The Plight of the Obscure Innovator in Science: A Few Reflections on Campanario's Note

  title={The Plight of the Obscure Innovator in Science: A Few Reflections on Campanario's Note},
  author={Moti Nissani},
  journal={Social Studies of Science},
  pages={165 - 183}
  • Moti Nissani
  • Published 1 February 1995
  • Education
  • Social Studies of Science
The extent of resistance to original contributions of obscure scientists is controversial. Some hold that such resistance is rare, and hence requires little study and no remedy. But others argue that, although not widespread, it happens often enough to merit study and reform. And others again hold it to be common, constituting the single most formidable barrier to scientific advances, and so disturbingly regular as to call for a partial restructuring of the modern scientific enterprise. This… 

Rejecting highly cited papers: The views of scientists who encounter resistance to their discoveries from other scientists

We studied the views of scientists who experience resistance to their new ideas by surveying a sample of 815 scientists who are authors of highly cited articles. The 132 responses (16.2p) received

Suppression of scientific research: Bahramdipity and Nulltiple scientific discoveries

  • T. Sommer
  • Education
    Science and engineering ethics
  • 2001
Examples of non-ideal scientific research and discovery are provided in order to contrast and clarify the meaning and use of bahramdipity.

La ciencia que no enseñamos

Although it is acknowledged that the history and philosophy of science can help in science teaching, an important part of these contents that are included in the curriculum do not take into account

Rejecting and resisting Nobel class discoveries: accounts by Nobel Laureates

I review and discuss instances in which 19 future Nobel Laureates encountered resistance on the part of the scientific community towards their discoveries, and instances that dealt with discoveries that later would earn them the Nobel Prize.

Challenging Dominant Physics Paradigms

There are many well-qualified scientists who question long- established physics theories even when paradigms are not in crisis. Challenging scientific orthodoxy is difficult because most scientists


  • S. Decanio
  • Economics, Political Science
    Social Philosophy and Policy
  • 2021
Abstract This essay examines certain epistemic problems facing administrative states’ efforts to draft efficient regulations for their societies. I argue that a basic feature of the administrative

The Decision-Making Constraints and Processes of Grant Peer Review, and Their Effects on the Review Outcome

When distributing grants, research councils use peer expertise as a guarantee for supporting the best projects. However, there are no clear norms for assessments, and there may be a large variation

The parallelism between scientists' and students' resistance to new scientific ideas

This paper compares resistance by scientists to new ideas in scientific discovery with students' resistance to conceptual change in science learning. First, the resistance by students to abandon



Accommodation of a scientific conception: Toward a theory of conceptual change

It has become a commonplace belief that learning is the result of the interaction between what the student is taught and his current ideas or concepts.’ This is by no means a new view of learning.

Psychological, Historical, and Ethical Reflections on the Mendelian Paradox

Fisher's dispassionate analysis of Mendel's experiments created a storm which, fifty-seven years after the event, shows no signs of subsiding and has received the closest possible attention from a great number of scholars.

History of Western philosophy

''Philosophy' is a word which has been used in many ways, some wider, some narrower. I propose to use it in a very wide sense, which I will now try to explain.' - Bertrand RussellNearly forty years

A cognitive reinterpretation of Stanley Milgram's observations on obedience to authority.

Stanley Milgram's (1974) observations on obedience to authority have exerted a great deal of influence on such diverse disciplines as social psychology, holocaust studies, and political science. In

When Prophecy Fails

In 1954 Leon Festinger, a brilliant young experimental social psychologist in the process of inventing a new theory of human behavior - the theory of cognitive dissonance - and two of his colleagues,

Consolation for the Scientist: Sometimes it is Hard to Publish Papers that are Later Highly-Cited

A set of 316 commentaries by authors of highly-cited papers was reviewed, to identify any difficulty encountered by the authors in producing or publishing their articles: one of them was co-authored by a Nobel Prize winner.

The philosophical basis of peer review and the suppression of innovation.

The fundamental purpose of peer review in the biomedical sciences must be consistent with that of medicine itself, to cure sometimes, to relieve often, to comfort always.

The Role of Anomalous Data in Knowledge Acquisition: A Theoretical Framework and Implications for Science Instruction

There are seven distinct forms of response to anomalous data, only one of which is to accept the data and change theories, and the factors that influence which of these seven forms a scientist or student will choose.

The Blue Nile

Part 1 The reconnaissance: the Blue Nile Don Quixote at the source the way back. Part 2 The French in Africa: Bonaparte sets out the long Egyptian night the march to Cairo the occupation the campaign