The Perils of Proliferation: Organization Theory, Deterrence Theory, and the Spread of Nuclear Weapons

  title={The Perils of Proliferation: Organization Theory, Deterrence Theory, and the Spread of Nuclear Weapons},
  author={Scott Douglas Sagan},
  journal={International Security},
  pages={107 - 66}
  • S. Sagan
  • Published 21 January 1994
  • Political Science
  • International Security
A n apparent contradiction lies at the center of our understandings about nuclear weapons and deterrence. On the one hand, it is widely believed that nuclear weapons were an important factor in maintaining the ”long peace” between the United States and the Soviet Union during the Cold War. The two superpowers avoided war despite a deep geopolitical rivalry, repeated crises, and a prolonged arms race. On the other hand, it is also widely believed that the continuing spread of nuclear weapons… 
Deterrence asymmetry and other challenges to small nuclear forces
Even though nuclear weapons have been around since 1945 the methodology of the maintenance of stable nuclear deterrence is still debated endlessly. The strategy to evolve a stable nuclear deterrence
Counter proliferation, conventional counterforce and Nuclear War
US policymakers and analysts are increasingly pre-occupied by the problem of nuclear proliferation, once considered, in the parlance of the Pentagon, to be a 'lesser included threat' covered by the
Deterring Nuclear Proliferation: Polarity, Credibility, and Preventive War ∗
Since the end of the Cold War, surprisingly few countries have attempted to obtain nuclear weapons. Still, nuclear proliferation has become a focal concern of U.S. foreign-policymakers. Under what
CHAPTER 2 Preventive War and the Spread of Nuclear Programs
What are the consequences of nuclear proliferation?1 Iran’s alleged pursuit of nuclear weapons and North Korea’s nuclear tests in 2006 and 2009 have heightened concerns about the further spread of
Proliferation and International Crisis Behavior
The literature on international conflict is divided on the impact of nuclear proliferation on state conflict. The optimists' argument contends that nuclear weapons raise the stakes so high that
Nuclear Proliferation Through Critical Security Studies
On 5 March 1970, the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) came into force, its preamble articulating international society’s fear not only of the devastation that could already be
Nuclear Deterrence, Preventive War, and Counterproliferation
During the Cold War, the principal function of nuclear weapons was to deter nuclear attack. Nuclear deterrence was not considered a tool of nonproliferation. The primary mechanisms for halting the
No End in Sight: The Continuing Menace of Nuclear Proliferation
The global threat of nuclear weapons is one of today's key policy issues. Using a wide variety of sources, including recently declassified information, Nathan E. Busch offers detailed examinations of
Critical risk and the 2002 Kashmir crisis
How does proliferation affect the risk of war between new nuclear powers like India and Pakistan? Two schools of thought—those of proliferation optimists and pessimists—answer this question in very
Deterrence Now: Deterrence in the post-Cold War world
This chapter offers an overview of how the nature and functions of deterrence in international politics have begun to change, applying themes of preceding chapters to contemporary concerns. To more


A Stable System of Mutual Nuclear Deterrence in the Arab-Israeli Conflict *
Many professional observers have come to the conclusion that, despite denials and technical problems whose solutions are not publicly known, Israel already has nuclear weapons or has completed all
An Assessment of the Merits of Selective Nuclear Proliferation
We assume that in a conflict between a nation with a nuclear capability and one without, the conflict may become nuclear, while, in a conflict between two nuclear powers, the conflict is unlikely to
The Origins of Overkill: Nuclear Weapons and American Strategy, 1945-1960
The history of American milita y policy in the early years of the nuclear age is beginning to be rewritten. The increasing availability of documentary evidence from the 2940s and 2950s enables us to
1914 Revisited: Allies, Offense, and Instability
T h e origins of the First World War continue to be of great interest today because there are a number of striking similarities between the events of 1914 and contemporary fears about paths by which
Proliferation, Deterrence, and the Likelihood of Nuclear War
Two arguments have traditionally been made about the effects of proliferation on the likelihood of nuclear war. One argument claims that proliferation increases the likelihood of nuclear war; the
Engaging the Enemy: Organization Theory and Soviet Military Innovation, 1955-1991
Did a "doctrine race" exist alongside the much-publicized arms competition between East and West? Using recent insights from organization theory, Kimberly Marten Zisk answers this question in the
Nuclear Myths and Political Realities
Two pervasive beliefs have given nuclear weapons a bad name: that nuclear deterrence is highly problematic, and that a breakdown in deterrence would mean Armageddon. Both beliefs are misguided and
Military Culture and Inadvertent Escalation in World War II
"unthinkable" means of warfare be avoided? How can states successfully observe mutually desired limitations on "taboo" forms of combat?' These questions are important because of concern that nuclear,
The Case Against a Ukrainian Nuclear Deterrent
The case for Ukrainian acquisition of nuclear weapons rests fundamentally on two key arguments: first, Ukrainian nuclear weapons will promote peace and stability in a region that might oth erwise be