• Corpus ID: 156871745

The Positive Law Model of the Fourth Amendment

  title={The Positive Law Model of the Fourth Amendment},
  author={William Baude and James Y. Stern},
  journal={Harvard Law Review},
For fifty years, courts have used a “reasonable expectation of privacy” standard to define “searches” under the Fourth Amendment. As others have recognized, that doctrine is subjective, unpredictable, and conceptually confused, but viable alternatives have been slow to emerge. This Article supplies one.We argue that Fourth Amendment protection should be anchored in background positive law. The touchstone of the search-and-seizure analysis should be whether government officials have done… 
9 Citations

The Sacred Fourth Amendment Text

The Supreme Court’s jurisprudence governing the Fourth Amendment’s “threshold”—a word meant to refer to the types of police actions that trigger the amendment’s warrant and reasonableness

Visible Policing: Technology, Transparency, and Democratic Control

Law enforcement has an opacity problem. Police use sophisticated technologies to monitor individuals, surveil communities, and predict behaviors in increasingly intrusive ways. But legal institutions

Originalism and the Law of the Past

Originalism has long been criticized for its “law office history” and other historical sins. But a recent “positive turn” in originalist thought may help make peace between history and law. On this

Originalism as a Constraint on Judges

One of Justice Antonin Scalia’s greatest legacies was his promotion of constitutional originalism. One important feature of Scalia’s particular arguments for originalism was constraint — the idea

Fourth Amendment Protections of Health Information After Carpenter v. United States: The Devil's In The Database

  • Ryan Knox
  • Law
    American Journal of Law & Medicine
  • 2019
This Article argues that Carpenter v. United States provides additional protections for future searches of health information in private databases, including heightened Fourth Amendment protection for health information.

Inescapable Surveillance

questions bound up with complex technological and sociological issues. Such questions may be especially difficult for courts to resolve effectively.116 Indeed, many lower court rulings on

Location Tracking and Digital Data: Can Carpenter Build a Stable Privacy Doctrine?

In Carpenter v. United States, the Supreme Court struggled to modernize search and seizure law for the digital age. Under longstanding doctrine, government needs only a subpoena rather than search

A Warrant Requirement Resurgence? The Fourth Amendment in the Roberts Court

My article challenges the conventional wisdom that the United States Supreme Court’s Fourth Amendment jurisprudence over the past thirty years is marked by a consistent and continuing decline in the

The Myth of Fourth Amendment Circularity

The Supreme Court’s decision in Katz v. United States made peoples’ reasonable expectations of privacy the touchstone for determining whether state surveillance amounts to a search under the Fourth



Close Enough for Government Work? Heien’s Less-Than-Reasonable Mistake of the Rule of Law

In Heien v. North Carolina, the Supreme Court held 8-1 that a search or seizure can be lawful under the Fourth Amendment despite its being founded on a government agent’s mistake of law, as long as

Beyond DOMA: Choice of State Law in Federal Statutes

The Defense of Marriage Act has been abandoned by the executive and held unconstitutional by courts, so it is time to think about what will be left in its place. Federal law frequently asks whether a

What Constitutes an Arrest within the Meaning of the Fourth Amendment

The word “arrest” cannot be found in the language of the Fourth Amendment. Yet, the fact of an arrest, and the definition of an arrest, is of fundamental importance in applying Fourth Amendment

A Norm-Based Remedial Model for Underinclusive Statutes

After declaring that a statutory provision which distributes benefits to or imposes burdens on some persons but not others violates a constitutional equal treatment requirement, courts must decide

Surveillance Law Through Cyberlaw's Lens

The continuing controversy over the surveillance-related provisions of the USA Patriot Act highlights the depth of Americans' concern about internet privacy. Although calls to limit the government's

Narrowing Supreme Court Precedent from Below

Lower courts supposedly follow Supreme Court precedent—but they often don’t. Instead of adhering to the most persuasive interpretations of the Court’s opinions, lower courts often adopt narrower

A User's Guide to the Stored Communications Act, and a Legislator's Guide to Amending it

Americans care deeply about their Internet privacy. But if they want to know how federal law protects the privacy of their stored Internet communications, they'll quickly learn that it's surprisingly

Theories of Rights

Contents: Recent work on the concept of rights, Rex Martin and James W. Nickel In defence of moral rights, Joel Feinberg On the nature of rights, J. Raz Are there natural rights?, H.L.A. Hart Rights,

The Guardian of Every Other Right: A Constitutional History of Property Rights

Editor's Preface Preface Introduction 1. The Origins of Property Rights: The Colonial Period 2. The Revolutionary Era, 1765-1787 3. "Property Must Be Secured": Establishing a New Constitutional Order

The Drones are Coming! Will the Fourth Amendment Stop Their Threat to Our Privacy?

The use of drones in military operations has become very public. What is less known is that local police have also begun to use drones and are planning to expand their use of to survey communities