo;bourgeois&dquo; social thought. On the other hand, many young intellectuals have passed through the revival and, after a heady and rapid apprenticeship, gone right out the other side again. They have &dquo;settled their accounts&dquo; with marxism and moved on to fresh intellectual 

Stuart Hall, Marxism without guarantees, and ‘The hard road to renewal’

This piece overviews Stuart Hall’s contribution to Marxism and to the left, and argues that whilst there were significant problems with the manifestation of Marxism Today, his work on hegemonic

Against Antinomies: For A Post-Marxist Politics

Crucial to the agenda of contemporary debate on class analysis and political action are a number of related issues concerning consciousness, ideology, interests and the diverse forms of struggle

Marxism without Revolution: Towards a History of Discouragement

Fredric Jameson has asserted the need for a theory of discouragement. I will leave the theorizing to him and follow instead another Jamesonian command, the one that says, "always historicize." I will

Re-engaging the third way? Regionalism, the European left and ‘Marxism without guarantees’

The failure of the ‘third way’ to reverse the decline of European socialism has led to the polarisation of the left in Europe, reflected both in practical politics and within academic circles. On the

Post-Marxism or Beyond: Hall and Foucault

Post-Marxism signifies a wide variety of efforts to rearticulate Marxist problems in order to explain contemporary societies in which a series of complex social, political, cultural, and economic

From hegemony to affinity

Drawing upon a critique of the (post)Marxist theory of hegemony and examples from contemporary activism, this article assesses new possibilities for the construction of radical alternatives within

Marxism as a Way of Seeing: Beyond the Limits of Current “Critical” Approaches to Sport

Like capitalism, Marxism constantly experiences contradictions and crises to which it reacts, adapts, and somehow survives. Currently, Marxism is under attack by post-Marxist critical theorists and

On Ideology and Education: Critical Pedagogy and the Politics of Empowerment*

Decades of volatile debates over the term ideology have produced a theoretical residue that continues to fleck the landscape of social theory, creating a conceptual terrain at once murky, distortive,

Emergency –A Self Justifying Ideological Tool in a Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry

During last century theorists of power analysis have been struggling to find the answer to the question as to why the class, economically poor and technically less equipped always accept the

History, Politics and Postmodernism: Stuart Hall and Cultural Studies

ion, and the concrete historical context which provides both its object of study and its conditions of existence. This is not merely a political position (although it is that); it is also an



Considerations on Western Marxism

This synoptic essay considers the nature and evolution of the Marxist theory that developed in Western Europe, after the defeat of the proletarian rebellions in the West and the isolation of the

Marxism and the philosophy of language

Translators' Preface, 1986 Author's Introduction, 1929 Guide to Translation Translators' Introduction PART 1: THE PHILOSOPHY OF LANGUAGE AND ITS SIGNIFICANCE FOR MARXISM 1. The Study of Ideologies

Politics and Ideology in Marxist Theory

Seminar Press Editor's Note: This essay originally appeared in Marx: 100 Years On

  • 1971

A Contribution to the Critique of Polilical Economy

  • 1967

Capital, vol. 1, New York: International Publishers Marx, K

  • 1967

Considerations on Western Marxism, London: New Left

  • 1976