The New Era of Counterforce: Technological Change and the Future of Nuclear Deterrence

  title={The New Era of Counterforce: Technological Change and the Future of Nuclear Deterrence},
  author={Keir A. Lieber and Daryl G. Press},
  journal={International Security},
Nuclear deterrence rests on the survivability of nuclear arsenals. For much of the nuclear age, “counterforce” disarming attacks—those aimed at eliminating an opponent's nuclear forces—were nearly impossible because of the ability of potential victims to hide and protect their weapons. Technological developments, however, are eroding this foundation of nuclear deterrence. Advances rooted in the computer revolution have made nuclear forces around the world considerably more vulnerable… 
Nuclear Deterrence in a New Age of Disruptive Technologies and Great Power Competition
An increasingly dangerous ‘second nuclear age’ is threatening the survival of humankind as geopolitical competition increases between established nuclear powers, unstable ‘rogue states’ and
Nuclear warfare beyond counterforce
Abstract A counterforce attack intends to disable an opponent's nuclear arsenal to limit potential damage from that adversary. We postulate a future when hardening and deeply burying fixed sites,
Emerging technology and nuclear security: What does the wisdom of the crowd tell us?
ABSTRACT What is the impact of emerging technologies on nuclear security and disarmament? Current rapid technological advances are taking place against the backdrop of increased investments in
Disrupting Deterrence: Examining the Effects of Technologies on Strategic Deterrence in the 21st Century
In potential military applications, cyber warfare and EW capabilities arguably possess the most-direct and well-demonstrated security effects of all eight technology areas. Information security and
A study on the development and implications of low-yield nuclear weapons, focusing on deterrence theory
  • Sung-Young Moon
  • Political Science
    Journal of Advances in Military Studies
  • 2021
This study aims to examine the development status and technical characteristics of low-yield nuclear weapons initiated by the Trump administration, predict the development trend in the Biden
Strategy in the New Era of Tactical Nuclear Weapons
Post–Cold War strategic discourse, primarily among Russian strategists, has challenged the precept that nuclear weapons are not useful tools of warfare or statecraft. To reduce the likelihood that
Correspondence: New Era or New Error? Technology and the Future of Deterrence
In their recent article, Keir Lieber and Daryl Press argue that enhanced counterforce capabilities are increasingly threatening the survivability of nuclear forces.1 They do not, however, provide a
Strategic non-nuclear weapons and the onset of a Third Nuclear Age
Abstract Three decades after what is widely referred to as the transition from a First to a Second Nuclear Age, the world stands on the cusp of a possible Third Nuclear Age where the way that we
The MAD Who Wasn't There: Soviet Reactions to the Late Cold War Nuclear Balance
ABSTRACT What do nuclear weapons mean for the stability of the military balance? Mutually assured destruction (MAD) describes a stalemated balance of power where nuclear adversaries possess
Counterforce Dilemmas and the Risk of Nuclear War in East Asia
  • Ian Bowers
  • Economics
    Journal for Peace and Nuclear Disarmament
  • 2022
ABSTRACT The discovery of new Chinese nuclear missile silos, a seemingly escalating nuclear-conventional arms competition between the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) and the Republic of


The Rise of U.S. Nuclear Primacy
FOR ALMOST half a century, the world's most powerful nuclear states have been locked in a military stalemate known as mutual assured destruction (MAD). By the early 196os, the nuclear arsenals ofthe
Sea changes: The future of nuclear deterrence
ABSTRACT In order to deter adversaries, a nuclear-armed power must deploy an invulnerable second-strike force; its leadership must display the willingness to use that force under certain well-defined
Why Nuclear Superiority Doesn't Matter
Recent debates on the role of nuclear weapons in American defense policy have not clarified the important issues or dealt with the underlying assumptions that are involved. While some of the
Analyzing Strategic Nuclear Policy
With sweeping changes in the Soviet Union and East Europe having shaken core assumptions of U.S. defense policy, it is time to reassess basic questions of American nuclear strategy and force
The Consequences of "Limited" Nuclear Attacks on the United States
A n all-out nuclear war between the United States and the Soviet Union would destroy the urban areas of both countries and thereby the infrastructure that makes them modern industrial states. This
The Effects of Nuclear War
measures of strategic power into more comprehensible terms. ” The study examines the full range of effects that nuclear war would have on civilians: direct effects from blast and radiation; and
Would China Go Nuclear? Assessing the Risk of Chinese Nuclear Escalation in a Conventional War with the United States
Could a conventional war with the United States inadvertently prompt Chinese nuclear escalation? The military-technical threat that such a war would pose to China's retaliatory capability—combined
Should the United States Reject MAD? Damage Limitation and U.S. Nuclear Strategy toward China
As China invests in its nuclear forces and U.S.-China relations become increasingly strained, questions of U.S. nuclear doctrine require greater attention. The key strategic nuclear question facing
The End of MAD? The Nuclear Dimension of U.S. Primacy
For nearly half a century, the world's most powerful nuclear-armed states have been locked in a condition of mutual assured destruction. Since the end of the Cold War, however, the nuclear balance
Why States Won't Give Nuclear Weapons to Terrorists
Many experts consider nuclear terrorism the single greatest threat to U.S. security. The fear that a state might transfer nuclear materials to terrorists was a core justification for the invasion of