The Negative Side of Positive Psychology

  title={The Negative Side of Positive Psychology},
  author={Barbara S. Held},
  journal={Journal of Humanistic Psychology},
  pages={46 - 9}
  • B. Held
  • Published 2004
  • Psychology
  • Journal of Humanistic Psychology
This article explores three ways in which the positive psychology movement’s construction and presentation of itself are negative. First, the negative side is construed as the negative side effects of positive psychology’s dominant, separatist message. Second, the negative side is construed as the negativity that can be found within the positive psychology movement. Here the author elaborates on the negative or dismissive reactions of some spokespersons for the movement to ideas or views that… Expand
Second Wave Positive Psychology: Exploring the Positive–Negative Dialectics of Wellbeing
Positive psychology has tended to be defined in terms of a concern with ‘positive’ psychological qualities and states. However, critics of the field have highlighted various problems inherent inExpand
Positive Psychology’s A Priori Problem
The positive/negative distinction works well in many fields—for example, in mathematics negative numbers hold their own, and in medical pathology negative results are usually celebrated. But inExpand
Skinner's Walden Two: An Anticipation of Positive Psychology?
B. F. Skinner's, 1948 novel, Walden Two has some remarkable parallels to the growing Positive Psychology movement which emphasizes the promotion of subjective well being, the development of characterExpand
Negative Reflections About Positive Psychology: On Constraining the Field to a Focus on Happiness and Personal Achievement
“Positive” psychology has gained a dominant voice within and outside the field of psychology. Although critiques of this perspective have been rendered, including by humanistic psychologists,Expand
Flourishing as a dialectical balance: emerging insights from second-wave positive psychology
Positive psychology, an emergent branch of scholarship concerned with wellbeing and flourishing, initially defined itself by a focus on “positive” emotions and qualities. However, critics soonExpand
Positive Psychology, Existential Psychology, and the Presumption of Egoism
Positive psychology and existential psychology are commonly thought to reflect radically different perspectives on the deep questions of human nature, what constitutes legitimate psychologicalExpand
Positive psychology 2.0: Towards a balanced interactive model of the good life.
This paper first describes the growing pains and challenges of the positive psychology (PP) movement and identifies the four pillars of the good life as meaning, virtue, resilience, and well-being,Expand
What is the Good Life? Positive Psychology and the Renaissance of Humanistic Psychology
Positive and humanistic psychology overlap in thematic content and theoretical presuppositions, yet positive psychology explicitly distances itself as a new movement, despite the fact that itsExpand
Positive Psychology: A Foucauldian Critique
This article analyzes and critiques some of the “truth claims” of positive psychology by applying Foucault's concepts of power/knowledge, discipline, and governmentality. It illustrates how positiveExpand
Positive psychology has been the subject of passionate attacks. Its novelty, its scientific scope, its intentions and even the honesty of its followers have been questioned. Furthermore, byExpand


The power of negative thinking: Truth, melancholia, and the tragic sense of life.
In this brief essay I argue that the contemporary “positive psychology” movement fails to emphasize important aspects of human existence that are essential to human excellence. Through an explicationExpand
The tyranny of the positive attitude in America: observation and speculation.
  • B. Held
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2002
Cross-cultural empirical research is presented that calls into question the typical (North American) assumption that a positive attitude is necessary for (a sense of) well-being, and findings in health psychology, clinical/counseling psychology, and organizational behavioral science are considered. Expand
Handbook of positive psychology
Psychology has long been enamored of the dark side of human existence, rarely exploring a more positive view of the mind. What has psychology contributed, for example, to our understanding of theExpand
The Humanistic Psychology and Positive Psychology Connection: Implications for Psychotherapy
This article explores the common ground between positive and humanistic psychology and responds to positive psychology’s challenges to humanistic psychology about research and a concern for socialExpand
Positive Psychology and Humanistic Psychology: A Reply to Seligman
Arguments in the current debate between “positive psychology” and humanistic psychology are reviewed with particular emphasis on Martin Seligman’s comment that humanistic psychologists do notExpand
Positive psychology. An introduction.
The authors outline a framework for a science of positive psychology, point to gaps in the authors' knowledge, and predict that the next century will see a science and profession that will come to understand and build the factors that allow individuals, communities, and societies to flourish. Expand
The positive psychology of negative thinking.
The use of defensive pessimism research is used to illustrate that there are times when pessimism and negative thinking are indeed positive psychology, as they lead to better performance and personal growth. Expand
Positive Psychology: A Clinical Behavior Analytic Perspective
Psychology has focused too much on reducing symptoms of distress and ameliorating behavioral problems rather than attending to the rewarding, engaging, and good side of human life. This articleExpand
Toward a Psychology of Optimal Human Functioning: What Positive Psychology Can Learn from the “Experiential Turns” of James, Dewey, and Maslow
Past perspectives on optimal functioning and experience are discussed to inform current epistemological debates in humanistic and positive psychology. It is suggested that William James, John Dewey,Expand
Illusion and well-being: a social psychological perspective on mental health.
Research suggesting that certain illusions may be adaptive for mental health and well-being is reviewed, examining evidence that a set of interrelated positive illusions—namely, unrealistically positive self-evaluations, exaggerated perceptions of control or mastery, and unrealistic optimism—can serve a wide variety of cognitive, affective, and social functions. Expand