The Persuasive Appeal of Alternative Medicine

@article{Kaptchuk1998ThePA,
  title={The Persuasive Appeal of Alternative Medicine},
  author={Ted J. Kaptchuk and David M Eisenberg},
  journal={Annals of Internal Medicine},
  year={1998},
  volume={129},
  pages={1061-1065}
}
The major presence of alternative medicine in western culture has been well documented [1, 2]. Discussion has focused on whether these practices have any biomedical efficacy and on potential adverse consequences. We examined the possibility that the cultural beliefs and contextual practices of alternative medicine frame a pathway of words, behaviors, and experiences that people find persuasive, compelling, and, ultimately, restorative. Shared cultural assumptions may provide a vehicle for an… 

Medicine is Patriarchal, But Alternative Medicine is Not the Answer

TLDR
It is argued that while many patients seek greater autonomy in alternative medicine, the absence of an evidence base and plausible mechanisms of action leaves patients unable to realize meaningful autonomy.

Varieties of Healing. 2: A Taxonomy of Unconventional Healing Practices

TLDR
An overview of alternative medicine in the United States is offered and a new taxonomy that is believed to configures the domains of unconventional medicine across a broader spectrum of health practices is offered.

Weighing the Alternatives: Lessons from the Paradoxes of Alternative Medicine

TLDR
In this issue, Kaptchuk and Eisenberg contribute importantly to the authors' understanding of what makes alternative practices so attractive to patients, and how these alternative approaches can provide important clues to ways in which scientific medicine is seen to be falling short.

Varieties of Healing. 1: Medical Pluralism in the United States

TLDR
This essay examines the specific development of medical pluralism in the United States and chooses the label unconventional or alternative medicine as a generic title for this field of inquiry.

Mesmer, the placebo effect, and the efficacy paradox: lessons for evidence based medicine and complementary and alternative medicine

TLDR
It is argued that the realms of evidence based medicine and complementary and alternative medicine have much to learn from each other, in that one has neglected the vast potential of producing clinical benefit through placebo responses, while the other has neglected the understanding that can be gained through experimentation.

Reflexive Biomedicalization and Alternative Healing Systems

TLDR
This paper challenges this thesis and offers an alternative explanation, arguing that the rise of alternative medicine is a consequence of the success and expanding influence of biomedicine rather than its failure and declining authority.

CAM and EBM: Arguments for Convergence

The expansion of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) during the past two decades has generated many articles in medical journals; and, whether the authors are for or against CAM, the

CAM and EBM: arguments for convergence.

TLDR
This paper looks at points of convergence that might open the way to future coordination, collaboration and integration of complementary and alternative medicine and modernism and postmodernism.

Healing at the Borderland of Medicine and Religion: Regulating Potential Abuse of Authority by Spiritual Healers

TLDR
Use of caring or healing touch is increasingly described as potentially useful in various health care settings, from acute care, to surgery, to obstetrical nursing practice; and Reiki, a Japanese form of energy healing, has even been used in efforts to help survivors recover from torture.

Physicians' Attitudes and Practices Regarding Complementary and Alternative Medicine

TLDR
The findings from an exploratory survey of the beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behaviors of conventionally trained physicians toward CAM revealed that physicians' use or recommendations of CAM in their practices are limited by concerns about medical professional norms, yet are positively associated with their use of computer technology for self-education and communication with peers.
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 86 REFERENCES

Alternative medicine and American religious life

This book upholds that underlying all unorthodox medical systems is a characteristically American strain of religious thought which states that spiritual, physical and economic well-being flow from

Tenacious Assumptions in Western Medicine

While biomedicine has successfully created and hoarded a body of technical knowledge to call its own, its knowledge and practices draw upon a background of tacit understandings that extend far beyond

Elements of Charismatic Persuasion and Healing

Therapeutic efficacy in religious healing is typically analyzed by extrapolating from ritual procedure to expected effect, without specifying conditions for success or failure in terms of the

In what sense is contemporary medicine dualistic?

  • M. Sullivan
  • Medicine
    Culture, medicine and psychiatry
  • 1986
TLDR
This paper seeks to clarify the relationship between disease and illness through an examination of their historical origins and compares the theory of knowledge implicit within this clinico-pathological approach to the body to that of Descartes.

The rhetoric of transformation in ritual healing

  • T. Csordas
  • Psychology
    Culture, medicine and psychiatry
  • 1983
TLDR
An interpretive approach is formulates in which healing is conceived as a form of discourse that is both religious and psychiatric, and which activates and controls healing processes endogenous to the supplicant in healing.

Placebo controls and epistemic control in orthodox medicine.

  • M. Sullivan
  • Medicine
    The Journal of medicine and philosophy
  • 1993
TLDR
The randomized clinical trial (RCT) introduces an epistemic bias into orthodox medicine: therapeutic successes that rely upon a direct link between knowing and healing, such as placebo effects, are discarded in favor of therapeutic successes which rely upon an indirect link betweenKnowing and healing; such as pharmacological interventions.

Advising Patients Who Seek Alternative Medical Therapies

TLDR
A step-by-step approach is proposed whereby medical providers and patients can proactively discuss alternative medical treatments and emphasize patient safety, the need for documentation in the patient record, and the importance of shared decision making.

The Anthropology of Medicine: From Culture to Method

Preface: The Cultural Context of Medicine and the Biohuman Paradigm Medical Systems and the Uses of Choice Creativity in Illness: Methodological Linkages to the Logic and Language of Science in Folk

Culture and clinical care. Folk illness beliefs and behaviors and their implications for health care delivery.

This article presents an approach to the evaluation of patient-held beliefs and behaviors that may not be concordant with those of biomedicine. Physicians and patients often hold discrepant models of
...