The Nature of Light and Twentieth Century Experimental Physics

  title={The Nature of Light and Twentieth Century Experimental Physics},
  author={S. Sulcs},
  journal={Foundations of Science},
  • S. Sulcs
  • Published 2003
  • Physics
  • Foundations of Science
In the popular literature of physics the electromagnetic field isoften treated as though it has an intrinsic particle nature. When thetheory is examined carefully, quantum theory only makes the weakerrequirement that the emission and absorption of light are restricted todiscrete amounts of energy. There are very few realizable experiments inoptics for which the classical Maxwell theory and the quantum theorymake a different prediction. I discuss some of these experiments with anemphasis on the… Expand
Surely You Must All be Joking: An Outsider's Critique of Quantum Physics
A critique of the state of current quantum theory in physics is presented, based on a perspective outside the normal physics training. From this perspective, the acceptance of quantum nonlocalityExpand
Surely You Must All be Joking : An Outsider ’ s Critique of the Current State of Quantum Physics
A critique of the state of current quantum theory in physics is presented, based on a perspective outside the normal physics training. From this perspective, the acceptance of quantum nonlocalityExpand
A QED-compatible wave theory of light, electrons, and their interactions
The photoelectric effect, the Compton effects, and now anticorrelation experiments have been claimed to prove that light consists of particles flying through a void. However the particle model isExpand
The Locality of the Superposition Principle Is Dictated by Detection Processes
Both classical and quantum physics thrive on the superposition principle (SP), yet the first one takes it as a local effect and the second one assumes it as a non-local phenomenon. We take SP as aExpand
Understanding quantum mechanics: a review and synthesis in precise language
This review is broad in scope, and aims to reflect enough of the literature to be representative of the current state of the subject, and to contribute to achieving greater consensus on how to understand quantum mechanics. Expand
What are the processes behind energy re-direction and re-distribution in interference and diffraction?
The interpretation of the detection of very slow rate of photo counts in interference and diffraction experiments have given rise to the prevailing interpretation that photons interfere by themselvesExpand
The Photoelectric Effect: Reconstructing the Story for the Physics Classroom
The photoelectric effect is commonly used as the introductory topic for the study of quantum physics. However, a literature review reveals that besides various weaknesses and errors in theExpand
If superposed light beams do not re-distribute each others energy in the absence of detectors (material dipoles), can an indivisible single photon interfere by/with itself?
The intention of this paper is to underscore that to understand fundamentally new properties of light beams, we must first find the limits of semi classical model to explain optical interferenceExpand
Herch Moysés Nussenzveig e a ótica quântica: consolidando disciplinas através de escolas de verão e livros-texto
The field of optics was shaken by the invention of the laser and by the new technical and theoretical developments that took place during the 1960s, resulting in a discontinuity in the field and theExpand
On the Philosophical Nature of Einstein’s Mass-Energy Equivalence Formula $$E=mc^{2}$$E=mc2
The historical development of the famous Einstein formula $$E=mc^{2}$$E=mc2 is briefly discussed. In this paper, on the basis of the Einstein viewpoint a new general approach is proposed forExpand


Localization of Photons
In a popular quantum mechanics textbook one reads … “If we have some indications that classical wave theory is macroscopically correct, it is nevertheless clear that on the microscopic level only theExpand
Stochastic Electrodynamics and the Bell Inequalities
The basic ideas of stochastic electrodynamics are presented. In the light of these ideas, some general differences between quantum mechanics and local realistic theories are pointed out. TheExpand
QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter
Famous the world over for the creative brilliance of his insights into the physical world, Nobel Prize-winning physicist Richard Feynman also possessed an extraordinary talent for explainingExpand
Stochastic optics: A reaffirmation of the wave nature of light
Quantum optics does not give a local explanation of the coincidence counts in spatially separated photodetectors. This is the case for a wide variety of phenomena, including the anticorrelatedExpand
Atomic Physics Tests of the Basic Concepts in Quantum Mechanics
Publisher Summary Quantum mechanics is the theory used to describe microscopic systems such as atoms, molecules, and elementary particles. It grew early in this century from a synthesis of Planck'sExpand
Two slit interference-classical and quantum pictures
Young's double-slit experiment demonstrates clearly the propagation of light in the form of a wave motion. Common attempts at a quantized picture of the experiment tend to describe light in terms ofExpand
The polarization correlation of photons emitted in an atomic cascade is treated in the framework of a general semiclassical radiation theory. These predictions are contrasted with those of orthodoxExpand
Comment on “Experimental Evidence for a Photon Anticorrelation Effect on a Beam Splitter: a New Light on Single-Photon Interferences”
A recent experiment by Grangier, Roger and Aspect is discussed. It is shown that, contrary to the too general claim by the authors, the results are compatible with classical wave models of light,Expand
Survey of the Present Status of Neoclassical Radiation Theory
Present quantum electrodynamics (QED) contains many very important “elements of truth”, but also some clear “elements of nonsense”. Because of the divergences and ambiguities, there is generalExpand
The Quantum Theory of Light
Preface 1. Planck's radiation law and the Einstein coefficients 2. Quantum mechanics of the atom-radiation interaction 3. Classical theory of optical fluctuations and coherence 4. Quantization of theExpand