The Penetration of Technocratic Logic into the Educational Field: Rationalizing Schooling from the Progressives to the Present

  title={The Penetration of Technocratic Logic into the Educational Field: Rationalizing Schooling from the Progressives to the Present},
  author={Jal Mehta},
  journal={Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education},
  pages={1 - 36}
  • Jal Mehta
  • Published 1 May 2013
  • Education
  • Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education
Context No Child Left Behind is only the most recent manifestation of a longstanding American impulse to reform schools through accountability systems created from afar. While research has explored the causes and consequences of No Child Left Behind, this study puts the modern accountability movement in longer historical perspective, seeking to identify broader underlying patterns that shape this approach to reform. Purpose and Research Design The study explores the question of the short and… 

Getting to Scale with Moral Education: The Demands of Reproducibility and the Case of the Chicago Manual Training School, 1884–1904

  • J. McCamant
  • Education
    Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education
  • 2018
Background Getting educational reforms “to scale” continues to be a primary preoccupation of scholars, but such studies tend to remain focused on the organizational or other characteristics of the

Power to the People? Populism and the Politics of School Choice in the United States

ABSTRACT I use the definition of populism as a discursive frame to consider the extent to which the politics of school choice in the United States have been populist. This analysis offers a novel way

Journal of Educational Administration Emerald Article: School administration in a changing education sector: the US experience

Examination of the entailments of shifts in the policy environment for school administrative practice, focusing on how school leaders manage in the middle between this shifting external policy environment and classroom teachers, reflects the times and a US educational governance system characterized by local control.

Normal Schools Revisited: A Theoretical Reinterpretation of the Historiography of Normal Schools

This article provides a theory-driven account of the emergence, development, and ultimate disappearance of the normal school as a unique institutional form within higher education. To that end, this

How Paradigms Create Politics

American educational policy was rapidly transformed between 1980 and 2001. Accountability was introduced into a sphere that had long been loosely coupled, both major political parties reevaluated

Plexiglass: how power, policy and politics create a mirage of equitable family engagement

Purpose Power, policy and politics set the landscape for technocratic approaches in the educational system. Efficiency and money-saving initiatives that adhere to a one-size-fits-all approach drive

Leveraging critical literacies for social change: questioning the culture of compliance at an ‘F’ school

Abstract This article traces the experiences of two veteran elementary school teachers in the urban Southwest, who are positioned by district and state policy ‘texts’ as insubordinate and failing,

Moral Professional Agency: A Framework for Exploring Teachers’ Constructions of Professionalism Within a Democratic Space

Despite long-standing debates about the nature of professions and professionalism related to teaching, little consensus has been reached due in large part to an ever-changing political climate and a

Ideological Call to Arms: Analyzing Institutional Contradictions in Political Party Discourse on Education and Accountability Policy, 1952–2012

Abstract Despite a legacy of research that emphasizes contradictions and their role in explaining change, less is understood about their character or the mechanisms that support them. This gap is

Accountability and “Racing to the Top” in New York State: A Report from the Frontlines

Background & Purpose This article focuses on the current educational reform movement in New York State resulting from the state's receipt of $700 million in Race to the Top (RTTT) money.



The paradox of progressive education: A frame analysis

The term progressive education, although widely used, encompasses a broad and contradictory range of ideas and reforms. Historians dispute its definition, and many deem the term to be paradoxical On

A Nation Reformed? American Education 20 Years After A Nation at Risk

be sent to There are no children in school today whose education is not shaped by A Nation At Risk. This report has profoundly affected the way policymakers view education today. With

Below the Bubble: “Educational Triage” and the Texas Accountability System

This article uses two dominant traditions in the organizational study of schools—the neoinstitutional and faculty workplace approaches—to explain an urban elementary school’s response to the Texas

Ideas, private institutions and American welfare state ‘exceptionalism’: the case of health and old‐age insurance, 1915–1965

Traditional theories of welfare state development divide into two camps: societal accounts and institutional accounts. The aim of the present article is to amend and enrich the institutional approach

Politics, Markets, and America's Schools

During the 1980s, widespread dissatisfaction with America's schools gave rise to a powerful movement for educational change, and the nation's political institutions responded with aggressive reforms.

Systemic school reform

This analytic essay draws on research about the effectiveness of current education policies as well as observations about developing policy systems in a number of states. The chapter begins with

Policy paradigms, social learning, and the state: the case of economic policymaking in Britain

This article examines the model of social learning often believed to confirm the autonomy of the state from social pressures, tests it against recent cases of change in British economic policies, and

The Shame of the Nation: The Restoration of Apartheid Schooling in America

ask why parents opt for Catholic schools when their own practice is not always informed by participation in Church, and likewise, without the support of government subsidies to fund their children’s

Reforming Again, Again, and Again

Why do reforms return again and again? To illustrate that the question is valid, I offer three examples drawn from instructional, curricular, and governance planned changes that have returned more

The Political Power of Economic Ideas: Keynesianism across Nations

John Maynard Keynes once observed that the "ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood." The