The Politics of Surrender: Canadian Soldiers and the Killing of Prisoners in the Great War

  title={The Politics of Surrender: Canadian Soldiers and the Killing of Prisoners in the Great War},
  author={Tim Cook},
  journal={The Journal of Military History},
  pages={637 - 665}
  • T. Cook
  • Published 10 July 2006
  • History, Political Science
  • The Journal of Military History
This article explores the act of surrender on the Western Front during the Great War, focusing on the behavior of Canadian soldiers toward surrendering Germans. Informal rules and symbolic gestures governed actions on the battlefield, and those who successfully negotiated the politics of surrender often survived the murderous first contact between attacking forces. But during the grey area between combat and capitulation, prisoners were frequently executed. The article also examines the… 
The Stigma of Surrender: German Prisoners, British Captors, and Manhood in the Great War and Beyond
Recent scholarship on the history of masculinity has struggled with a difficult question: how did men form ideals of manhood in the traumatic context of total war? While scholars like George Mosse
‘Tokens of Fritz’: Canadian Soldiers and the Art of Souveneering in the Great War
Abstract Canadian soldiers had a fierce reputation for collecting souvenirs on the Western Front in the Great War. Almost every soldier engaged in ‘souveneering’, in the hope of finding trinkets,
Spacial Sanctuaries and Normalizing Violence: The Canadian Soldier on the Western Front during the Great War
Abstract:This essay explores how Canadian soldiers of the Great War created protective spaces and sanctuaries in the front-line trenches of the Western Front to normalize violence. The Western Front
Capturing captivity: Australian prisons of the Great War
Over 4000 Australian soldiers were taken prisoner during the course of the Great War. Their experiences have been largely unexplored. A small number of these men wrote about their experiences, and in
Bereaved and aggrieved: combat motivation and the ideology of sacrifice in the First World War
This article re-examines the role of sacrificial ideology in motivating Germans and Britons to fight between 1914-18. Contrary to current historiography, it contends that the ideology remained
Informing the enemy: Australian prisoners and German intelligence on the Western Front, 1916–1918
This article considers the intelligence value of prisoners captured during the First World War. 3848 troops of the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) were taken prisoner by the German Army on the
Surviving Defeat: battlefield surrender in classical Greece
Abstract The fate of war captives has been extensively explored, as, indeed, has the way that fate affects both the conduct and course of hostilities. Nevertheless, little research has been conducted
Why Do Soldiers Give Up? A Self-Preservation Theory of Surrender
Surrender, or capitulation to the adversary in combat, can have a significant impact on the duration, intensity, and outcomes of battles and wars. Yet the reasons why soldiers choose to capitulate
[Humanities as a means of survival: the testimony of a Siberian prisoner of war in the First World War].
The autobiography of the Croatian chemist and pharmacognosist Antun Vrgoč entitled My Memories of the World War 1914-1920 and published in Zagreb in 1937 shows a striking lack of civilian or military hostility towards the prisoners and the respect of the Geneva Convention.
Order within Anarchy: The Laws of War as an International Institution
1. Introduction 2. Common conjectures, norms, and identities 3. The laws of war in their strategic context 4. Modeling minutia 5. Patterns of compliance with the laws of war during the twentieth


Prisoner Taking and Prisoner Killing in the Age of Total War: Towards a Political Economy of Military Defeat
Compared with the First World War, which ended quite quickly once the position of Germany became strategically hopeless, the Second World War proved exceedingly difficult to end even after the
Death's Men: Soldiers Of The Great War
Death's Men is the classic bestselling story of the First World War as told by the soldiers themselves - reissued for the 2014 Centenary. Millions of British men were involved in the Great War of
An Intimate History of Killing : Face-To-Face Killing in Twentieth-Century Warfare
It is almost universally accepted among writers on warfare that battle is a terrible experience, and that men who fight are at the very least sobered, and often deeply traumatized, by the horrors of
Documenting War and Forging Reputations: Sir Max Aitken and the Canadian War Records Office in the First World War
  • T. Cook
  • Political Science, History
  • 2003
Although the Canadian Corps was one of the finest fighting formations on the Western Front during the First World War and earned a reputation as the shock troops of the British Expeditionary Force,
POWs and the Great War: Captivity on the Eastern Front
List of Figures, Tables and Charts Acknowledgements List of Abbreviations page Introduction...1 Clio's Veil...1 Historiographic Contexts...5 1 Becoming Prisoners of War...45 The Creation of the
Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning: The Great War in European Cultural History
Introduction Part I. Catastrophe and Consolation: 1. Homecomings: the return of the dead 2. Communities in mourning 3. Spiritualism and the 'Lost Generation' 4. War memorials and the mourning process
The Face of Battle
"The Face of Battle" is military history from the battlefield: a look at the direct experience of individuals at the "point of maximum danger." Without the myth-making elements of rhetoric and
The Madman and the Butcher: Sir Sam Hughes, Sir Arthur Currie, and their War of Reputations
  • T. Cook
  • History, Political Science
  • 2004
Canadian Corps commander Sir Arthur Currie is regarded as one of the finest generals of the Great War. Sir Sam Hughes, minister of militia and defence, 19111916, is often portrayed as little more
Death So Noble: Memory, Meaning, and the First World War
This text examines the myriad ways in which Canadians remembered and celebrated their participation in the Great War. Collectively these memories offered explanations and consolations to Canadians
A Lesson in Success: The Calonne Trench Raid, 17 January 1917
Abstract The Allied armies slugged it out on the Western front for nearly four years before finally achieving the breakout sought since November 1914. The four-division strong Canadian Corps led this